TL;DR
This study explores how healthcare teams initiate care escalations for deteriorating patients in acute wards, revealing that a significant portion of these escalations are not triggered by standard early warning scores. The research identifies four distinct communication phenotypes, suggesting that a more nuanced understanding beyond a one-size-fits-all approach is crucial for improving patient safety and optimizing clinical workflows.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Improving the care of deteriorating patients in hospitals is a critical challenge. A key aspect of this is "escalation of care," where clinical staff recognize and communicate a patient's worsening condition to specialist teams. Failure to escalate effectively can lead to adverse outcomes like cardiac arrests and increased mortality. While Early Warning Scores (EWS) are designed to standardize this process, existing research suggests that many patients are transferred to critical care without triggering an alert, and clinicians often identify concerning patients who don't meet EWS thresholds. Furthermore, the literature often treats "escalation" as a uniform process, lacking a deeper understanding of the nuances in communication and the factors that contribute to success. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by developing a theoretical understanding of escalation and identifying its success factors.
Methods
The study employed a qualitative, non-participant observational approach. Researchers shadowed clinical staff across two National Health Service (NHS) Trusts for a total of 105 hours, observing 38 sessions. During these observations, 151 escalation events were captured. The data collected included quantitative information (like patient age and trigger scores) and qualitative field notes.
Key methodological elements include:
- Hierarchical Task Analysis (HTA): Used to map the key steps involved in the escalation process, breaking it down into detection, communication, and action phases.
- Framework Analysis: Applied to the qualitative data to identify themes and patterns related to escalation success factors.
- Ad hoc Interviews: Short, informal interviews with staff were conducted to clarify triggers, clinical concerns, and narratives surrounding escalation events.
- Minimizing Hawthorne Effect: Non-participant observation was used to reduce the observer's influence on the observed behavior.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study collected observational data from clinical staff within two NHS Trusts.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Non-EWS Initiated Escalations are Common: A surprising finding is that approximately half (51%) of the observed escalation events were not initiated by a patient's Early Warning Score (EWS). This highlights that clinical judgment and recognition of subtle signs are crucial, and relying solely on EWS might miss critical situations.
- Four Escalation Phenotypes: The study identified four distinct ways clinicians communicate escalations:
- Outcome-Focused Escalation: The referrer clearly anticipates specific outcomes (e.g., blood cultures, antibiotic prescriptions). This was the most common type.
- Informative Escalation: Used to fulfill organizational requirements or due diligence, often when clinical concern is low, and may not lead to immediate medical review. This was the second most frequent.
- General Concern Escalation: Based on a "gut feeling" or subtle signs of deterioration without a clear preconceived outcome.
- Spontaneous Interaction Escalation: Informal, opportunistic discussions in shared workspaces, influenced by team structure and environment. This was the least frequent.
- Escalation is Not Homogenous: The existence of these distinct phenotypes challenges the idea of a single, standardized escalation process. Understanding these differences is key to improving communication and support systems.
- Environmental and System Design Matters: The study suggests that physical ward layouts and system designs can influence the frequency and effectiveness of spontaneous interactions, which can be beneficial for early detection and dialogue.
Key Results
- A total of 151 escalation events were captured across 38 observation sessions (105 hours).
- 51% of escalations were non-EWS initiated, often related to bleeding, infection, or chest pain.
- Outcome-Focused Escalation was the most common phenotype (41.6% of identified phenotypes).
- Informative Escalation was the second most common (35.8%).
- General Concern Escalation accounted for 19%, and Spontaneous Interaction Escalation for 3.6%.
- For EWS-initiated escalations, common concerns included sepsis, hypotension, low GCS, and hypoxia.
- For non-EWS initiated escalations, common concerns included bleeding, infection, and chest pain.
Limitations and Future Work
- Observational Challenges: Observing escalation events in real-time is inherently difficult, leading to potential data gaps. The study was also conducted during a period of significant healthcare turbulence (COVID-19 pandemic), which may have restricted access and influenced findings.
- Generalizability: The findings may not be fully generalizable due to the specific context of the observed Trusts and the evolving pandemic situation.
- Hawthorne Effect: While efforts were made to minimize it, the researcher's presence might have influenced behavior.
Future work suggested includes:
- Further examination of reducing Informative Escalations and increasing Spontaneous Escalations through designed systems and environments.
- Developing systems to better support staff in undertaking non-EWS initiated escalations.
- Exploring the impact of environmental and system factors on facilitating more spontaneous interaction escalations.
- Further research into the nuances of escalation communication to move beyond a homogenous definition.
Summary updated