Superior photo-carrier diffusion dynamics in organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites revealed by spatiotemporal conductivity imaging

Xuejian Ma, Fei Zhang, Zhaodong Chu, Ji Hao, Xihan Chen, Jiamin Quan, Zhiyuan Huang, Xiaoming Wang, Xiaoqin Li, Yanfa Yan, Kai Zhu, Keji LaiNature Communications 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a novel imaging technique to visualize how electrons and holes move within perovskite solar cells, revealing that their differing lifetimes are cleverly balanced by their mobilities. This intricate interplay explains the excellent performance of these next-generation solar materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Organic-inorganic hybrid perovskite solar cells (PSCs) have shown remarkable promise, achieving power conversion efficiencies over 25%. A key factor in their success is the excellent photo-physical properties of both electrons and holes within the material. However, understanding the precise dynamics of these charge carriers – how long they live and how far they travel – is crucial for further improving PSC performance. Previous studies often relied on indirect methods or couldn't simultaneously probe both spatial and temporal aspects of carrier behavior. This paper aims to directly visualize and quantify the diffusion dynamics of individual electrons and holes in Cs-doped formamidinium lead triiodide (FACsPbI₃) thin films, a material known for its stability and excellent light absorption.

Methods

The researchers employed a technique called spatiotemporal conductivity imaging, specifically microwave impedance microscopy (iMIM). This technique combines optical excitation with electrical probing at high spatial (20-50 nm) and temporal (10 ns) resolutions.

Here's how it works:

  • Optical Pump: A pulsed laser illuminates the perovskite film, generating electron-hole pairs.
  • Electrical Probe: A sharp microwave tip scans across the sample surface, measuring changes in its impedance. This impedance change is directly related to the local photoconductivity.
  • Spatiotemporal Imaging: By scanning the tip and analyzing the signal over time, the researchers can create maps of how conductivity (and thus charge carrier density) changes in both space and time.

To distinguish between electron and hole dynamics, they used charge transport layers:

  • HTL (Hole Transport Layer): A PTAA layer was added to rapidly extract photo-generated holes, allowing the measurement of electron dynamics.
  • ETL (Electron Transport Layer): A TiO₂ layer was added to rapidly extract photo-generated electrons, allowing the measurement of hole dynamics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental measurements performed on synthesized FACsPbI₃ thin films.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Balancing Act: The most striking finding is how disparate electron and hole lifetimes are compensated by their differing mobilities. This creates a surprisingly balanced diffusion dynamic, crucial for efficient charge extraction.
  • Intrinsic Lifetimes: The two observed relaxation times (around 1 µs and 10 µs) are intrinsic to the FACsPbI₃ material, independent of the excitation wavelength.
  • Grain Boundaries Don't Hinder: Despite the presence of numerous grain boundaries, the carrier diffusion was found to be largely unimpeded, suggesting that these specific grain boundaries are not significant recombination centers.
  • Direct Measurement: This work provides a direct, simultaneous measurement of diffusion length, carrier lifetime, and charge mobility for both electrons and holes within the same material batch, a significant advancement over previous studies.

Key Results

  • Diffusion Lengths: The diffusion lengths for both electrons and holes were found to be comparable, in the range of 3-5 µm. Specifically, electron diffusion length (Lₑ) was ~5.2 µm and hole diffusion length (L<0xE2><0x82><0x95>) was ~2.7 µm in the HTL/ETL samples.
  • Lifetimes: Two distinct relaxation times were observed: a fast component (τ₁) around 0.7 µs and a slow component (τ₂) around 10 µs. These were attributed to electron and hole lifetimes, respectively.
  • Mobility: The study revealed a significant difference in mobility, with electrons being much more mobile (μ<0xE2><0x82><0x91> ≈ 15 cm²/V·s) than holes (μ<0xE2><0x82><0x95> ≈ 0.3 cm²/V·s). This disparity is a key factor in the overall balanced diffusion.
  • Power Dependence: At higher illumination intensities, the diffusion length showed a more complex power dependence, with electron diffusion length decreasing and hole diffusion length increasing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Dependence: The authors acknowledge that sample-to-sample variation is common in PSC research, and it's possible that grain boundaries in other perovskite films might have stronger impacts.
  • Theoretical Elucidation: While a qualitative explanation for the differing lifetimes and mobilities is proposed based on deep-level defects (iodine interstitials), further theoretical work is needed for a quantitative understanding.
  • Future Experiments: The authors suggest future experiments to compare photoluminescence and photoconductivity imaging results across multiple grains, which could provide further insights. They also highlight the need for more detailed theoretical work to fully elucidate the observed phenomena.

Summary updated

Abstract

The outstanding performance of organic-inorganic metal trihalide solar cells benefits from the exceptional photo-physical properties of both electrons and holes in the material. Here, we directly probe the free-carrier dynamics in Cs-doped FAPbI<sub>3</sub> thin films by spatiotemporal photoconductivity imaging. Using charge transport layers to selectively quench one type of carriers, we show that the two relaxation times on the order of 1 μs and 10 μs correspond to the lifetimes of electrons and holes in FACsPbI<sub>3</sub>, respectively. Strikingly, the diffusion mapping indicates that the difference in electron/hole lifetimes is largely compensated by their disparate mobility. Consequently, the long diffusion lengths (3~5 μm) of both carriers are comparable to each other, a feature closely related to the unique charge trapping and de-trapping processes in hybrid trihalide perovskites. Our results unveil the origin of superior diffusion dynamics in this material, crucially important for solar-cell applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2021superior,
  author = {Xuejian Ma and Fei Zhang and Zhaodong Chu and Ji Hao and Xihan Chen and Jiamin Quan and Zhiyuan Huang and Xiaoming Wang and Xiaoqin Li and Yanfa Yan and Kai Zhu and Keji Lai},
  title = {{Superior photo-carrier diffusion dynamics in organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites revealed by spatiotemporal conductivity imaging}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-25311-1},
}
Figure