Sulfate-Centered Sodium-Icosahedron-Templated Uranyl Peroxide Phosphate Cages with Uranyl Bridged by μ–η1:η2 Peroxide

Jie Qiu, Tyler L. Spano, Mateusz Dembowski, Alex M. Kokot, Jennifer E. S. Szymanowski, Peter C. BurnsInorganic 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have synthesized two novel uranyl peroxide phosphate cage clusters, U₂₀P₆ and U₂₀P₁₂, featuring an unprecedented μ–η¹:η² peroxide bridging motif. This discovery expands our understanding of uranyl chemistry, demonstrating the remarkable structural flexibility of uranyl polyhedra and potentially opening new avenues for applications in nuclear fuel cycles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Uranyl peroxide cage clusters are a fascinating class of nanoscale materials with potential applications, particularly in nuclear fuel cycles. While over 60 such clusters have been identified since 2005, they have consistently featured a specific type of peroxide bridge: the μ–η²:η² configuration, where the peroxide molecule bridges two uranyl ions by coordinating through both its oxygen atoms to each uranyl. This paper addresses the question of whether other peroxide coordination modes are possible in high-nuclearity uranyl peroxide cages and what structural and chemical implications such variations might have. Specifically, the authors explore the incorporation of the less common μ–η¹:η² peroxide bridge, where one oxygen atom coordinates to one uranyl and the other to a second uranyl, into these complex cage structures.

Methods

The synthesis of these novel clusters involved carefully controlled reactions combining uranyl nitrate hexahydrate, hydrogen peroxide, lithium hydroxide, sodium sulfite (for U₂₀P₆), and sodium sulfate (for U₂₀P₁₂), along with phosphoric acid. The reactions were carried out in sealed vials with slow evaporation at room temperature, leading to the formation of crystalline products.

Key characterization techniques employed include:

  • Single-Crystal X-ray Diffraction: This was the primary method for determining the precise atomic structure of the U₂₀P₆ and U₂₀P₁₂ clusters, revealing their intricate polyhedral arrangements and the unique peroxide bridging modes.
  • Elemental Analysis (XRF and ICP-OES): These techniques confirmed the elemental composition of the synthesized clusters, verifying the presence of uranium, phosphorus, sulfur, sodium, and lithium.
  • Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA): Used to quantify the amount of water molecules incorporated into the crystal structure.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: Employed to identify vibrational modes associated with uranyl and peroxide groups, and importantly, to probe the stability of the clusters. Isotopic labeling with ¹⁸O was used to distinguish between uranyl and peroxide stretches.
  • Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS): Utilized to study the formation and stability of the clusters in solution, providing insights into their nanoscale dimensions and aggregation behavior over time.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The research focuses on the synthesis and characterization of new chemical compounds, rather than on training or evaluating models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Discovery of the μ–η¹:η² Peroxide Bridge in High-Nuclearity Uranyl Cages: This is the most significant finding. The paper reports the first instances of this peroxide coordination mode in complex uranyl peroxide structures, challenging the previously assumed universality of the μ–η²:η² bridge.
  • Structural Flexibility of Uranyl Polyhedra: The incorporation of the μ–η¹:η² peroxide bridge leads to notable distortions in the uranyl hexagonal bipyramids. This highlights the inherent pliability of uranyl coordination geometries, which is crucial for the vast topological diversity observed in uranyl compounds.
  • Templating Role of the Sulfate-Centered Na₁₂ Icosahedron: The formation of these specific cage structures appears to be templated by a sulfate-centered Na₁₂ cluster, which adopts an icosahedral arrangement. This templating unit is proposed to be larger than what can be accommodated in simpler uranyl cages, driving the formation of these unique, larger clusters.
  • Stability of Novel Clusters: Despite the unusual structural features and distortions, both U₂₀P₆ and U₂₀P₁₂ demonstrate remarkable stability in both solid state and aqueous solutions, as evidenced by Raman spectroscopy and SAXS studies. This is a crucial finding for any potential applications.

