Superior Guarantees for Sequential Prediction and Lossless Compression via Alphabet Decomposition

Ron Begleiter, Ran El-YanivJMLR 2006

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new theoretical framework and a novel algorithm called DECO for sequential prediction and lossless compression, particularly for multi-alphabet sequences. It provides the first rigorous worst-case performance guarantees for this approach, showing it to be superior to existing methods, especially for sparse alphabets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting the next symbol in a sequence and compressing data are fundamental tasks with deep connections. While many algorithms exist, understanding their performance on finite, potentially small, datasets has been a challenge. For multi-alphabet sequences (where symbols can be from a large set, like characters in text), existing methods like the Context Tree Weighting (CTW) algorithm, while effective for binary sequences, struggle to achieve state-of-the-art performance. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a hierarchical decomposition approach (DECO) that breaks down multi-alphabet prediction into a series of binary prediction problems, offering theoretical guarantees and demonstrating practical advantages.

Methods

The core of the paper is the DECO algorithm, which tackles multi-alphabet prediction by decomposing the problem hierarchically. It uses a decomposition tree where each internal node represents a binary prediction problem. These binary problems are solved using a slight variation of the Context Tree Weighting (CTW) algorithm. The paper also introduces decomposed sources as a theoretical tool to analyze the DECO algorithm and establishes equivalences between decomposed sources and standard tree sources. A key contribution is deriving a worst-case redundancy bound for DECO, particularly when using a Huffman coding tree as the decomposition structure. This bound is shown to be tighter than existing bounds for multi-CTW.

Datasets

The authors evaluated their algorithms using the Calgary Corpus, a standard benchmark for lossless compression and prediction. This corpus consists of 18 files of various types, including English texts, binary files, and source code. They also used a reduced version of the Calgary Corpus for some experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hierarchical Decomposition is Key: Breaking down complex multi-alphabet prediction into simpler binary problems via a tree structure is a powerful strategy.
  • DECO Outperforms Multi-CTW for Sparse Alphabets: The theoretical bounds and experimental results suggest that DECO's performance degrades more gracefully than multi-CTW when alphabet symbols are sparse, meaning some symbols appear infrequently.
  • Huffman Trees Provide a Good Heuristic: While finding the optimal decomposition tree is NP-hard, using a Huffman coding tree (based on symbol frequencies) provides a strong, theoretically justified heuristic that leads to tight bounds.
  • Theoretical Guarantees Justify Practical Success: The paper provides the first rigorous worst-case redundancy bounds for DECO, offering a compelling explanation for its observed empirical success.

Key Results

  • The paper provides the first worst-case redundancy bound for the DECO algorithm.
  • For Huffman decomposition trees, the derived bound is shown to be tighter than the best known bounds for multi-CTW, especially for sufficiently long sequences and large alphabets (k ≥ 118).
  • Experimental results on the Calgary Corpus show that the "Improved" DECO algorithm (which heuristically optimizes the decomposition tree) achieves statistically significant performance improvements over the standard Huffman decomposition.
  • The DECO algorithm, even with a random tree structure, often outperforms multi-CTW.
  • For text sequences, using Good-Turing or improved estimators significantly improves multi-CTW performance, but DECO with the standard KT estimator achieves the best overall performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimizing Decomposition Trees: Finding the optimal decomposition tree is NP-hard. While Huffman trees are a good heuristic, further research into optimizing tree structures is needed.
  • Finite-Sample Bounds: The paper focuses on asymptotic bounds. Developing tighter bounds for finite and short sequences remains an open and important research question.
  • Exploring Other Decompositions: The paper suggests investigating "flat" decomposition techniques (like one-vs-all) and other hierarchical structures beyond Huffman trees.
  • Other Zero-Order Estimators: While DECO with KT performed best in experiments, exploring combinations of DECO with other advanced zero-order estimators is a promising direction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{begleiter2006superior,
  author = {Ron Begleiter and Ran El-Yaniv},
  title = {{Superior Guarantees for Sequential Prediction and Lossless Compression via Alphabet Decomposition}},
  journal = {J. Mach. Learn. Res.},
  year = {2006},
}
Figure