Substratum interactions determine immune response to allogeneic transplants of endothelial cells

Elise C. Wilcox, Elazer R. EdelmanFrontiers in Immunology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the physical environment (substratum) on which endothelial cells (ECs) grow significantly alters their immune signaling capabilities. This difference in EC phenotype, driven by whether they are cultured in 2D or 3D, directly impacts how the immune system responds to transplanted ECs, influencing both the type and intensity of the immune reaction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting and controlling the immune response to transplanted cells, particularly endothelial cells (ECs), remains a major challenge in regenerative medicine and transplantation. ECs are crucial for vascular health and play a significant role in immune regulation. However, their behavior and immune signaling are known to be influenced by their microenvironment. The authors aim to understand how the physical "bed" or substratum on which ECs grow affects their state and, consequently, their interaction with the immune system, specifically in the context of allogeneic (genetically different) cell transplantation. This is critical because current cell-based therapies often involve implanting cells in different physical configurations, and understanding how this impacts immune rejection or acceptance is key to successful outcomes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining in vitro and in vivo techniques:

  • RNA Sequencing (RNAseq): Used to comprehensively analyze the gene expression profiles of ECs cultured on different substrata (2D tissue culture plastic vs. 3D collagen scaffolds) under both basal and cytokine-stimulated (inflammatory) conditions. This allowed them to identify differences in the expression of key immune-related molecules.
  • Animal Models: An allogeneic rat transplantation model was established where ECs (either 2D or 3D cultured, and either "freed" from their substratum or implanted within their scaffold) were transplanted subcutaneously.
  • Immune Response Assays:
    • Cytotoxicity Assay: Measured the ability of splenocytes (immune cells) from transplanted rats to kill target ECs ex vivo.
  • IFNγ ELISA: Quantified the release of Interferon-gamma, a key cytokine involved in immune responses, from co-cultured splenocytes and ECs.
  • T Cell Proliferation Assay: Assessed the extent to which splenocytes proliferated when exposed to ECs.
  • Serum Antibody Assays: Measured levels of IgM and IgG antibodies specific to the transplanted ECs in the serum of the recipient rats.
  • Histological Analysis: Examined explanted scaffolds and surrounding tissue to assess immune cell infiltration, scaffold integrity, and EC viability.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study generated gene expression data from RNA sequencing of ECs under various conditions. This data was analyzed using tools like DESeq2 and g:Profiler for differential gene expression and functional enrichment analysis. The in vivo experiments generated immunological data (cytotoxicity, cytokine release, proliferation, antibody levels) from animal models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Substratum Dictates EC Phenotype: The physical environment (2D vs. 3D) profoundly shapes EC gene expression and function, even under inflammatory conditions. Cytokines don't force 2D and 3D ECs into a single "activated" state; they maintain their distinct substratum-driven phenotypes.
  • 3D ECs are More Responsive to Inflammation: Generally, ECs cultured in 3D scaffolds were more sensitive to inflammatory stimuli (cytokines) than their 2D counterparts.
  • 2D ECs Drive Cytotoxicity, 3D ECs Drive Proliferation: A critical finding is that ECs grown in 2D are more likely to elicit a strong cytotoxic T cell response in vivo, while 3D-cultured ECs tend to induce T cell proliferation. This suggests different modes of immune engagement based on physical context.
  • Physical Barrier Matters: The 3D scaffold itself acts as a physical barrier, influencing immune cell infiltration and potentially modulating the immune response differently than just the EC phenotype alone.
  • Memory Response Differences: While 2D-freed ECs induce a robust cytotoxic memory response, 3D scaffold-adherent ECs also induce a memory response, but it appears to be a different type, potentially less cytotoxic.