Key Results

  • U₂₀P₆ and U₂₀P₁₂ Synthesis: Two new uranyl peroxide phosphate cage clusters, U₂₀P₆ (Li₄Na₁₂{(SO₄)CNa₁₂C[(UO₂)₂₀(O₂)₂₇(HPO₄)₆]}(H₂O)₄₂) and U₂₀P₁₂ (LiNa₆₋ₓ{(SO₄)CNa₁₂C[(UO₂)₂₀(O₂)₂₄(HPO₄)₆(H₂PO₄)₆]}(H₂O)), were successfully synthesized and structurally characterized.
  • Unique Peroxide Coordination: Both clusters contain the novel μ–η¹:η² peroxide bridges, alongside the common μ–η²:η² bridges. U₂₀P₆ features 21 μ–η²:η² and 6 μ–η¹:η² peroxide groups, while U₂₀P₁₂ has 18 μ–η²:η² and 6 μ–η¹:η² peroxide groups.
  • Structural Framework: Both cages are built from 20 uranyl hexagonal bipyramids arranged on the vertices of distorted dodecahedrons. U₂₀P₆ incorporates 6 phosphate tetrahedra, and U₂₀P₁₂ incorporates 12 phosphate tetrahedra.
  • Templating Unit: A sulfate-centered Na₁₂ icosahedron acts as a template, influencing the cage formation.
  • Stability: Raman spectra showed no significant changes over 45 days for solid U₂₀P₆, and SAXS data indicated stability in aqueous solution for over 42 days.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low Yield for U₂₀P₁₂: The synthesis of U₂₀P₁₂ was achieved in low yield and was often accompanied by a fine precipitate, hindering detailed chemical characterization. Further optimization of synthesis conditions for U₂₀P₁₂ is warranted.
  • Disordered Sulfate in U₂₀P₁₂: The sulfate tetrahedron in U₂₀P₁₂ was found to be positionally disordered in the X-ray structure, suggesting potential for further structural investigation.
  • Understanding Formation Mechanisms: While the templating role of the sulfate-centered Na₁₂ icosahedron is proposed, the precise reasons for the formation of these specific cage sizes (U₂₀) over potentially larger ones remain an area for further exploration.
  • Broader Applications: The authors suggest that the pliable nature of uranyl polyhedra and the observed stability of these new clusters contribute to the tremendous topological variability of uranyl compounds, hinting at potential for designing new materials with tailored properties. Future work could focus on exploring the functional properties and applications of these unique structures, particularly in areas like nuclear waste remediation or catalysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Two novel hybrid uranyl peroxide phosphate cage clusters, designated U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>6</sub> and U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>12</sub>, contain peroxide bridges between uranyl in an unusual μ-η<sup>1</sup>:η<sup>2</sup> configuration, as well as the common μ-η<sup>2</sup>:η<sup>2</sup> configuration. These appear to be the only high-nuclearity metal peroxide complexes containing μ-η<sup>1</sup>:η<sup>2</sup> peroxide bridges, and they are unique among uranyl peroxide cages. Both clusters contain 20 uranyl polyhedra, and U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>6</sub> and U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>12</sub> contain 6 and 12 phosphate tetrahedra, respectively. The 20 uranyl polyhedra in both cages are arranged on the vertices of distorted topological dodecahedrons (20 vertex fullerenes). Each cage is completed by phosphate tetrahedra and is templated by a sulfate-centered Na<sub>12</sub> cluster with the Na cations defining a regular convex isocahedron. Whereas μ-η<sup>2</sup>:η<sup>2</sup> peroxides are essential features of uranyl peroxide cages, where they form equatorial edges of uranyl hexagonal bipyramids, the μ-η<sup>1</sup>:η<sup>2</sup> peroxide groups in U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>6</sub> and U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>12</sub> are associated with strong distortions of the uranyl polyhedra. Formation of U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>6</sub> and U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>12</sub> is a further demonstration of the pliable nature of uranyl polyhedra, which contributes to the tremendous topological variability of uranyl compounds. Despite the unusual structure and highly distorted polyhedral geometries of U<sub>20</sub>P<sub>6</sub>, small-angle X-ray scattering and Raman spectra suggest its stability in the aqueous solution and solid state.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qiu2017sulfate,
  author = {Jie Qiu and Tyler L. Spano and Mateusz Dembowski and Alex M. Kokot and Jennifer E. S. Szymanowski and Peter C. Burns},
  title = {{Sulfate-Centered Sodium-Icosahedron-Templated Uranyl Peroxide Phosphate Cages with Uranyl Bridged by μ–η<sup>1</sup>:η<sup>2</sup> Peroxide}},
  booktitle = {Inorganic},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.inorgchem.6b02429},
}
Figure