Subseasonal‐to‐interdecadal variability of the Australian monsoon over North Queensland

Andrew W. Robertson, Sergey Kirshner, Padhraic Smyth, Stephen P. Charles, Bryson C. BatesQuarterly 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a Hidden Markov Model (HMM) to identify five distinct "weather states" that characterize daily rainfall variability in North Queensland. These states are linked to specific atmospheric circulation patterns, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of monsoon variability across subseasonal, interannual, and interdecadal timescales. The HMM also proves useful for simulating and potentially forecasting rainfall patterns.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Australian monsoon, particularly over North Queensland, is known for its significant variability across different timescales, from daily active/break periods to longer-term decadal shifts. Previous research has described the general climatology and some aspects of this variability, but a unified framework to understand how daily rainfall patterns evolve and relate to atmospheric circulation across these diverse timescales has been lacking. Specifically, the paper aims to move beyond simple averages and explore the underlying discrete states that govern rainfall and how their frequencies change over time, connecting local weather to broader climate phenomena like ENSO and MJO.

Methods

The core methodology is the application of a Hidden Markov Model (HMM). This statistical framework is used to model the observed daily rainfall at a network of 11 stations. The HMM assumes that the observed rainfall is generated by a sequence of unobserved "hidden states." The authors identified five discrete rainfall states by fitting the HMM to 40 years of daily rainfall data. These states are characterized by different combinations of rainfall occurrence and intensity across the stations. Crucially, the paper then composites atmospheric circulation data (850-hPa winds and 500-hPa omega) for days assigned to each state, linking the rainfall states to specific weather regimes. For prediction, they introduce a non-homogeneous HMM (NHMM), where the state transition probabilities are influenced by external predictors like large-scale precipitation from reanalysis or GCMs, and antecedent sea surface temperatures (SSTs).

Datasets

  • Observed Daily Rainfall Data: 11 stations in North Queensland, spanning the October 1 – April 15 period from 1958–1998. Data was sourced from the Patched Point Dataset (PPD), which includes infilling for missing data.
  • Atmospheric Circulation Data: NCEP-NCAR reanalysis data and ECMWF ERA-40 data were used for constructing atmospheric circulation composites associated with the identified rainfall states.
  • Predictor Data for NHMM:
    • NCEP-NCAR reanalysis large-scale precipitation fields.
  • ECHAM4.5 General Circulation Model (GCM) simulations forced with observed SSTs.
  • Antecedent (June-August) Pacific SST anomalies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rainfall States as Building Blocks: The identification of five distinct rainfall states provides a powerful way to decompose the complex variability of the monsoon. Instead of looking at continuous averages, we can analyze the frequency and transitions between these discrete states.
  • Linking Local Weather to Global Patterns: The strong association between these rainfall states and specific atmospheric circulation patterns (e.g., monsoonal ascent for wet states, subtropical descent for dry states) offers a clear mechanism for understanding how large-scale climate drivers influence regional rainfall.
  • Monsoon "Onset" is Complex: The paper challenges the notion of a simple, well-defined monsoon onset date, suggesting that the monsoon's evolution is better described as a probabilistic progression through different states, with significant year-to-year variability.
  • Interdecadal Shifts are Significant: The finding that stronger monsoons were prevalent in the 1970s, followed by a weaker regime and increased dry states, highlights the importance of considering longer-term climate variability and its potential impact on regional water resources.
  • Predictive Skill Varies: While reanalysis data shows good skill in simulating interannual rainfall variability, GCM simulations and SST predictors are less successful, suggesting that improving GCM precipitation simulation and understanding the SST-rainfall link are crucial for better seasonal forecasting.

Key Results

  • Five Rainfall States Identified: The HMM successfully identified five distinct rainfall states, including three general states (very wet, moderately wet, dry) and two coastal states (enhanced coastal rainfall with inland dryness).
  • State-Circulation Linkages: Each state was associated with statistically significant atmospheric circulation anomalies. For example, the "very wet" state (State 5) showed large-scale ascent and monsoonal westerlies, while the "dry" state (State 2) was linked to subtropical descent and SE trade winds.
  • Seasonal Cycle of States: The average seasonal cycle showed a progression from dry states in early summer to wet states in January-February, with coastal states becoming more prevalent later in the season.
  • Interannual Variability and ENSO: The dry state (State 2) was strongly correlated with El Niño conditions, while wet states (1 and 5) showed associations with La Niña.
  • Interdecadal Trend: A notable trend of weaker monsoons and increased dry states was observed from the late 1970s onwards.
  • Simulation Skill: NHMM simulations using NCEP-NCAR reanalysis precipitation showed relatively accurate interannual variability of rainfall occurrence and amount (correlation of 0.82 and 0.79, respectively). GCM predictors led to degraded simulation quality, while antecedent SST predictors showed comparable skill to the GCM.

