Superconductivity on the surface of topological insulators and in two-dimensional noncentrosymmetric materials

Luiz H. Santos, Titus Neupert, Claudio Chamon, Christopher MudryPhysical 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the fascinating interplay between superconductivity and exotic electronic states found on the surfaces of topological insulators and in non-centrosymmetric materials. The authors reveal that the unique properties of these materials lead to distinct superconducting phases and the emergence of Majorana fermions bound to magnetic vortices, with the number of these elusive particles depending on the specific material and superconducting state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the question of how superconductivity manifests in materials with unusual electronic properties, specifically focusing on two scenarios: the surface states of 3D topological insulators (TIs) and 2D non-centrosymmetric superconductors. Both systems exhibit strong spin-orbit coupling, which mixes spin and momentum, leading to complex electronic behavior. The authors are particularly interested in understanding the superconducting instabilities in these systems, how they differ from conventional superconductors, and whether they host exotic phenomena like Majorana fermions, which are predicted to have applications in quantum computing. A key challenge is to map out the phase diagrams of these superconducting states and understand the role of both singlet and triplet pairing in their formation.

Methods

The authors employ a theoretical approach, primarily using the Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) formalism to describe superconductivity. They analyze the electronic dispersion relations for both the Rashba-Dirac surface states of TIs and the Fermi-liquid-like states in non-centrosymmetric materials. A significant part of the work involves constructing mean-field phase diagrams by analyzing the conditions under which the superconducting gap closes. They also investigate the properties of magnetic vortices within these superconducting states, specifically focusing on the existence and number of bound Majorana fermions. This involves detailed mathematical analysis of Hamiltonians and their eigenvalues.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two distinct superconducting regimes: The paper clearly distinguishes between the superconducting behavior on TI surfaces (Rashba-Dirac limit) and in 2D non-centrosymmetric materials (Fermi limit). The former exhibits a single superconducting phase, while the latter shows two, depending on the relative strengths of singlet and triplet pairing.
  • Majorana fermions in vortices: A central finding is the prediction of Majorana fermions bound to the core of magnetic vortices. These are exotic particles that are their own antiparticles and are of great interest for topological quantum computing.
  • Vortex vorticity and Majorana count: The number of Majorana fermions bound to a vortex is not arbitrary. In the TI surface state case, a single vortex binds one Majorana fermion. In the non-centrosymmetric case, depending on the superconducting phase, a vortex can bind zero or two Majorana fermions.
  • Role of spin-orbit coupling: The strong spin-orbit coupling in these materials is crucial. It leads to the mixing of singlet and triplet pairing components, even when only one type of pairing is initially considered, and dictates the behavior of the superconducting states and the bound Majorana fermions.
  • TRS and vortex properties: The presence of time-reversal symmetry (TRS) in these systems leads to specific constraints on the pairing potentials and influences the nature of the bound Majorana fermions. For instance, TRS forces a relationship between the spin-resolved pairing amplitudes, which is key to understanding why full vortices bind Majorana fermions in these systems, unlike in some other superconducting states.

Key Results

  • Rashba-Dirac limit: A single superconducting phase is identified, characterized by the binding of exactly one Majorana fermion to the core of an isolated vortex with unit vorticity.
  • Fermi limit: Two distinct superconducting phases are found. In one phase (singlet-dominated), vortices bind no Majorana fermions. In the other phase (triplet-dominated), vortices bind two Majorana fermions.
  • Vortex vorticity: The vorticity required to bind Majorana fermions is quantized in units of the magnetic flux quantum, contrasting with half-flux vortices in some other superconducting systems.
  • Phase diagram: The authors map out the mean-field phase diagram as a function of chemical potential and the relative strengths of singlet and triplet pairing potentials.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper focuses on theoretical predictions and mean-field approximations. Experimental verification of these predicted superconducting phases and the observation of Majorana fermions in these specific material systems would be a crucial next step. The authors also mention that the robustness of the Majorana fermions in the non-centrosymmetric case is not guaranteed against generic perturbations that break translation invariance, suggesting further investigation into their topological protection. Future work could also explore the effects of more complex vortex configurations and the role of disorder in these systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the superconducting instabilities of a single species of two-dimensional Rashba-Dirac fermions, as it pertains to the surface of a three-dimensional time-reversal symmetric topological band insulator. We also discuss the similarities as well as the differences between this problem and that of superconductivity in two-dimensional time-reversal symmetric noncentrosymmetric materials with spin-orbit interactions. The superconducting order parameter has both $s$-wave and $p$-wave components, even when the superconducting pair potential only transfers either pure singlet or pure triplet pairs of electrons in and out of the condensate, a corollary to the nonconservation of spin due to the spin-orbit coupling. We identify one single superconducting regime in the case of superconductivity in the topological surface states (Rashba-Dirac limit), irrespective of the relative strength between singlet and triplet pair potentials. In contrast, in the Fermi limit relevant to the noncentrosymmetric materials we find two regimes depending on the value of the chemical potential and the relative strength between singlet and triplet potentials. We construct explicitly the Majorana bound states in these regimes. In the single regime for the case of the Rashba-Dirac limit, there exists one and only one Majorana fermion bound to the core of an isolated vortex. In the Fermi limit, there are always an even number (0 or 2 depending on the regime) of Majorana fermions bound to the core of an isolated vortex. In all cases, the vorticity required to bind Majorana fermions is quantized in units of the flux quantum, in contrast to the half flux in the case of two-dimensional ${p}_{x}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}i{p}_{y}$ superconductors that break time-reversal symmetry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{santos2010superconductivity,
  author = {Luiz H. Santos and Titus Neupert and Claudio Chamon and Christopher Mudry},
  title = {{Superconductivity on the surface of topological insulators and in two-dimensional noncentrosymmetric materials}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.81.184502},
}
Figure