Sub-homogeneous positive monotone systems are insensitive to heterogeneous time-varying delays

Hamid Reza Feyzmahdavian, Themistoklis Charalambous, Mikael JohanssonarXiv 2014 · OpenReview

Abstract

We show that a sub-homogeneous positive monotone system with bounded heterogeneous time-varying delays is globally asymptotically stable if and only if the corresponding delay-free system is globally asymptotically stable. The proof is based on an extension of a delay-independent stability result for monotone systems under constant delays by Smith to systems with bounded heterogeneous time-varying delays. Under the additional assumption of positivity and sub-homogeneous vector fields, we establish the aforementioned delay insensitivity property and derive a novel test for global asymptotic stability. If the system has a unique equilibrium point in the positive orthant, we prove that our stability test is necessary and sufficient. Specialized to positive linear systems, our results extend and sharpen existing results from the literature.

Introduction

In many real-world engineering systems—ranging from wireless power control to chemical reactors—the current state of the system depends not just on its current values, but on values from the past. These "time delays" are often caused by communication lags or physical transport times. In most dynamical systems, increasing a delay can eventually turn a stable system into an unstable, oscillating state. However, a special class called "positive linear systems" is known to be "delay-insensitive": if they are stable with zero delay, they remain stable for any delay.

The challenge is that most real-world systems are nonlinear. While previous research showed that certain nonlinear systems are insensitive to constant delays, real-world delays are often heterogeneous (different for different components) and time-varying. This paper addresses this gap by proving that sub-homogeneity and monotonicity are the key ingredients that guarantee stability even under unpredictable, changing delays.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The authors employ tools from nonlinear control theory and functional differential equations, focusing on two primary properties:

  1. Monotone System Theory: Systems where trajectories preserve a specific ordering (if state A starts "ahead" of state B, it stays ahead).
  2. Sub-homogeneity: Vector fields where scaling the input by a factor $\lambda$ results in an output scaled by at most $\lambda^\alpha$.

A key technical contribution is a comparison principle that allows the trajectory of a system with complex, time-varying delays to be "sandwiched" between two simpler systems with constant delays. This approach bypasses the failure of standard proof techniques for constant delays when applied to time-varying scenarios.

Figure 1: Phase portrait illustrating invariant rectangles and convergence to equilibrium points, characteristic of monotone systems.

Key Results

The core finding, formalized in Theorem 2, states that for sub-homogeneous positive monotone systems, global asymptotic stability (GAS) without delays is mathematically equivalent to GAS with arbitrary bounded heterogeneous time-varying delays.

This "if and only if" relationship simplifies stability analysis significantly: one only needs to check the stability of the delay-free version of the system. Furthermore, the paper provides a concrete stability test. For systems with a unique equilibrium in the positive orthant, stability under any delay is guaranteed if and only if a specific feasibility condition (finding a positive vector $v$ such that $f(v) + g(v) < 0$) is met.

Numerical Validation

The authors validate their findings using illustrative numerical examples where they simulate trajectories of nonlinear systems. These simulations demonstrate how states converge to equilibrium points despite the presence of varying delays, confirming the theoretical delay-insensitivity property.

Figure 3: Numerical simulation showing the trajectory of a nonlinear system converging to a stable equilibrium point despite time-varying delays.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work extends and sharpens the existing literature on positive linear systems by providing a robust theoretical foundation for their resilience to lag within a broader nonlinear context. However, the results are constrained by the assumption of sub-homogeneity and the requirement that delays must be bounded. Future research may explore extending these results to more general classes of positive monotone systems where the sub-homogeneity assumption can be relaxed.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that a sub-homogeneous positive monotone system with bounded heterogeneous time-varying delays is globally asymptotically stable if and only if the corresponding delay-free system is globally asymptotically stable. The proof is based on an extension of a delay-independent stability result for monotone systems under constant delays by Smith to systems with bounded heterogeneous time-varying delays. Under the additional assumption of positivity and sub-homogeneous vector fields, we establish the aforementioned delay insensitivity property and derive a novel test for global asymptotic stability. If the system has a unique equilibrium point in the positive orthant, we prove that our stability test is necessary and sufficient. Specialized to positive linear systems, our results extend and sharpen existing results from the literature.
BibTeX
@misc{feyzmahdavian2014sub,
  author = {Hamid Reza Feyzmahdavian and Themistoklis Charalambous and Mikael Johansson},
  title = {{Sub-homogeneous positive monotone systems are insensitive to heterogeneous time-varying delays}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1407.1502},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1407.1502},
}
Figure