Submarine groundwater discharge in Dongshan Bay, China: A master regulator of nutrients in spring and potential national significance of small bays

Yafei Sun, Guizhi Wang, Yubin Weng, Qing Li, Fei Zhang, Weizhen Jiang, Guiyuan Dai, Wen Lin, Shengyao Sun, Yiyong Jiang, Yuanjing ZhangFrontiers in Marine Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Submarine groundwater discharge (SGD)—the "invisible" flow of water from the seabed to the ocean—is the primary driver of nutrient levels in China's small coastal bays, accounting for over 95% of their nutrient load. This study reveals that while large estuaries get all the headlines, the cumulative impact of SGD in small bays (<500 km²) actually delivers twice as much dissolved inorganic nitrogen to the national coastline as their larger counterparts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal eutrophication (excessive nutrient enrichment leading to algal blooms and oxygen depletion) is a global crisis. Traditionally, scientists and policymakers focus on "point sources" like river runoff and sewage pipes. However, Submarine Groundwater Discharge (SGD) is a significant but often overlooked "non-point" source of nutrients.

In China, approximately 90% of coastal bays are classified as "small" (<500 km²). Despite their abundance, most research has focused on massive systems like the Yangtze or Pearl River estuaries. This creates a massive knowledge gap: are these small bays negligible in the national nutrient budget, or are we missing a critical piece of the environmental puzzle? The authors used Dongshan Bay as a case study to quantify the role of SGD in these smaller, yet ubiquitous, ecosystems.

Methods

The researchers employed radium isotopes ($^{226}Ra$ and $^{228}Ra$) as natural geochemical tracers. Radium is highly enriched in groundwater compared to seawater, making it an ideal "fingerprint" for tracking SGD.

Key components of their approach included:

  • Hydrographic Mapping: A bay-wide survey in May 2020 to map salinity, temperature, nutrients, and radium activities.
  • Time-Series Observation: A 12-hour investigation at a specific site (Site Z6) to observe how tidal cycles influence radium and nutrient concentrations.
  • Mass Balance Modeling: The authors constructed a radium mass balance model to calculate the SGD rate, accounting for river inputs, sediment diffusion, and mixing with offshore water.
  • National Extrapolation: Using k-means clustering, they classified China's bays by size and extrapolated their findings to estimate the national significance of SGD-derived nutrients from small bays.

Datasets

This study relied on original field data collected by the authors:

  • Dongshan Bay Survey (May 2020): Surface and bottom water samples from 13 stations.
  • Groundwater & River Sampling: Samples collected in December 2020 and August 2021 to capture seasonal end-member concentrations.
  • National Bay Database: A compilation of physical parameters (area, shoreline length, etc.) for Chinese embayments used for the k-means clustering and scaling analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Master Regulator": The correlation between $^{228}Ra$ and nutrients was extraordinarily high ($R^2 > 0.90$). This suggests that SGD isn't just a contributor; it is the dominant force controlling nutrient distribution in the bay, far outweighing riverine input or atmospheric deposition.
  • The Hotspot Effect: The study identified an SGD "hotspot" in the center of the bay (Site Z6). Interestingly, this hotspot co-occurred with the highest chlorophyll-a concentrations, suggesting that groundwater-fed nutrients are directly fueling local algal blooms.
  • Small Bays, Big Impact: While a single small bay might seem insignificant, they collectively punch way above their weight class. Because small bays have a higher ratio of shoreline/seabed area to water volume, the relative impact of SGD is magnified compared to large, deep estuaries.
  • The Nitrogen Paradox: On a national scale, the flux of dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) carried by SGD in small bays was found to be roughly twice as high as that in large bays (>2,000 km²).

Key Results

  • SGD Rate: The bay-wide average SGD rate was estimated at $0.048 \pm 0.022$ m/day.
  • Nutrient Contribution: SGD accounts for over 95% of the DIN, soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP), and dissolved silicate (DSi) in Dongshan Bay.
  • National Scale: The total estimated nutrient flux via SGD along the entire Chinese coastline is approximately $2.57 \times 10^8$ mol/day for DIN. Small bays are the primary drivers of this total.
  • Biological Link: Chlorophyll-a levels (a proxy for algal biomass) peaked at $5.02 \mu g/L$ near the SGD hotspot, providing strong evidence that SGD supports primary productivity and potential blooms.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their bay-wide mapping was conducted during a single season (spring). While they sampled groundwater in different seasons to establish "end-members," the actual SGD rate likely fluctuates throughout the year based on monsoon rainfall and land-use changes.

Future research should focus on:

  1. Long-term Monitoring: Multi-season studies to capture the full temporal variability of SGD.
  2. Biogeochemical Transformations: Investigating how nutrients change as they pass through the "subterranean estuary" (the mixing zone in the aquifer) before entering the bay.
  3. Management Integration: Incorporating SGD into coastal management strategies, as current policies focusing solely on rivers may fail to prevent eutrophication in small bays.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite over 90% of China’s coastal bays have an area less than 500 km 2 , the geochemical effects of SGD on those ecosystems are ambiguous. Based on mapping and time-series observations of Ra isotopes and nutrients, a case study of small bays (&amp;lt;500 km 2 ), we revealed that submarine groundwater discharge (SGD) predominately regulated the distribution of nutrients and fueled algal growth in Dongshan Bay, China. On the bay-wide scale, the SGD rate was estimated to be 0.048 ± 0.022 m day −1 and contributed over 95% of the nutrients. At the time-series site where the bay-wide highest Ra activities in the bottom water marked an SGD hotspot with an average rate an order of magnitude greater, the maximum chlorophyll concentration co-occurred, suggesting that SGD may support the algal bloom. The ever-most significant positive correlations between 228 Ra and nutrients throughout the water column (P&amp;lt; 0.01, R 2 &amp;gt; 0.90 except for soluble reactive phosphorus in the surface) suggested the predominance of SGD in controlling nutrient distribution in the bay. Extrapolated to a national scale, the SGD-carried dissolved inorganic nitrogen flux in small bays was twice as much as those in large bays (&amp;gt;2,000 km 2 ). Thus, the SGD-carried nutrients in small bays merit immediate attention in environmental monitoring and management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2023submarine,
  author = {Yafei Sun and Guizhi Wang and Yubin Weng and Qing Li and Fei Zhang and Weizhen Jiang and Guiyuan Dai and Wen Lin and Shengyao Sun and Yiyong Jiang and Yuanjing Zhang},
  title = {{Submarine groundwater discharge in Dongshan Bay, China: A master regulator of nutrients in spring and potential national significance of small bays}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2023.1164589},
}
Figure