Superconducting Proximity Effect in Topological Metal

Kyungmin Lee, Abolhassan Vaezi, Mark H. Fischer, Eun-Ah KimBulletin 2014

TL;DR

This paper explores how superconductivity can be induced in "topological metals" (materials with both topological surface states and conducting bulk states), a scenario distinct from the more studied topological insulators. They demonstrate that this proximity effect can extend to the "naked" surface, potentially hosting Majorana zero modes in vortices, which are more accessible for experimental observation than in pure topological insulators.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The quest for Majorana zero modes (MZMs), exotic particles with potential applications in topological quantum computing, has largely focused on their potential appearance at the interface between a superconductor and a topological insulator (TI). However, many promising TI materials are actually "topological metals" (TMs), meaning they possess conducting bulk states in addition to the desired topological surface states. This coexistence of bulk and surface states fundamentally alters how the superconducting proximity effect behaves. The key question this paper addresses is: how does the superconducting proximity effect manifest in these topological metals, and can it lead to the formation of MZMs on the outermost surface, making them more experimentally accessible?

Methods

The authors employ the Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) formalism to model a heterostructure consisting of a finite-thickness slab of a topological metal (specifically, Bi₂Se₃) interfaced with a conventional s-wave superconductor. They solve the BdG equations to understand the spatial distribution of the superconducting pair amplitude within the topological metal. Based on these solutions, they then analyze the vortex-bound-state spectra to identify the presence and location of MZMs. They specifically investigate three regimes: a pure topological insulator (TI), a metal (M), and the topological metal (TM) regime, distinguished by the position of the chemical potential relative to the material's band structure.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and calculations based on established material parameters for Bi₂Se₃.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Proximity effect reaches the naked surface in TMs: Unlike in TI-SC heterostructures where the superconducting pair amplitude is confined to the interface, in TM-SC heterostructures, the proximity effect can propagate all the way to the outer, "naked" surface due to the presence of conducting bulk states.
  • TMs offer a distinct advantage for MZM hosting: The ability of the proximity effect to reach the naked surface in TMs means that MZMs, if they form in vortices, can be located on this accessible surface, rather than being buried at the interface.
  • Chemical potential is key: The behavior of the proximity effect is highly sensitive to the chemical potential. The paper defines three distinct regimes (TI, M, TM) based on this, with the TM regime showing the most promising characteristics for naked-surface MZMs.
  • Singlet vs. Triplet pairing: While both singlet and triplet superconducting components are present due to spin-orbit coupling, their relative contributions and spatial profiles differ across the TI, M, and TM regimes. In the TM regime, the induced pairing on the naked surface is a mixture of both.

Key Results

  • Spatial profile of pair amplitude:
    • In the TI regime, the pair amplitude decays exponentially from the interface.
  • In the M regime, it exhibits Friedel oscillations with an algebraically decaying envelope.
  • In the TM regime, the pair amplitude shows a combination of surface and bulk contributions, with a power-law decay at larger distances, allowing it to reach the naked surface.
  • Majorana vortex bound states: The paper predicts that vortices in a TM-SC heterostructure will host energetically stable Majorana vortex bound states on the naked surface. This is in contrast to the TI regime, where MZMs would be confined to the buried interface.
  • Experimental accessibility: The TM regime offers a significant advantage by placing MZMs on the experimentally accessible naked surface, facilitating their detection and manipulation via techniques like scanning tunneling microscopy (STM).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The study uses a simplified effective Hamiltonian for Bi₂Se₃ and an s-wave superconductor. While the authors argue their findings are generalizable to d-wave superconductors and other materials, further work could explore more complex material models and superconducting pairings.
  • Experimental Verification: While the paper proposes experimental avenues (e.g., in-field STM measurements), direct experimental confirmation of naked-surface MZMs in TM-SC heterostructures is still needed.
  • Distinguishing Surfaces: The paper notes that experimentally distinguishing between the top (naked) and bottom (buried) surfaces of a TI/TM heterostructure is challenging but crucial for verifying their predictions. Future work could focus on developing techniques for such discrimination.
  • Gap Profile Dependence: The specific gap profiles used for the TI and TM regimes are based on theoretical considerations. Investigating the robustness of the MZM states to variations in these gap profiles would be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{lee2014superconducting,
  author = {Kyungmin Lee and Abolhassan Vaezi and Mark H. Fischer and Eun-Ah Kim},
  title = {{Superconducting Proximity Effect in Topological Metal}},
  journal = {Bulletin},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure