Subgame Optimal and Prior-Independent Online Algorithms

Jason D. Hartline, Aleck C. Johnsen, Anant ShaharXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Traditional online algorithms are typically evaluated by their worst-case competitive ratio, a metric that often results in overly pessimistic decision-making. This paper proposes two alternative paradigms—subgame optimality and prior-independence—to design algorithms that exploit "mistakes" made by non-worst-case adversaries. By modeling online algorithm design as a two-player zero-sum game, we develop strategies that remain robust even when the environment deviates from the absolute worst case. We apply these concepts to the finite-horizon ski-rental problem, providing a full mathematical characterization of subgame optimal algorithms and a Fully Polynomial Time Approximation Scheme (FPTAS) for computing prior-independent optimal strategies.

Introduction

In online computation, an algorithm must make decisions without full knowledge of future inputs. The standard benchmark for such algorithms is the competitive ratio, which compares the algorithm's performance against an optimal offline adversary. However, worst-case analysis often fails to account for scenarios where the input is not maximally adversarial. A "worst-case optimal" algorithm may perform poorly on benign inputs because it was never designed to capitalize on the "slack" provided by a non-optimal adversary.

This research addresses two primary gaps in current theory:

  1. Subgame Optimality: Ensuring an algorithm remains optimal even when the input sequence deviates from the worst case (i.e., when the algorithm is "off-path").
  2. Prior-Independence: Designing algorithms that perform well across a class of distributions when the specific input distribution (the "prior") is unknown, moving away from purely adversarial models toward distributional ones.

Methodology

The authors frame the design of online algorithms as an extensive-form game between an algorithm designer and an adversary. The finite-horizon ski-rental problem—deciding whether to rent or buy equipment with an unknown number of usage days remaining—serves as the primary testbed.

Subgame Optimality

While standard algorithms focus on optimality from the initial state, a subgame optimal algorithm must be optimal at every decision node. This ensures that if an adversary provides a sub-optimal input, the algorithm adjusts its strategy to exploit the remaining horizon optimally rather than remaining "indifferent" to the non-worst-case input.

Prior-Independent Framework

In this setting, the adversary chooses a distribution (i.i.d. over time) rather than a fixed sequence. To find an optimal strategy without knowing the prior, the authors develop an FPTAS. This scheme utilizes:

  • Small-Cover: Discretizing the space of possible distributions to make the problem computationally tractable.
  • Best-Response Oracles: Using techniques like backwards induction to find the optimal algorithm for a specific distribution.
  • Online Learning: Applying the Multiplicative Weights Update (MWU) algorithm to find an approximate Nash equilibrium in the game between the distribution and the algorithm.

Key Results and Empirical Analysis

The study provides a mathematical characterization of subgame optimal algorithms for ski-rental and proves the computational efficiency of prior-independent algorithms, showing they can be computed in $O(T^{12}\epsilon^{-3})$ time.

Performance comparison of Worst-Case, Subgame Optimal, and Prior-Independent algorithms across different values of B.

As shown in the figure above, the prior-independent algorithm consistently achieves the lowest (best) performance ratio across varying stopping costs ($B$). The subgame optimal algorithm also demonstrates a clear advantage over the standard worst-case optimal approach. These results confirm that moving beyond simple worst-case analysis allows for more efficient and robust online decision-making. Notably, the prior-independent ratio is generally lower because the i.i.d. assumption restricts the adversary's power compared to the unrestricted worst-case model.

Discussion and Limitations

While the proposed frameworks offer significant performance gains, challenges remain. The $T^{12}$ term in the FPTAS complexity, while polynomial, may be prohibitive for very large time horizons, suggesting a need for more efficient approximation techniques. Additionally, while the FPTAS framework is general, the specific proofs of "information symmetry" used here are tailored to the ski-rental problem. Future work will focus on extending these paradigms to more complex problems like the $k$-server problem and exploring non-i.i.d. distribution classes, such as Markovian inputs.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{hartline2024subgame,
  author = {Jason D. Hartline and Aleck C. Johnsen and Anant Shah},
  title = {{Subgame Optimal and Prior-Independent Online Algorithms}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2403.10451},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10451},
}
Figure