Limitations and Future Work

  • GCM Predictor Limitations: The study found that using GCM simulations as predictors for the NHMM resulted in significantly degraded simulation quality compared to reanalysis data. This highlights the ongoing challenges in accurately simulating regional precipitation with GCMs.
  • SST Predictor Caveats: While antecedent Pacific SSTs showed comparable skill to GCMs, the authors note that the criteria for selecting these predictors were based on Queensland rainfall itself, potentially overstating their predictive skill.
  • Predictor Selection: The paper acknowledges that the choice of predictors for the NHMM is somewhat subjective, and further work is needed to determine the most appropriate variables for improving seasonal climate forecasts.
  • Rainfall Intensity Prediction: The NHMM simulations were less successful in capturing the interannual variability of rainfall intensity compared to occurrence and amount.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that NHMMs could be a valuable tool for assessing the potential of seasonal climate forecasts to be downscaled in time. They also mention that preliminary work with multi-model GCM ensembles suggests improved skill, indicating that combining multiple GCMs might be a promising avenue. Further investigation into the specific atmospheric circulation patterns that can lead to similar rainfall patterns (especially for the dry state) is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Daily rainfall occurrence and amount at 11 stations over North Queensland are examined for summers 1958–1998, using a Hidden Markov Model (HMM). Daily rainfall variability is described in terms of the occurrence of five discrete ‘weather states’, identified by the HMM. Three states are characterized respectively by very wet, moderately wet, and dry conditions at most stations; two states have enhanced rainfall along the coast and dry conditions inland. Each HMM rainfall state is associated with a distinct atmospheric circulation regime. The two wet states are accompanied by monsoonal circulation patterns with large‐scale ascent, low‐level inflow from the north‐west, and a phase reversal with height; the dry state is characterized by circulation anomalies of the opposite sense. Two of the states show significant associations with midlatitude synoptic waves. Variability of the monsoon on time‐scales from subseasonal to interdecadal is interpreted in terms of changes in the frequency of occurrence of the five HMM rainfall states. Large subseasonal variability is identified in terms of active and break phases, and a highly variable monsoon onset date. The occurrence of the very wet and dry states is somewhat modulated by the Madden–Julian oscillation. On interannual time‐scales, there are clear relationships with the El Niño–Southern Oscillation and Indian Ocean sea surface temperatures (SSTs). Interdecadal monsoonal variability is characterized by stronger monsoons during the 1970s, and weaker monsoons plus an increased prevalence of drier states in the later part of the record. Stochastic simulations of daily rainfall occurrence and amount at the 11 stations are generated by introducing predictors based on large‐scale precipitation from (a) reanalysis data, (b) an atmospheric general circulation model (GCM) run with observed SST forcing and (c) antecedent June–August Pacific SST anomalies. The reanalysis large‐scale precipitation yields relatively accurate station‐level simulations of the interannual variability of daily rainfall amount and occurrence, with rainfall intensity less well simulated. At some stations, interannual variations in 10‐day dry‐spell frequency are also simulated reasonably well. The interannual quality of the simulations is markedly degraded when the GCM simulations are used as inputs, while antecedent Pacific SST inputs yield an anomaly correlation skill comparable to that of the GCM. Copyright © 2006 Royal Meteorological Society
BibTeX
@inproceedings{robertson2006subseasonaltointerdecadal,
  author = {Andrew W. Robertson and Sergey Kirshner and Padhraic Smyth and Stephen P. Charles and Bryson C. Bates},
  title = {{Subseasonal‐to‐interdecadal variability of the Australian monsoon over North Queensland}},
  booktitle = {Quarterly},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1256/qj.05.75},
}
Figure