Subtle Molecular Changes Largely Modulate Chiral Helical Assemblies of Achiral Conjugated Polymers by Tuning Solution-State Aggregation

Kyung Sun Park, Xuyi Luo, Justin J. Kwok, Azzaya Khasbaatar, Jianguo Mei, Ying DiaoACS 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals how subtle molecular modifications in achiral conjugated polymers dramatically influence their solution-state aggregation, leading to distinct hierarchical chiral helical assemblies. By tuning the flexibility and rigidity of polymer chains, researchers can control the formation of 1D fibers or 2D sheets, which in turn dictate the pitch length and chiroptical properties of resulting liquid crystal mesophases, paving the way for advanced chiral optoelectronics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Conjugated polymers are vital for organic electronics, but their performance hinges on their solid-state morphology, which is largely dictated by how they aggregate in solution before deposition. Understanding and controlling these solution-state aggregates is a major challenge, especially when aiming for chiral structures from achiral building blocks. While previous work has shown that solvent selectivity can influence aggregate formation, the precise molecular attributes that govern the hierarchical assembly into chiral structures remain unclear. This paper tackles this by investigating how minor structural changes in achiral conjugated polymers (specifically, functionalization on the bithiophene unit) affect their solution aggregation and, consequently, their ability to form chiral helical liquid crystal mesophases.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize the polymers and their assemblies:

  • Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS) and Wide-Angle X-ray Scattering (WAXS): These techniques were used to probe the nanoscale structure of the polymer aggregates in solution, determining dimensions, packing, and the presence of lamellar and π-π stacking. Specialized SAXS models (2SFC and SA models) were adapted to fit the data.
  • Microscopy Techniques: Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM), Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), and Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) were used to visualize the morphology of freeze-dried samples, providing direct imaging of the aggregates and mesophases at both nanoscale and micron scales.
  • Cross-Polarized Optical Microscopy (CPOM): This was used to observe the liquid crystal mesophases formed at higher concentrations, revealing different morphologies like isotropic phases, twist-bent mesophases, and striped twist-bent mesophases.
  • Circular Dichroism (CD) Spectroscopy: This technique was crucial for quantifying the chirality of the mesophases by measuring the dissymmetry factor (g-factor), which indicates the degree of optical activity.
  • Density Functional Theory (DFT) Calculations: DFT was employed to model the molecular conformations of the polymers, specifically analyzing the torsional barriers and dihedral angles of the thiophene units to understand their inherent flexibility or rigidity.
  • UV-Vis Absorption and Raman Spectroscopy: These spectroscopic methods provided complementary information on polymer conformation in solution, probing conjugation length and backbone torsional disorder.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental characterization and theoretical modeling of synthesized polymers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Not all aggregates are made the same": This central theme highlights that even subtle molecular changes can lead to drastically different solution aggregate structures (1D fibers vs. 2D sheets).
  • Dimensionality Matters: The dimensionality of the primary solution aggregate (1D fibers vs. 2D sheets) is a key determinant of the hierarchical chiral helical assembly and the resulting pitch length of the mesophases.
  • Rigidity vs. Flexibility: The rigidity of the polymer backbone, influenced by side-chain functionalization (e.g., fluorine promoting planarity and rigidity, methyl groups promoting torsion), directly impacts the internal structure of aggregates and the resulting mesophase properties.
  • Chirality from Achirality: The study demonstrates a powerful strategy for generating chiral structures from achiral polymers by controlling their self-assembly pathways.
  • High Chiroptical Performance: The DPP-T2F2 system, with its rigid 1D fibers and ordered packing, achieved a remarkably high anisotropic dissymmetry factor (g-factor) of 0.09, showcasing the potential for high-performance chiral optoelectronic devices.

