Suggestion overrides the Stroop effect in highly hypnotizable individuals

Amir Raz, Miguel Moreno-Íñiguez, Laura E. Martin, Hongtu ZhuConsciousness 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that post-hypnotic suggestions can significantly reduce, and even eliminate, the Stroop effect in highly hypnotizable individuals. This challenges the notion that reading is an immutable automatic process, suggesting that cognitive control can be exerted over seemingly involuntary behaviors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cognitive science generally distinguishes between automatic and controlled mental processes. Automatic processes are typically considered to be initiated unintentionally, effortlessly, and difficult to interrupt once automatized, with reading being a prime example. The Stroop effect, where participants are slower to name the ink color of a word when the word itself is a color name that mismatches the ink color (e.g., the word "BLUE" printed in red ink), is often cited as a "gold standard" for demonstrating the automaticity of reading. While much research has focused on how processes become automatic, the question of whether automatized processes can be de-automatized or brought back under volitional control has been largely unaddressed. This paper investigates whether a powerful suggestion, delivered via hypnosis, can override this seemingly automatic reading process.

Methods

The researchers employed a within-subject design using a modified Stroop task. Participants, all highly hypnotizable individuals, completed the task under two conditions: with a post-hypnotic suggestion and without it. The suggestion, administered after a standard hypnotic induction, instructed participants to perceive the presented words as meaningless symbols of a foreign language, focusing only on their ink color. The control condition involved standard instructions for the Stroop task.

The Stroop task itself involved presenting color words (RED, BLUE, GREEN, YELLOW) and neutral words (LOT, SHIP, KNIFE, FLOWER) in one of four ink colors. Participants were asked to identify the ink color by pressing a corresponding key. The experimental conditions were:

  • Congruent: Color word matches ink color (e.g., "RED" in red ink).
  • Neutral: Neutral word in a color ink (e.g., "LOT" in red ink).
  • Incongruent: Color word mismatches ink color (e.g., "BLUE" in red ink).

Reaction times (RTs) and accuracy were recorded. The key manipulation was the post-hypnotic suggestion, triggered by a hand clap, which was either present or absent during the task. The order of conditions was counterbalanced.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data from 49 participants who were screened for high hypnotizability using the Harvard Group Scale of Hypnotic Susceptibility (HGSHS:A) and the Stanford Hypnotic Susceptibility Scale, Form C (SHSS:C).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • De-automatization is possible: The most significant insight is that a strong suggestion can indeed override a process widely considered automatic, like reading. This suggests that the boundary between automatic and controlled processes might be more fluid than previously assumed.
  • Hypnotizability as a key factor: The study highlights the crucial role of high hypnotizability in achieving this de-automatization. This implies that individual differences in suggestibility are critical for understanding the malleability of cognitive processes.
  • Top-down control: The findings suggest that suggestion operates via a top-down mechanism, influencing higher-level cognitive processes to alter the perception and processing of lower-level stimuli. This has implications for understanding attentional control and how the brain prioritizes information.
  • "Un-ringing the bell": The paper frames this as the ability to "un-ring the bell," metaphorically referring to reversing a process that is typically irreversible once initiated.

Key Results

  • Stroop Interference Reduction: In the absence of suggestion, Stroop interference and facilitation were significant. Following the post-hypnotic suggestion, both Stroop interference and facilitation were removed.
  • Reaction Time (RT) Changes: While RTs for congruent trials were not significantly affected by suggestion, RTs for neutral and incongruent trials were significantly shorter with the suggestion present. This indicates faster processing of the ink color when the word meaning was disregarded.
  • Accuracy: Accuracy data showed that while Stroop subtractions were significant without suggestion, they were removed following the suggestion. Accuracy performance became similar across all three Stroop conditions and matched the accuracy of the neutral condition without suggestion.
  • Overall Stroop Effect: The Stroop effect (incongruent vs. congruent) was reduced but not completely eliminated by suggestion in this study.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Specificity: The study focused exclusively on highly hypnotizable individuals. The generalizability of these findings to the broader population, or even to moderately hypnotizable individuals, is not directly addressed.
  • Suggestion Strength: The effectiveness of the suggestion might be dependent on its strength and the individual's susceptibility. The paper notes that other studies have reported varying degrees of Stroop reduction or elimination, suggesting that methodological differences and participant characteristics play a role.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this work has important therapeutic implications for de-automatizing ingrained behaviors in conditions like impulse control disorders and for understanding the neural substrates of the placebo response. They also propose that highly hypnotizable individuals could serve as valuable models for studying "atypical attention" and that further neuroimaging studies are needed to elucidate the brain mechanisms involved. The potential genetic component of hypnotizability is also mentioned as an area for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{raz2006suggestion,
  author = {Amir Raz and Miguel Moreno-Íñiguez and Laura E. Martin and Hongtu Zhu},
  title = {{Suggestion overrides the Stroop effect in highly hypnotizable individuals}},
  booktitle = {Consciousness},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1016/j.concog.2006.04.004},
}

Loading related content...

Figure