StudyU: A Platform for Designing and Conducting Innovative Digital N-of-1 Trials

Stefan Konigorski, Sarah Wernicke, Tamara Slosarek, Alexander M. Zenner, Nils Strelow, Darius F. Ruether, Florian Henschel, Manisha Manaswini, Fabian Pottbäcker, Jonathan Antonio Edelman, Babajide Owoyele, Matteo Danieletto, Eddye Golden, Micol Zweig, Girish N. Nadkarni, Erwin P. BöttingerJournal of Medical Internet Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces StudyU, an open-source platform designed to democratize and streamline the creation and execution of digital N-of-1 trials. StudyU empowers researchers to easily design personalized studies and allows participants to engage in them without requiring user accounts, paving the way for more accessible and reproducible personalized medicine research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of conducting N-of-1 trials, which are the gold standard for evaluating individual treatment effects and developing personalized strategies. While digital tools offer immense potential to scale and broaden N-of-1 trials, a lack of fully functional, user-friendly platforms hinders their widespread adoption. Existing solutions are often limited in platform support, customization, or require complex user account setups, creating barriers for both researchers and participants. This gap prevents the full realization of personalized medicine and evidence generation for self-optimization.

Methods

StudyU is a comprehensive platform composed of three main parts:

  • StudyU Designer: A collaborative web application for researchers to digitally specify, publish, and manage N-of-1 trials. It provides a structured workflow for defining study metadata, interventions, eligibility criteria, observations, schedules, and consent forms.
  • StudyU App: A smartphone application for participants to engage in published trials. It offers a user-centric experience, allowing participation without requiring user accounts, and provides in-app analysis and visualization of results.
  • Backend: A secure storage system that hosts study definitions, participant data, and other essential information.

The platform is built using Flutter for cross-platform compatibility (iOS, Android, Web) and Parse Server for backend functionalities like data storage, user authentication, and push notifications. The study model is represented in JSON format, allowing for flexible study design and dynamic updates without requiring app store re-deployments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Democratizing N-of-1 Trials: StudyU significantly lowers the barrier to entry for conducting N-of-1 trials, making this powerful research design accessible to a broader range of researchers and clinicians.
  • User-Centric Design: The platform prioritizes a seamless experience for participants, notably by eliminating the need for user accounts, which addresses privacy concerns and simplifies participation.
  • Integrated Workflow: StudyU provides an end-to-end solution, from study design and participant recruitment to in-app data analysis and result visualization, streamlining the entire N-of-1 trial process.
  • Reproducibility and Transparency: By making study designs available, StudyU fosters reproducibility and transparency in medical science.
  • Personalized Evidence Generation: The platform enables personalized evidence generation for both self-optimization and medical research, moving beyond population-level averages.

Key Results

The paper presents StudyU as a functional platform with a demonstrated ability to design and conduct digital N-of-1 trials. Key features highlighted include:

  • Flexible Study Design: Researchers can define complex interventions, eligibility criteria, and observations with various question types (Boolean, multiple-choice, slider).
  • User-Friendly Interface: Both the designer and the app feature intuitive interfaces with features like inline editing, icon pickers, and clear visual cues.
  • In-App Results Visualization: Participants can view their study progress and results through visualizations like progress bars and statistical reports (e.g., linear regression), encouraging continued engagement.
  • Open-Source and Free: The platform is publicly available and free to use, further promoting its adoption.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The current version of the app requires participants to select only two interventions per study.
  • While the platform is designed for HIPAA and GDPR compliance, specific deployment details for these regulations are not elaborated upon.
  • Future Work:
    • Include more features for collaborative study design, such as a database of interested researchers and institutions.
  • Integrate sensor-based measures for interventions and outcome assessment.
  • Develop adaptive trial designs, including micro-randomized trials and just-in-time adaptive interventions.
  • Incorporate more advanced statistical and machine learning methods for complex individual-level treatment effect analysis.
  • Explore user-centric N-of-1 trials designed by participants themselves.
  • Integrate with electronic health records for seamless connection to clinical practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

N-of-1 trials are the gold standard study design to evaluate individual treatment effects and derive personalized treatment strategies. Digital tools have the potential to initiate a new era of N-of-1 trials in terms of scale and scope, but fully functional platforms are not yet available. Here, we present the open source StudyU platform, which includes the StudyU Designer and StudyU app. With the StudyU Designer, scientists are given a collaborative web application to digitally specify, publish, and conduct N-of-1 trials. The StudyU app is a smartphone app with innovative user-centric elements for participants to partake in trials published through the StudyU Designer to assess the effects of different interventions on their health. Thereby, the StudyU platform allows clinicians and researchers worldwide to easily design and conduct digital N-of-1 trials in a safe manner. We envision that StudyU can change the landscape of personalized treatments both for patients and healthy individuals, democratize and personalize evidence generation for self-optimization and medicine, and can be integrated in clinical practice.
BibTeX
@article{konigorski2022studyu,
  author = {Stefan Konigorski and Sarah Wernicke and Tamara Slosarek and Alexander M. Zenner and Nils Strelow and Darius F. Ruether and Florian Henschel and Manisha Manaswini and Fabian Pottbäcker and Jonathan Antonio Edelman and Babajide Owoyele and Matteo Danieletto and Eddye Golden and Micol Zweig and Girish N. Nadkarni and Erwin P. Böttinger},
  title = {{StudyU: A Platform for Designing and Conducting Innovative Digital N-of-1 Trials}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2196/35884},
}
Figure