Superconductivity in a layered cobalt oxychalcogenide Na$_{2}$CoSe$_{2}$O with a triangular lattice

Jingwen Cheng, Jianli Bai, Bin-Bin Ruan, Pinyu Liu, Yuying Huang, Qingxin Dong, Yifei Huang, Yingrui Sun, Cundong Li, Libo Zhang, Qiaoyu Liu, Wenliang Zhu, Zhi‐An Ren, Genfu ChenarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

This paper reports the discovery of a new unconventional superconductor, $\text{Na}_2\text{CoSe}_2\text{O}$, which breaks the mold of traditional transition-metal superconductors. By combining a unique triangular lattice structure with "negative charge transfer" electronics, the authors have opened a new frontier in the search for high-temperature superconductivity.

TL;DR

Researchers have synthesized $\text{Na}_2\text{CoSe}_2\text{O}$, the first 3d transition-metal oxychalcogenide superconductor, featuring a geometrically frustrated triangular lattice. Despite a modest transition temperature ($T_c \approx 6.3\text{ K}$), it exhibits an exceptionally high upper critical field that shatters the standard Pauli limit, suggesting a highly exotic pairing mechanism.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Most unconventional superconductors found in bulk materials belong to two "families": the copper-based cuprates and the iron-based pnictides/chalcogenides. Outside of these, finding 3d transition-metal superconductors is incredibly difficult.

Until now, the only known cobalt-based exotic superconductor was a hydrated cobaltate ($\text{Na}_x\text{CoO}_2 \cdot y\text{H}_2\text{O}$). However, that material is notoriously difficult to study because it is chemically unstable and its water content is hard to control. The field has long sought a stable, well-defined cobalt-based analog to help unravel how geometric frustration (the "struggle" of spins to align on a triangular lattice) and strong electronic correlations lead to superconductivity.

Methods

The team used a combination of experimental synthesis and theoretical modeling:

  • Crystal Growth: They produced high-quality single crystals via a solid-state reaction of $\text{Na}_2\text{O}_2$, NaSe, and CoSe at 650°C. Due to the material's sensitivity to moisture, all handling was done in an argon-filled glovebox.
  • Characterization: The structure was determined using single-crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD), and chemical composition was verified with Energy Dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectroscopy.
  • Physical Measurements: They measured resistivity, the Hall effect, and magnetic susceptibility using standard cryogenic systems (PPMS and MPMS) to confirm the superconducting state and its properties.
  • First-Principles Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT + U) was employed to map the electronic band structure and understand the charge transfer between the sodium-oxide and cobalt-selenide layers.

Datasets

As an experimental condensed matter physics paper, it does not use standard machine learning datasets. Instead, the "data" consists of:

  • Crystallographic data: Refined unit cell parameters ($a = 3.5161\text{ \AA}$, $c = 28.745\text{ \AA}$) and atomic positions.
  • Transport/Magnetic curves: Temperature-dependent resistivity and magnetic susceptibility plots.
  • Computational results: Electronic density of states (DOS) and Fermi surface maps generated via Quantum ESPRESSO.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Triangular Advantage: Unlike the square lattices of cuprates, $\text{Na}_2\text{CoSe}_2\text{O}$ features a perfect triangular lattice of cobalt ions. This geometry prevents simple magnetic ordering, potentially stabilizing exotic states like the Resonating Valence Bond (RVB) state.
  • Negative Charge Transfer (NCT): In most materials, electrons move from the metal to the ligand (like Oxygen or Selenium). Here, the opposite happens: electrons transfer from the ligands back to the highly oxidized Cobalt ($Co^{4+}$). This makes $\text{Na}_2\text{CoSe}_2\text{O}$ a rare "NCT superconductor," where holes in the ligand orbitals drive the physics.
  • Self-Doping: Most superconductors require chemical doping (adding/removing atoms) to work. This material is "self-doping"—the internal charge transfer between the $[\text{Na}_2\text{O}]$ and $[\text{CoSe}_2]$ layers naturally creates the necessary carrier concentration for superconductivity.
  • Breaking the Pauli Limit: The upper critical field ($\mu_0H_{c2}$) is the magnetic field strength that kills superconductivity. In this material, the in-plane $\mu_0H_{c2}$ is 3 to 4 times higher than the theoretical "Pauli limit," a strong hint that the electrons might be pairing up in an unconventional (possibly spin-triplet) way.

