Sunscreen Formula of <scp>FeO</scp> ( <scp>OH</scp> )· <scp> H 2 O </scp> / <scp> TiO 2 </scp> With Spectral Selectivity to Enhance Collagen Biosynthesis via Fibroblast Test

Xun Zhang, Xuefa Wen, Wang Yu-ling, Fangru Jiang, Yi‐Ting Chen, Zhe LiuJournal of Cosmetic Dermatology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel sunscreen formulation that selectively filters harmful UV and high-energy visible (HEV) light while allowing beneficial longer wavelengths to pass through. This "spectral selectivity" not only protects the skin but also promotes collagen synthesis, offering a dual-action approach to skincare beyond traditional sun protection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sunlight, while essential for certain biological processes, poses significant risks to skin health, including sunburn, photoaging, and cancer. Traditional sunscreens primarily focus on blocking UV radiation (UVA and UVB). However, recent research highlights that high-energy visible (HEV) light (400-550 nm) also contributes to oxidative stress and skin damage, similar to UVA. Conversely, certain longer wavelengths of visible light (550-760 nm) have been shown to promote skin regeneration and collagen synthesis. The challenge, therefore, is to develop sunscreens that can effectively block the damaging wavelengths (280-550 nm) while allowing the beneficial ones (550-760 nm) to reach the skin, thus offering a more nuanced approach to sun protection that also supports skin health.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel metric called the "Selection Index" (SI) to quantify spectral selectivity. This index measures the differential transmittance of beneficial light (550-760 nm) versus harmful light (280-550 nm), normalized by the total transmittance across the 280-760 nm range.

They screened various inorganic filters (ZnO, TiO₂, Fe₂O₃, FeO(OH)·H₂O, Fe₃O₄) for their transmittance spectra. Based on this, TiO₂ and FeO(OH)·H₂O emerged as promising candidates due to their low transmittance in the damaging range and higher transmittance in the beneficial range.

A series of formulations with varying ratios of TiO₂ and FeO(OH)·H₂O were tested to optimize the SI value. The optimal mixture (64:36 TiO₂:FeO(OH)·H₂O) was then incorporated into a sunscreen base with traditional UV filters.

The efficacy of the optimized formula was evaluated using human dermal fibroblasts (HDFs). Cells were exposed to simulated sunlight after being treated with different sunscreen formulations. Cell viability was assessed using the MTT assay, and collagen I levels were measured via immunofluorescence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized commercially available filters and cell culture reagents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond UV Blocking: The Power of Spectral Selectivity: The core idea is that sunscreens can do more than just block harmful rays; they can be designed to selectively allow beneficial light to pass through, actively promoting skin health.
  • TiO₂ and FeO(OH)·H₂O Synergy: This specific combination of inorganic filters exhibits a unique spectral profile, acting as a natural "window" for beneficial light while blocking damaging wavelengths.
  • The Selection Index (SI) as a New Metric: The development of the SI provides a quantitative way to assess a sunscreen's ability to differentiate between harmful and beneficial light, complementing traditional metrics like SPF.
  • Collagen Boost from "Beneficial" Light: The study provides in-vitro evidence that allowing longer visible light wavelengths to reach fibroblasts can indeed enhance collagen synthesis, suggesting a proactive role for sunscreens in anti-aging.

Key Results

  • Optimal Formula Identified: The optimal ratio of TiO₂ to FeO(OH)·H₂O for spectral selectivity was found to be 64:36, achieving the highest Selection Index (SI).
  • Enhanced Collagen I: The sunscreen formula incorporating the optimized TiO₂ and FeO(OH)·H₂O mixture, along with traditional UV filters, significantly increased collagen I levels in HDFs compared to control groups.
  • SI vs. SPF: While many formulations achieved high estimated SPF values (40-50), the SI values varied significantly. The formula with the highest SI (Cell-4, using the 64:36 TiO₂:FeO(OH)·H₂O ratio) also demonstrated the most pronounced increase in collagen I.
  • Limitations of Conventional Sunscreens: Formulations using only conventional UV filters or non-spectral selective inorganic filters showed less significant improvements in collagen I levels compared to the spectrally selective formula.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In-Vitro Study: The study was conducted using HDFs in a lab setting. Further in-vivo studies are needed to validate these findings in human skin and to assess the effects across different skin types and conditions.
  • Skin Tone Considerations: The authors acknowledge that skin tone can influence the response to light, particularly HEV, and suggest that Southeast Asian populations with type II skin might benefit more from spectrally selective sunscreens. Future research should explore these variations.
  • Integration with Organic Filters: While the study focused on inorganic filters for spectral selectivity, the authors suggest that in scenarios with high light energy or increased UV/HEV proportions (e.g., high altitudes, seaside), incorporating organic filters that absorb wavelengths below 550 nm could further enhance protection.
  • Long-Term Effects: The study focused on short-term collagen synthesis. Long-term studies are needed to assess the sustained benefits and potential side effects of this spectrally selective approach.

Summary updated

Abstract

This work uncovers the influence of spectral selectivity on the enhancement of sunscreen performance and proposes a filter combination with spectral selectivity. This formula, when integrated with conventional UV sunscreens, allows for the beneficial effects of sunlight to be more pronounced. This discovery may provide fresh insights for the design of future sunscreen products.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2025sunscreen,
  author = {Xun Zhang and Xuefa Wen and Wang Yu-ling and Fangru Jiang and Yi‐Ting Chen and Zhe Liu},
  title = {{Sunscreen Formula of <scp>FeO</scp> ( <scp>OH</scp> )· <scp> H <sub>2</sub> O </scp> / <scp> TiO <sub>2</sub> </scp> With Spectral Selectivity to Enhance Collagen Biosynthesis via Fibroblast Test}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1111/jocd.70060},
}
Figure