Subcarrier Allocation Based Cooperative Spectrum Sharing with Wireless Energy Harvesting in OFDM Relaying Networks

Dan Huang, Mengshu Hou, Weidang LuSensors 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel cooperative spectrum sharing protocol for OFDM relaying networks that integrates wireless energy harvesting. By intelligently allocating subcarriers and power, a cognitive relay can simultaneously decode primary user information, harvest energy, and then forward both primary and cognitive signals without causing interference, thereby maximizing cognitive system throughput while respecting primary system constraints.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing demand for wireless data, especially with the advent of 5G and the proliferation of IoT devices, has led to a scarcity of available radio spectrum. Cognitive radio (CR) offers a solution by allowing secondary (cognitive) users to opportunistically access licensed spectrum when primary users are inactive or when interference levels are below a certain threshold. However, existing CR systems often face challenges:

  • Interference: When cognitive users transmit simultaneously with primary users, they can cause interference, degrading performance for both.
  • Resource Allocation: Efficiently managing spectrum, power, and relaying strategies is complex, especially when considering multiple objectives.
  • Cognitive Relay Motivation: Cognitive relays might be reluctant to assist primary users if it significantly depletes their own resources or offers little benefit.

This paper specifically tackles the issue of interference and resource optimization in OFDM relaying networks by proposing a cooperative spectrum sharing protocol that leverages wireless energy harvesting (WEH) to incentivize and enable the cognitive relay.

Methods

The proposed protocol operates in two phases and employs a joint optimization strategy:

  1. Two-Phase Cooperative Relaying with SWIPT:
    • Phase 1: The cognitive relay node (CRN) receives signals from both the primary transmitter (PT) and the cognitive source node (CSN). It splits the received power: a fraction is used for decoding information (Simultaneous Wireless Information and Power Transfer - SWIPT), and the remaining fraction is harvested as energy.
  2. Phase 2: The CRN uses the harvested energy to forward the signals. Crucially, it utilizes disjoint subcarriers for the primary system's signal (to the primary receiver, PR) and the cognitive system's signal (to the cognitive destination node, CDN). This disjoint subcarrier allocation is the key to eliminating interference between the primary and cognitive transmissions in this phase.
  3. Joint Optimization: The core of the paper lies in optimizing three key parameters to maximize the cognitive system's achievable rate ($R_C$) while ensuring the primary system meets its target transmission rate ($R_T$):
  4. Power Splitting Ratio ($\lambda$): Determines how the received power in Phase 1 is divided between information decoding and energy harvesting.
  5. Power Allocation ($P$): Optimizes the transmit power of the CRN for forwarding signals in Phase 2.
  6. Subcarrier Allocation ($G$): Decides which subcarriers are allocated to the primary signal and which to the cognitive signal in Phase 2.

The optimization problem is formulated as a non-convex problem. The authors address this by:

  • Using a binary search to find the optimal power splitting ratio ($\lambda^*$).
  • Employing a dual decomposition method to iteratively optimize power allocation ($P$) and subcarrier allocation ($G$) given the dual variables.
  • The subcarrier allocation is determined by evaluating a derived metric ($F_k$) for each subcarrier and assigning those with positive values to the cognitive system.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on numerical and simulation results generated based on the defined system model and parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interference Elimination via Disjoint Subcarriers: The most significant insight is the use of disjoint subcarriers in the second phase for primary and cognitive signal forwarding. This elegantly solves the interference problem that plagues many cooperative CR systems, allowing for improved performance for both.
  • Energy Harvesting as a Motivator: By enabling the CRN to harvest energy from the primary transmission, the protocol makes it more attractive for the CRN to participate in spectrum sharing, as it gains a resource (energy) that directly benefits its own transmission.
  • Trade-off between Primary Rate and Cognitive Rate: The results highlight a clear trade-off: increasing the primary system's target rate ($R_T$) necessitates dedicating more resources (power and subcarriers) to forwarding the primary signal, thus reducing the achievable rate for the cognitive system.
  • Impact of Primary Transmit Power ($P_p$): Higher primary transmit power ($P_p$) leads to a higher achievable cognitive rate. This is because more power from the primary signal means more energy can be harvested by the CRN, which can then be used to boost its own transmissions.
  • Optimal Power Splitting: The optimal power splitting ratio is dynamic and depends on the primary transmit power and the primary target rate. When $P_p$ is high, more power can be split for energy harvesting. Conversely, a higher $R_T$ requires more power for decoding, leaving less for harvesting.

Key Results

  • The proposed scheme significantly outperforms a prior scheme [26] that uses the same bandwidth for both primary and cognitive signals, demonstrating the effectiveness of disjoint subcarrier allocation in reducing interference.
  • The achievable rate of the cognitive system increases with the primary transmit power ($P_p$). For example, with $R_T = 0.5$ bps, increasing $P_p$ from 0.6W to 1.6W results in a noticeable increase in the cognitive system's achievable rate.
  • The achievable rate of the cognitive system decreases as the primary target transmission rate ($R_T$) increases. For a fixed $P_p$, a higher $R_T$ demands more resources for the primary system, leaving less for the cognitive system.
  • Figure 5 illustrates the power and subcarrier allocation in the second phase, showing that the cognitive system is allocated more power and subcarriers than the primary system, reflecting the need to achieve a relatively small target rate for the primary system.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Channel State Information (CSI): The paper assumes perfect CSI is available. In real-world scenarios, imperfect CSI can degrade performance. Future work could explore robust optimization under CSI errors.
  • Complexity: The dual decomposition method, while effective, can be computationally intensive. Investigating more efficient optimization algorithms could be beneficial.
  • System Model Simplifications: The model assumes a single primary transmitter/receiver pair and a single cognitive relay. Extending the model to multi-user scenarios or multiple relays could provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Energy Harvesting Model: The paper uses a linear energy harvesting model. Exploring non-linear models could offer more realistic insights.

The authors suggest that the proposed protocol provides useful insights into the impact of various system parameters, laying the groundwork for further research in cooperative spectrum sharing with energy harvesting.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we propose subcarrier allocation based cooperative spectrum sharing protocol for OFDM relaying networks with wireless energy harvesting. In the proposed protocol, the cognitive relay node utilizes different subcarriers to forward the primary information to obtain the spectrum access for the cognitive system transmission. The primary system consists of two parts, a primary transmitter (PT) and primary receiver (PR), and cognitive system includes a cognitive source node (CSN), cognitive destination node (CDN) and cognitive relay node (CRN). In the first phase, CRN splits a fraction of the power received from the PT and CSN transmission to decode information, while the remaining power is used for energy harvesting. Then CRN uses disjoint subcarriers to forward the signals of PT and CSN by utilizing the harvested energy in the second phase. Three parameters which consist of power splitting ratio, power allocation and subcarriers allocation are optimized in our algorithm to maximize the cognitive transmission rate with the constraint of primary target transmission rate. Numerical and simulation results are shown to give useful insights into the proposed cooperative spectrum sharing protocol, and we also found that various system parameters have a great effect for the simulation results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2019subcarrier,
  author = {Dan Huang and Mengshu Hou and Weidang Lu},
  title = {{Subcarrier Allocation Based Cooperative Spectrum Sharing with Wireless Energy Harvesting in OFDM Relaying Networks}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/s19122663},
}
Figure