Key Results

  • Distinct Aggregates:
    • DPP-T2M2 and DPP-T2F2 form semicrystalline 1D fiber aggregates. DPP-T2F2 fibers are strongly bound and rigid, while DPP-T2M2 fibers are weakly bound and more flexible.
  • DPP-T4 forms highly crystalline 2D sheet aggregates.
  • Chiral Mesophase Formation: All three polymers form lyotropic chiral helical liquid crystal mesophases at higher concentrations.
  • Pitch Length Modulation: The dimensionality of the aggregates significantly influences the helical pitch length. DPP-T4 (2D sheets) exhibits much larger pitch lengths (e.g., 1365 ± 254 µm for striped twist-bent mesophase) compared to DPP-T2M2 and DPP-T2F2 (1D fibers, e.g., 595 ± 149 µm and 220 ± 35 µm, respectively).
  • High g-factor: DPP-T2F2 achieved a maximum g-factor of 0.09, attributed to its small helical pitch and long-range order.
  • Molecular Conformation: DFT calculations and spectroscopy revealed that fluorine substitution in DPP-T2F2 promotes a planar and rigid backbone, while methyl groups in DPP-T2M2 lead to a more torsional and flexible backbone. DPP-T4's flexible T-T dihedral allows easy adaptation to crystallization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Handedness Inversion: The study notes a stochastic character in the handedness of the chiral mesophases and an inversion from twist-bent to striped twist-bent mesophases, the origin of which is currently unknown. This presents an avenue for future investigation.
  • Mechanism of Handedness Inversion: Further research is needed to elucidate the underlying mechanisms driving the observed handedness inversion.
  • Broader Applicability: While this study focuses on DPP-based polymers, exploring similar structure-property relationships in other conjugated polymer systems could broaden the understanding and application of this assembly strategy.
  • Device Integration: The paper suggests that this work can catalyze the field of chiral (opto)electronics. Future work would involve translating these controlled hierarchical assemblies into functional devices to demonstrate their potential in applications like circularly polarized light emission or detection.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the solution-state aggregate structure and the consequent hierarchical assembly of conjugated polymers is crucial for controlling multiscale morphologies during solid thin-film deposition and the resultant electronic properties. However, it remains challenging to comprehend detailed solution aggregate structures of conjugated polymers, let alone their chiral assembly due to the complex aggregation behavior. Herein, we present solution-state aggregate structures and their impact on hierarchical chiral helical assembly using an achiral diketopyrrolopyrrole-quaterthiophene (DPP-T4) copolymer and its two close structural analogues wherein the bithiophene is functionalized with methyl groups (DPP-T2M2) or fluorine atoms (DPP-T2F2). Combining in-depth small-angle X-ray scattering analysis with various microscopic solution imaging techniques, we find distinct aggregate in each DPP solution: (i) semicrystalline 1D fiber aggregates of DPP-T2F2 with a strongly bound internal structure, (ii) semicrystalline 1D fiber aggregates of DPP-T2M2 with a weakly bound internal structure, and (iii) highly crystalline 2D sheet aggregates of DPP-T4. These nanoscopic aggregates develop into lyotropic chiral helical liquid crystal (LC) mesophases at high solution concentrations. Intriguingly, the dimensionality of solution aggregates largely modulates hierarchical chiral helical pitches across nanoscopic to micrometer scales, with the more rigid 2D sheet aggregate of DPP-T4 creating much larger pitch length than the more flexible 1D fiber aggregates. Combining relatively small helical pitch with long-range order, the striped twist-bent mesophase of DPP-T2F2 composed of highly ordered, more rigid 1D fiber aggregate exhibits an anisotropic dissymmetry factor (g-factor) as high as 0.09. This study can be a prominent addition to our knowledge on a solution-state hierarchical assembly of conjugated polymers and, in particular, chiral helical assembly of achiral organic semiconductors that can catalyze an emerging field of chiral (opto)electronics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{park2023subtle,
  author = {Kyung Sun Park and Xuyi Luo and Justin J. Kwok and Azzaya Khasbaatar and Jianguo Mei and Ying Diao},
  title = {{Subtle Molecular Changes Largely Modulate Chiral Helical Assemblies of Achiral Conjugated Polymers by Tuning Solution-State Aggregation}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1021/acscentsci.3c00775},
}
Figure