Subchondral Pathology: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meeting on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle

Yoshiharu Shimozono, Alexandra J. Brown, Jorge Batista, Christopher D. Murawski, Mohamed Gomaa, Siu Wah Kong, Tanawat Vaseenon, Masato Takao, Mark Glazebrook, Jakob Ackermann, Samuel B. Adams, Carol L. Andrews, Chayanin Angthong, O Baur, Steve Bayer, Christoph Becher, Gregory C. Berlet, Lorraine A. T. Boakye, Roberto Buda, James Calder, Gian Luigi Canata, Dominic S. Carreira, Thomas O. Clanton, Jari Dahmen, Pieter D’Hooghe, Christopher W. DiGiovanni, Malcolm E. Dombrowski, Mark C. Drakos, Richard D. Ferkel, Paulo N. F. Ferrao, Lisa A. Fortier, Eric Giza, Simon Görtz, Amgad M. Haleem, Kamran S. Hamid, László Hangody, Charles P. Hannon, Daniël Haverkamp, Jay Hertel, Beat Hintermann, MaCalus V. Hogan, Kenneth J. Hunt, Eoghan T. Hurley, Jón Karlsson, Stephen R. Kearns, John G. Kennedy, Gino M. M. J. Kerkhoffs, Hak Jun Kim, Sameh A. Labib, Kaj T. A. Lambers, Jin Woo Lee, Keun Bae Lee, Jeffrey S. Ling, Umile Giuseppe Longo, Alberto Marangon, Graham McCollum, Adam Mitchell, Peter N. Mittwede, Stefan Nehrer, Philipp Niemeyer, James A. Nunley, Martin O’Malley, David O. Osei-Hwedieh, Jochen Paul, Christopher J. Pearce, Hélder Pereira, Adam Popchak, Marcelo Pires Prado, Steven M. Raikin, Mikel L. Reilingh, Benjamin B. Rothrauff, Lew C. Schon, Helene Simpson, Niall A. Smyth, Carolyn M. Sofka, Pietro Spennacchio, James W. Stone, Martin Sullivan, Yasuhito Tanaka, David B. Thordarson, Rocky S. Tuan, Víctor Valderrábano, Christiaan J. A. van Bergen, C. Niek van Dijk, Pim A. D. van Dijk, Francesca Vannini, Markus Walther, Martin Wiewiorski, Xiangyang Xu, Youichi Yasui, Yinghui Hua, Ichiro Yoshimura, Alastair Younger, Zijun ZhangFoot 2018 · DOI

Abstract: This international consensus statements regarding subchondral pathology of the talus derived from leaders in the field will assist clinicians in the assessment and management of this difficult pathology.

Introduction

The subchondral bone serves as the essential structural foundation and "shock absorber" for the ankle joint. When this bone fails—whether through cysts, lesions, or bone marrow edema (BME)—it often precipitates debilitating pain and eventual cartilage collapse. Despite its critical role in joint health, the orthopaedic community has historically lacked a standardized "gold standard" for treatment. Most existing literature consists of low-quality evidence with limited follow-up, leaving surgeons to rely on anecdotal experience. This paper presents the findings of the first major international consensus meeting dedicated to bridging this gap.

Methodology

To establish reliable guidelines, the authors employed a modified Delphi method, a structured communication technique designed to reach consensus among a panel of 75 international experts from 25 countries. The process involved:

  1. Literature Review: A comprehensive review was conducted to grade existing evidence using a standardized scale ranging from high-level meta-analyses to expert opinion.
  2. Iterative Voting: Experts participated in multiple rounds of blinded electronic surveys.
  3. Consensus Thresholds: Statements were categorized by agreement levels: "Consensus" (51-74%), "Strong Consensus" (75-99%), or "Unanimous" (100%).
The evidence grading scale used by the expert panel to evaluate the strength of existing clinical literature.