Key Results

  • Superconducting Transition: The material becomes superconducting at an onset temperature of $\sim 6.3\text{ K}$.
  • Upper Critical Field: The estimated $\mu_0H_{c2}(0)$ reaches $41\text{ T}$ for fields applied parallel to the layers, far exceeding the Pauli paramagnetic limit of $\sim 11.6\text{ T}$.
  • Bulk Nature: Magnetic susceptibility measurements confirmed a superconducting volume fraction exceeding 100% (after accounting for sample shape), proving the effect is a bulk property of the crystal, not a surface impurity.
  • Carrier Type: Hall coefficient measurements confirmed that holes are the dominant charge carriers, consistent with the p-type semiconductor behavior predicted by theory.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Air Sensitivity: The crystals are unstable in moist air, which complicates long-term study and potential applications.
  • Spin Configuration: While DFT suggests a low-spin state, the actual spin configuration of the cobalt ions remains unconfirmed. The authors suggest future neutron diffraction studies are needed to map the magnetism.
  • Mechanism Debate: The exact symmetry of the superconducting "gap" (e.g., $d+id$ wave) is still theoretical. Experimental verification of the pairing symmetry is the next major hurdle.
  • Raising $T_c$: The authors propose that by modifying the "blocking layers" (replacing Na or O with other elements), it may be possible to design related materials with much higher transition temperatures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Unconventional superconductivity in bulk materials under ambient pressure is extremely rare among the 3d transition metal compounds outside the layered cuprates and iron-based family. It is predominantly linked to highly anisotropic electronic properties and quasi-two-dimensional (2D) Fermi surfaces. To date, the only known example of a Co-based exotic superconductor is the hydrated layered cobaltate, Na$_{x}$CoO$_{2}\cdot$ yH$_{2}$O, and its superconductivity is realized in the vicinity of a spin-1/2 Mott state. However, the nature of the superconductivity in these materials is still a subject of intense debate, and therefore, finding a new class of superconductors will help unravel the mysteries of their unconventional superconductivity. Here we report the discovery of superconductivity at $\sim$ 6.3 K in our newly synthesized layered compound Na$_{2}$CoSe$_{2}$O, in which the edge-shared CoSe$_{6}$ octahedra form [CoSe$_{2}$] layers with a perfect triangular lattice of Co ions. It is the first 3d transition metal oxychalcogenide superconductor with distinct structural and chemical characteristics. Despite its relatively low $T_{c}$, this material exhibits very high superconducting upper critical fields, $μ_{0}H_{c2}(0)$, which far exceeds the Pauli paramagnetic limit by a factor of 3 - 4. First-principles calculations show that Na$_{2}$CoSe$_{2}$O is a rare example of a negative charge transfer superconductor. This cobalt oxychalcogenide with a geometrical frustration among Co spins shows great potential as a highly appealing candidate for the realization of unconventional and/or high-$T_{c}$ superconductivity beyond the well-established Cu- and Fe-based superconductor families and opens a new field in the physics and chemistry of low-dimensional superconductors.
BibTeX
@misc{cheng2023superconductivity,
  author = {Jingwen Cheng and Jianli Bai and Bin-Bin Ruan and Pinyu Liu and Yuying Huang and Qingxin Dong and Yifei Huang and Yingrui Sun and Cundong Li and Libo Zhang and Qiaoyu Liu and Wenliang Zhu and Zhi‐An Ren and Genfu Chen},
  title = {{Superconductivity in a layered cobalt oxychalcogenide Na$\_\{2\}$CoSe$\_\{2\}$O with a triangular lattice}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2310.17464},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17464},
}
Figure