Key Results

  • Gene Expression: RNAseq revealed significant differences in the basal expression and cytokine-induced upregulation of key immune molecules (MHC class I/II, adhesion molecules like ICAM1/VCAM1, and co-stimulatory molecules like PD-L1) between 2D and 3D ECs. For example, 3D ECs showed greater upregulation of MHC class I and associated TAP proteins upon cytokine stimulation.
  • Cytotoxicity: Rats implanted with 2D-freed ECs (2Df) consistently showed higher splenocyte-mediated cytotoxicity against ECs, both acutely and chronically, compared to 3D-implanted groups.
  • IFNγ Release: While acute responses showed some trends, chronic responses and booster experiments highlighted differences, with 3DSF (3D scaffold-adherent) ECs showing higher IFNγ release in some scenarios compared to 3Df (3D freed) ECs.
  • T Cell Proliferation: 3D scaffold-adherent (3DSF) ECs generally induced greater T cell proliferation compared to 2D-freed (2Df) or 3D-freed (3Df) ECs, particularly in the acute and chronic settings.
  • Serum Antibodies: 2D-freed ECs led to higher levels of both IgM and IgG antibodies, while 3D-freed ECs showed lower levels. 3D scaffold-adherent ECs showed elevated IgG but lower IgM.
  • Histology: Immune cells infiltrated the periphery of 3D scaffolds but largely did not reach the hypoxic center. CD31 staining indicated EC retention in acute implants but poor viability in chronic implants, suggesting potential issues with long-term survival in the scaffold. HIF-1α staining confirmed hypoxic conditions within the scaffold.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rodent Model Limitations: The authors acknowledge that differences exist between rodent and human EC signaling (e.g., constitutive MHC class II expression in humans vs. rodents, differences in CD2 signaling importance). This limits direct translation to human applications.
  • Hypoxia in 3D Scaffolds: The hypoxic environment within the 3D scaffolds likely impacted EC viability and immune cell penetration, potentially contributing to the observed differences. Future work could explore strategies to mitigate this.
  • Specific T Cell Subsets: The study broadly examined T cell responses. Future work should delve into the specific effects of EC signaling on different T cell subsets (e.g., T helper cells, regulatory T cells).
  • Biomaterial Properties: While the study focused on EC phenotype, the physical properties of the scaffold itself (e.g., modulus) also play a role and could be further investigated.
  • Clinical Translation: The authors suggest that understanding these substratum-driven EC phenotypes could inform strategies for optimizing donor organ selection and developing more tailored transplant treatments, moving beyond simple metrics like ischemic time. The findings could also be applied to emerging ex vivo organ perfusion technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Endothelial cells (ECs) are central to vascular health but also interact with and regulate the immune system. Changes in endothelial state enable immune cells to migrate into the tissue to facilitate repair and fight infection. ECs modulate the function of immune cells through the expression of adhesion molecules, chemokines, major histocompatibility complex (MHC), and an array of co-stimulatory and inhibitor molecules. These interactions allow ECs to act as antigen presenting cells (APCs) and influence the outcome of immune recognition. This study elucidates how EC microenvironment, vascular cell biology, and immune response are not only connected but interdependent. More specifically, we explored how cell-substratum interactions influence EC antigen presentation and co-stimulation, and how these differences affect allorecognition in animal models of cell transplantation. Investigation of EC state was carried out using RNA sequencing while assessment of the allogeneic response includes measurements of immune cell cytotoxic ability, T cell proliferation, cytokine release, serum antibodies, and histological staining. Differences in substratum led to divergent EC phenotypes which in turn influenced immune response to transplanted cells, both due to the physical barrier of matrix-adhesion and differences in expression of surface markers. ECs grown in 2D on tissue culture plastic or in 3D on collagen scaffolds had significantly different basal levels of MHC expression, co-stimulatory and adhesion molecules. When treated with cytokines to mimic an inflammatory state, ECs did not converge to a single phenotype but rather responded differently based on their substratum. Generally, 3D ECs were more responsive to inflammatory stimuli than 2D ECs. These unique expression patterns measured <i>in vitro</i> also influence immune recognition <i>in vivo</i>. ECs grown in 2D were more likely to provoke a cytotoxic response while 3D ECs induced T cell proliferation. ECs are uniquely configured to sense not only local flow and mechanical forces but a range of markers related to systemic state, including immune function. ECs interact with immune cells with differing results depending on the environment in which the EC-lymphocyte interaction occurs. Therefore, understanding this relationship is essential to predicting and modifying the outcome of EC-immune interacts. We specifically examined the relationship between EC substratum and allorecognition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wilcox2022substratum,
  author = {Elise C. Wilcox and Elazer R. Edelman},
  title = {{Substratum interactions determine immune response to allogeneic transplants of endothelial cells}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Immunology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fimmu.2022.946794},
}
Figure