Clinical Guidelines and Key Insights

The consensus meeting produced nine formal statements to guide clinical practice. Key clinical takeaways include:

  • The "Intact Cartilage" Rule: Retrograde drilling—approaching the lesion from the side or back to avoid the joint surface—is specifically recommended when the overlying articular cartilage remains healthy.
  • Conservative Management for Edema: Bone marrow edema (BME) should not be treated surgically as a first-line option. The consensus mandates a minimum of three months of conservative treatment, including non-weightbearing and anti-inflammatories, before surgical intervention is considered.
  • Surgical Precision: While intraoperative imaging (e.g., fluoroscopy) is essential to ensure accurate drill placement, the panel noted that high-tech computer-aided navigation or robotic assistance is currently unnecessary for these procedures.
  • Thresholds for Bone Grafting: The group established concrete physical "triggers" for grafting. If a lesion exceeds 1 cm in depth, 1 cm in width, or a volume of 100 mm³, simple drilling is insufficient; the void must be packed with a graft.

Results and Discussion

All nine formal consensus statements reached the "Strong Consensus" threshold (at least 81% agreement), though notably, no statement achieved 100% unanimity. This reflects the inherent complexity and ongoing controversy surrounding subchondral bone pathology. Cancellous bone grafting was identified as the preferred method for filling bone voids, as current evidence is insufficient to support the widespread use of synthetic bone substitutes.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors acknowledge that these guidelines primarily represent Level E evidence (expert opinion) due to the weakness of existing clinical literature. These statements serve as a "best guess" by global leaders rather than absolute biological truths.

Future work must focus on high-level randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to compare drill sizes and graft materials. Furthermore, long-term data (5-10 years) is required to determine if these interventions successfully prevent the progression of long-term arthritis. This consensus is intended to be a "living document," updated as higher-quality evidence emerges.

Summary updated

Abstract

This international consensus statements regarding subchondral pathology of the talus derived from leaders in the field will assist clinicians in the assessment and management of this difficult pathology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shimozono2018subchondral,
  author = {Yoshiharu Shimozono and Alexandra J. Brown and Jorge Batista and Christopher D. Murawski and Mohamed Gomaa and Siu Wah Kong and Tanawat Vaseenon and Masato Takao and Mark Glazebrook and Jakob Ackermann and Samuel B. Adams and Carol L. Andrews and Chayanin Angthong and Jorge Batista and O Baur and Steve Bayer and Christoph Becher and Gregory C. Berlet and Lorraine A. T. Boakye and Roberto Buda and James Calder and Gian Luigi Canata and Dominic S. Carreira and Thomas O. Clanton and Jari Dahmen and Pieter D’Hooghe and Christopher W. DiGiovanni and Malcolm E. Dombrowski and Mark C. Drakos and Richard D. Ferkel and Paulo N. F. Ferrao and Lisa A. Fortier and Eric Giza and Simon Görtz and Amgad M. Haleem and Kamran S. Hamid and László Hangody and Charles P. Hannon and Daniël Haverkamp and Jay Hertel and Beat Hintermann and MaCalus V. Hogan and Kenneth J. Hunt and Eoghan T. Hurley and Jón Karlsson and Stephen R. Kearns and John G. Kennedy and Gino M. M. J. Kerkhoffs and Hak Jun Kim and Sameh A. Labib and Kaj T. A. Lambers and Jin Woo Lee and Keun Bae Lee and Jeffrey S. Ling and Umile Giuseppe Longo and Alberto Marangon and Graham McCollum and Adam Mitchell and Peter N. Mittwede and Stefan Nehrer and Philipp Niemeyer and James A. Nunley and Martin O’Malley and David O. Osei-Hwedieh and Jochen Paul and Christopher J. Pearce and Hélder Pereira and Adam Popchak and Marcelo Pires Prado and Steven M. Raikin and Mikel L. Reilingh and Benjamin B. Rothrauff and Lew C. Schon and Helene Simpson and Niall A. Smyth and Carolyn M. Sofka and Pietro Spennacchio and James W. Stone and Martin Sullivan and Yasuhito Tanaka and David B. Thordarson and Rocky S. Tuan and Víctor Valderrábano and Christiaan J. A. van Bergen and C. Niek van Dijk and Pim A. D. van Dijk and Francesca Vannini and Markus Walther and Martin Wiewiorski and Xiangyang Xu and Youichi Yasui and Yinghui Hua and Ichiro Yoshimura and Alastair Younger and Zijun Zhang},
  title = {{Subchondral Pathology: Proceedings of the International Consensus Meeting on Cartilage Repair of the Ankle}},
  booktitle = {Foot},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1177/1071100718781866},
}
Figure