Super-exponential behaviors of out-of-time ordered correlators and Loschmidt echo in a non-Hermitian interacting system

Wen-Lei Zhao, Jie Liu, Ke, Han, Liu, JiearXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered a "super-exponential" regime of quantum chaos in non-Hermitian interacting systems. By studying a kicked Gross-Pitaevskii model, they demonstrate that information scrambling and dynamical instability can grow significantly faster than the standard exponential rates seen in traditional chaotic systems, following a universal scaling law that is independent of specific system parameters.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the study of quantum chaos, we typically look for exponential growth. For example, the distance between two nearby quantum states usually diverges at a rate defined by a Lyapunov exponent ($e^{\lambda t}$). This growth is a hallmark of "scrambling"—how quickly a system spreads information across its degrees of freedom.

However, most classical studies assume "Hermitian" systems, where energy is conserved. Real-world quantum systems often involve gain and loss (non-Hermiticity) and interactions (nonlinearity), such as those found in Bose-Einstein Condensates (BECs). The authors ask a fundamental question: Can quantum instability grow even faster than exponentially? And if so, what governs this "super-chaos"?

Methods

The authors investigate a Non-Hermitian Gross-Pitaevskii Map (NGPM). This is essentially a "kicked rotor" model—a standard paradigm for chaos—but modified with two key features:

  1. Nonlinearity: The interaction strength depends on the density of the quantum state.
  2. Non-Hermiticity: The interaction strength is complex ($g + i\eta$), representing gain or loss in the system.

They use numerical simulations to track two primary metrics:

  • Out-of-Time Ordered Correlators (OTOCs): A modern tool used to quantify how quickly operators "grow" and scramble information.
  • Loschmidt Echo (LE): A measure of how sensitive a system's evolution is to tiny perturbations (the "butterfly effect").

By analyzing the ratios of these values between successive "kicks," they look for scaling laws that might hide behind the explosive growth.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, this work does not use external datasets. Instead, the "data" consists of high-precision numerical solutions of the time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation under various parameters for the non-Hermitian strength ($\eta$) and the effective Planck constant ($\hbar_{eff}$).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Super-Exponential Growth: The most striking finding is that both OTOCs and the Loschmidt echo grow faster than any standard exponential function. This indicates a level of instability and scrambling speed previously unseen in simpler chaotic models.
  • The Equivalence Principle: The authors prove a rigorous mathematical equivalence between the distance of two nearby quantum states and the OTOCs in this system. This means that the physical divergence of states and the scrambling of information are two sides of the same coin.
  • Universal Scaling Laws: Despite changing the "noise" (Planck constant) or the "gain/loss" (non-Hermitian parameter), the growth curves collapse onto a single scaling-law curve after proper normalization. This suggests the existence of a fundamental, underlying mechanism for super-exponential behavior.
  • Energy Diffusion: The root cause of this explosive growth is "super-exponentially fast diffusion of energy." As the system is kicked, its mean kinetic energy increases at an accelerating rate, which in turn drives the rapid divergence of quantum states.

Key Results

  • Scaling Function: The authors identified a specific fitting function for the growth ratio $R(t)$: $\ln[R(t+1)] = \alpha [R(t) \ln R(t)]^\beta$. This formula held true across different regimes, including "quantum resonance" (where the system is highly ordered) and non-resonance (where it is more disordered).
  • Numerical Confirmation: In semi-log plots, the growth of OTOCs and LE appears as a curve that bends upward, rather than a straight line, confirming the super-exponential nature.
  • Metrology Implications: The paper links this fast growth to Quantum Fisher Information (QFI). Because the system is so sensitive to small changes, it could potentially be used to create ultra-precise sensors that surpass the standard limits of measurement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while they have a strong numerical grasp of the scaling law, a full analytical solution for the "non-resonant" case remains elusive because there is no simple explicit expression for the quantum state in that regime.

Future research directions include:

  • Experimental Validation: Proposing setups using Bose-Einstein Condensates in ring traps or optical fibers with modulated refractive indices to observe these super-exponential behaviors in the lab.
  • Many-Body Systems: Extending these results from a single-particle "map" model to more complex, many-body quantum systems to see if the scaling laws remain robust.

Reference: Zhao, W.-L., et al. (2025). Super-exponential behaviors of out-of-time ordered correlators and Loschmidt echo in a non-Hermitian interacting system. arXiv:2305.12150v2 [quant-ph].

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the out-of-time ordered correlators and Loschmidt echo in a non-Hermitian interacting system governed by a Gross-Pitaevskii map model, which incorporates a periodically modulated complex strength of the nonlinear interaction as delta kicks. We uncover that the time evolutions of the out-of-time ordered correlators follow that of the Loschmidt echo in certain situations. In particular, we find that both of them can exhibit a super-exponential growth with time, indicating the emergence of super-exponential scrambling and instability. Interestingly, after a proper scaling scheme, we find that all the super-exponential behaviors approximately collapse on a scaling-law curve that is independent on the non-Hermitian parameter as well as the effective Planck constant. The underlying mechanism is rooted in the super-exponentially fast diffusion of energy as well as the norm of quantum states. Our findings suggest a kind of fastest divergence of two nearby quantum states, which has implication in information scrambling.
BibTeX
@misc{zhao2023super,
  author = {Wen-Lei Zhao and Jie Liu and Ke, Han and Liu, Jie},
  title = {{Super-exponential behaviors of out-of-time ordered correlators and Loschmidt echo in a non-Hermitian interacting system}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2305.12150},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12150},
}
Figure