SUPERNOVA EJECTA IN THE YOUNGEST GALACTIC SUPERNOVA REMNANT G1.9+0.3

Kazimierz J. Borkowski, Stephen P. Reynolds, Una Hwang, David A. Green, Robert Petre, Kalyani Krishnamurthy, Rebecca WillettThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses long-term Chandra X-ray observations of the youngest known supernova remnant, G1.9+0.3, to map the distribution of heavy elements ejected by the explosion. The findings reveal a highly asymmetric distribution of elements like iron, silicon, and sulfur, strongly suggesting that the supernova itself was not spherical but rather a violent, asymmetric event.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Supernovae, the explosive deaths of stars, are crucial for creating and dispersing heavy elements into the universe. Understanding the explosion mechanism of a supernova is key to understanding the origin of these elements. G1.9+0.3 is the youngest supernova remnant in our galaxy, offering a unique, early-stage glimpse into the aftermath of a stellar explosion. Previous observations hinted at the presence of thermal emission from ejecta, but lacked the detail to map the distribution of specific elements. This paper aims to precisely map the spatial distribution and relative abundances of key heavy elements (silicon, sulfur, and iron) within the ejecta of G1.9+0.3 to constrain the explosion physics of the progenitor star. Specifically, it addresses the surprising presence of high-velocity iron-group elements, which are not commonly observed in typical supernova models.

Methods

The researchers utilized a long (980 ks) Chandra X-ray observation of G1.9+0.3. To analyze the data, they employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Denoising and Spatial Localization: They used a spatio-spectral denoising method (Krishnamurthy et al. 2010) to improve the signal-to-noise ratio of the X-ray data. Subsequently, a continuous wavelet transform method (Du et al. 2006) was applied to spatially pinpoint the locations of thermal emission from specific elements. This technique is particularly useful for isolating faint spectral lines from background noise.
  2. Spectral Analysis: Once regions of interest were identified, X-ray spectra were extracted and analyzed using the XSPEC software package. They fitted these spectra with models that account for plasma emission from shocked ejecta, including absorbed power-law continua and Gaussian lines to represent spectral features. They specifically focused on identifying emission lines from silicon (Si), sulfur (S), and iron (Fe) Kα lines, as well as considering the possibility of 44Sc and 44Ti.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from a long Chandra X-ray observation of G1.9+0.3, totaling 977 ks, conducted in May and July of 2011. This observation utilized the ACIS S3 chip in Very Faint mode. The data reduction and spectral extraction were performed using CIAO v4.5 and CALDBv4.5.1. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focuses on analyzing existing observational data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Extreme Asymmetry in Ejecta: The most striking finding is the highly asymmetric distribution of heavy elements. Iron, in particular, is concentrated in the northern rim, while the western rim shows silicon and sulfur but a notable absence of iron. This directly challenges the idea of a spherically symmetric supernova explosion.
  • High-Velocity Iron-Group Elements: The detection of iron at high velocities (greater than 18,000 km/s) is surprising. This suggests that the progenitor star ejected these elements with significant kinetic energy, pointing towards an energetic explosion mechanism.
  • Undiluted Fe-Group Elements: In a specific region of the northern rim, intermediate-mass elements (IMEs) are less abundant than iron. This implies that undiluted iron-group elements, possibly including 56Ni, were ejected at high speeds.
  • O-Burning Products: The presence of silicon and sulfur-rich ejecta without iron in the inner west rim indicates that high-velocity products from oxygen burning were also ejected.
  • Connection to Energetic Type Ia SNe: The observed characteristics, particularly the high-velocity iron-group elements, align with observations of energetic Type Ia supernovae like SN 2010jn.
  • Implications for Explosion Models: The pronounced asymmetry strongly supports models of asymmetric supernova explosions, such as 3D delayed-detonation Type Ia models, where the explosion is not uniform in all directions.

Key Results

  • Spatially resolved spectroscopy revealed that the distribution of intermediate-mass elements (Si, S) and iron (Fe) in G1.9+0.3 is extremely asymmetric.
  • The strongest ejecta emission, particularly for Fe Kα, is observed in the northern rim.
  • Fits to thermal models indicate strongly oversolar Fe abundances in the northern rim.
  • In a localized region of the northern rim, IMEs are less abundant than Fe, suggesting the ejection of undiluted Fe-group elements.
  • In the inner west rim, Si- and S-rich ejecta were found without traces of Fe, indicating the ejection of high-velocity products of O-burning.
  • The inferred shocked mass of ejecta is significantly larger than previously estimated, suggesting that the continuum emission might not be purely thermal.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Continuum Emission Uncertainty: The authors note that the assumption of a thermal continuum for the X-ray emission might be incorrect, potentially affecting the accuracy of mass and abundance estimates, especially for iron. They suggest that a nonthermal continuum might be more appropriate.
  • Model Dependence: While the findings strongly favor asymmetric explosion models, the precise details of these models and their ability to reproduce the observed ejecta distribution require further investigation.
  • Radio Emission Origin: The paper discusses the possibility of positron contribution to the radio flux from 56Co decay but concludes it's unlikely to explain the radio maximum in the northern rim, suggesting further radio observations are needed.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for future 3D hydrodynamical simulations of asymmetric Type Ia explosions, followed by modeling of their interaction with the interstellar medium. They also highlight the importance of studying other young supernova remnants exhibiting similar large-scale asymmetries in their Fe-rich ejecta to better understand Type Ia explosions and their progenitors.

Summary updated

Abstract

G1.9+0.3 is the youngest known Galactic supernova remnant (SNR), with an estimated supernova (SN) explosion date of approximately 1900, and most likely located near the Galactic Center. Only the outermost ejecta layers with free-expansion velocities (is) approximately greater than 18,000 km s-1 have been shocked so far in this dynamically young, likely Type Ia SNR. A long (980 ks) Chandra observation in 2011 allowed spatially-resolved spectroscopy of heavy-element ejecta. We denoised Chandra data with the spatio-spectral method of Krishnamurthy et al., and used a wavelet based technique to spatially localize thermal emission produced by intermediate-mass elements (IMEs: Si and S) and iron. The spatial distribution of both IMEs and Fe is extremely asymmetric, with the strongest ejecta emission in the northern rim. Fe K alpha emission is particularly prominent there, and fits with thermal models indicate strongly oversolar Fe abundances. In a localized, outlying region in the northern rim, IMEs are less abundant than Fe, indicating that undiluted Fe-group elements (including 56Ni) with velocities greater than 18,000 km s-1 were ejected by this SN. But in the inner west rim, we find Si- and S-rich ejecta without any traces of Fe, so high-velocity products of O-burning were also ejected. G1.9+0.3 appears similar to energetic Type Ia SNe such as SN 2010jn where iron-group elements at such high free-expansion velocities have been recently detected. The pronounced asymmetry in the ejecta distribution and abundance inhomogeneities are best explained by a strongly asymmetric SN explosion, similar to those produced in some recent 3D delayed-detonation Type Ia models.
BibTeX
@article{borkowski2013supernova,
  author = {Kazimierz J. Borkowski and Stephen P. Reynolds and Una Hwang and David A. Green and Robert Petre and Kalyani Krishnamurthy and Rebecca Willett},
  title = {{SUPERNOVA EJECTA IN THE YOUNGEST GALACTIC SUPERNOVA REMNANT G1.9+0.3}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1088/2041-8205/771/1/l9},
}
Figure