SUBDEGREE SUNYAEV-ZEL'DOVICH SIGNAL FROM MULTIFREQUENCY BOOMERANG OBSERVATIONS

M. Veneziani, A. Amblard, Asantha Cooray, F. Piacentini, D. Pietrobon, P. Serra, P. A. R. Ade, J. J. Bock, J. R. Bond, J. Borrill, A. Boscaleri, P. Cabella, Carlo Contaldi, B. P. Crill, P. de Bernardis, G. de Gasperis, A. de Oliveira‐Costa, G. De Troia, Giuseppe Di Stefano, K. Ganga, E. Hivon, W. C. Jones, T. S. Kisner, A. E. Lange, C. J. MacTavish, S. Masi, P. Mauskopf, A. Melchiorri, T. E. Montroy, P. Natoli, C. B. Netterfield, E. Pascale, G. Polenta, S. Ricciardi, G. Romeo, J. E. Ruhl, P. Santini, Max Tegmark, N. VittorioThe Astrophysical Journal 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first statistical limits on the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect at sub-degree angular scales using multifrequency data from the BOOMERANG 2003 experiment. By carefully separating the SZ signal from the primary Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and other foregrounds, the authors place constraints on the amplitude of density perturbations in the universe, finding values consistent with other cosmological probes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect is a crucial phenomenon where CMB photons are scattered by hot electrons in intervening gas, particularly in massive galaxy clusters. This scattering imprints a distinct spectral signature on the CMB, allowing us to probe the distribution of matter in the universe. While the SZ effect has been observed in individual galaxy clusters, understanding its contribution to the overall anisotropy power spectrum at arcminute scales (from unresolved clusters) has been challenging. This is due to the difficulty in separating the SZ signal from the dominant primary CMB anisotropies and other astrophysical foregrounds like Galactic dust and infrared sources. This paper aims to constrain the SZ anisotropy power spectrum at sub-degree scales, bridging the gap between cluster-specific observations and larger-scale cosmological measurements.

Methods

The core of the method involves a sophisticated statistical technique to extract the SZ signal from multifrequency CMB data. The authors employ a technique that minimizes the covariance of the data with respect to the known frequency dependence of the SZ effect, treating other signals (CMB, dust, etc.) as noise. This involves constructing a covariance matrix from the cross-spectra between different detectors and frequency channels. Optimal weights are then derived to reconstruct the SZ power spectrum. Crucially, the paper emphasizes the importance of detailed simulations to propagate errors and potential systematic effects, including instrumental noise, primary CMB, Galactic dust, FIRB, and radio point sources. They also account for the beam window function and calibration uncertainties.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the BOOMERANG 2003 flight, specifically measurements at three frequencies: 145 GHz, 245 GHz, and 345 GHz. The analysis focuses on a deep survey region covering approximately 100 square degrees. The paper also references and compares its results with data from other SZ experiments like SZA, CBI, BIMA, and ACBAR, as well as CMB data from WMAP.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SZ Signal Separation is Key: The success of this work hinges on the ability to disentangle the subtle SZ signal from the much brighter primary CMB and various astrophysical foregrounds. The multifrequency approach is essential for this.
  • Sub-degree SZ is a Cosmological Probe: The paper demonstrates that SZ fluctuations at these scales, arising from the integrated effect of unresolved structures, can be used to constrain fundamental cosmological parameters like the normalization of the matter power spectrum ($\sigma_8$).
  • Foregrounds are Significant: The study highlights that foreground contamination, particularly from Galactic dust and FIRB, is a major challenge in SZ measurements, even at these frequencies. Careful modeling and simulation are vital to account for these.
  • Consistency with CMB: The derived SZ constraints on $\sigma_8$ are found to be consistent with those obtained from primary CMB measurements (like WMAP), reinforcing the standard cosmological model.

Key Results

  • The paper provides an overall upper limit of 15.3 μK (2σ) for the root-mean-square (rms) SZ fluctuations in a broad bin between multipoles of 250 and 1200 at the Rayleigh-Jeans (RJ) end of the spectrum.
  • Using BOOMERANG SZ data alone, an upper limit on the local universe normalization of density perturbations is found to be $\sigma_8^{\text{SZ}} < 1.14$ at the 95% confidence level.
  • When combined with other CMB anisotropy and SZ measurements, this constraint tightens to $\sigma_8^{\text{SZ}} < 0.92$ (95% c.l.), which is consistent with WMAP 5-year results ($\sigma_8 = 0.81 \pm 0.02$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Frequency Coverage: The authors acknowledge that having only three frequency channels, with one near the SZ null, makes a perfect separation of all foregrounds challenging. More frequency channels, especially at higher frequencies where the SZ signal is positive, would improve this.
  • Foreground Model Dependence: The accuracy of the SZ constraints is dependent on the accuracy of the foreground models used in the simulations.
  • Future Work: The paper points to future experiments like Planck and OLIMPO, which will have multiple frequency bands, including those where the SZ signal is positive. These instruments will be better equipped to measure and separate FIRB from SZ fluctuations, leading to more precise cosmological constraints. The authors also suggest that a more aggressive approach, assuming no FIRB, could lead to a marginal detection of the SZ signal, but they deem this unrealistic given current uncertainties.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect is the inverse Compton-scattering of cosmic microwave background (CMB) photons by hot electrons in the intervening gas throughout the universe. The effect has a distinct spectral signature that allows its separation from other signals in multifrequency CMB data sets. Using CMB anisotropies measured at three frequencies by the BOOMERANG 2003 flight we constrain SZ fluctuations in the 10 arcmin to 1 deg angular range. Propagating errors and potential systematic effects through simulations, we obtain an overall upper limit of 15.3 μK (2σ) for rms SZ fluctuations in a broad bin between multipoles of 250 and 1200 at the Rayleigh-Jeans (RJ) end of the spectrum. The resulting upper limit on the local universe normalization of the density perturbations with BOOMERANG SZ data alone is σ^(SZ)_8 &lt; 1.14 at the 95% confidence level. When combined with other CMB anisotropy and SZ measurements, we find σ^(SZ)_8 &lt; 0.92 (95% c.l.).
BibTeX
@article{veneziani2009subdegree,
  author = {M. Veneziani and A. Amblard and Asantha Cooray and F. Piacentini and D. Pietrobon and P. Serra and P. A. R. Ade and J. J. Bock and J. R. Bond and J. Borrill and A. Boscaleri and P. Cabella and Carlo Contaldi and B. P. Crill and P. de Bernardis and G. de Gasperis and A. de Oliveira‐Costa and G. De Troia and Giuseppe Di Stefano and K. Ganga and E. Hivon and W. C. Jones and T. S. Kisner and A. E. Lange and C. J. MacTavish and S. Masi and P. Mauskopf and A. Melchiorri and T. E. Montroy and P. Natoli and C. B. Netterfield and E. Pascale and G. Polenta and S. Ricciardi and G. Romeo and J. E. Ruhl and P. Santini and Max Tegmark and N. Vittorio},
  title = {{SUBDEGREE SUNYAEV-ZEL'DOVICH SIGNAL FROM MULTIFREQUENCY BOOMERANG OBSERVATIONS}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1088/0004-637x/702/1/l61},
}
Figure