Study Protocol: Transitions in Adolescent Girls (TAG)

Marjolein E.a. Barendse, Nandita Vijayakumar, Michelle L. Byrne, Jessica Flannery, Theresa W Cheng, John C. Flournoy, Benjamin W. Nelson, Danielle Cosme, Arian Mobasser, Samantha Chavez, Lauren Hval, Bernadette Brady, Hanna Nadel, Alison Helzer, Elizabeth A. Shirtcliff, Nicholas B. Allen, Jennifer H. PfeiferFrontiers in Psychiatry 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the protocol for the Transitions in Adolescent Girls (TAG) study, a longitudinal investigation into the complex interplay between pubertal development, brain changes, social-cognitive processes, and mental health in adolescent females. By integrating biological, neurological, and psychological data over three years, the study aims to identify developmental pathways and risk factors for mental illnesses like depression and anxiety in this vulnerable population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adolescence is a critical period marked by significant physical, neurological, and social development, but it also sees a sharp increase in the incidence of mental health disorders, particularly depression and anxiety in females. While pubertal and neurodevelopmental changes are known to influence mental health, the precise mechanisms and pathways linking these processes remain poorly understood. Existing research often examines these factors in isolation, leaving a gap in our understanding of how they interact to shape mental well-being during this transitional phase. The TAG study aims to bridge this gap by comprehensively investigating these interconnected developmental trajectories.

Methods

The TAG study employs a longitudinal, multi-wave design with three assessment points over three years. The methodology is comprehensive, integrating several key approaches:

  • Biological and Hormonal Assessment: Saliva samples are collected weekly to assess hormone levels (DHEA, testosterone, estradiol) and immune factors (CRP, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, IL-12p70, TNF-a, IFN-y, SIgA). Additionally, hair samples are collected to provide a longer-term index of hormone levels over the past five months. Telomere length is also measured from saliva samples.
  • Neuroimaging: Participants undergo structural, diffusion, resting-state functional, and task-based functional MRI scans. These scans are used to assess brain structure, connectivity, and neural activity during specific cognitive tasks.
  • Psychological and Behavioral Assessments:
    • Diagnostic Interview: The Kiddie Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia (K-SADS-PL) is used for a comprehensive assessment of current and lifetime mental health, including psychiatric disorders.
  • Self-Perception and Social Cognition Tasks: * fMRI Self-Evaluation Task: Adolescents rate individual trait adjectives related to interpersonal relationships, assessing how well they describe themselves and whether these traits are malleable.
  • fMRI Self-Disclosure Task: Participants respond to statements about themselves and choose whether to share this information with a friend or keep it private, allowing for the calculation of their point of subjective equivalence for disclosure.
  • "This Is Me" Task: A one-minute video speech designed to measure social functioning under mild social evaluation stress.
  • Questionnaires: A wide array of questionnaires are administered to both adolescents and parents/guardians, covering pubertal development, mental health, risk factors, social functioning, emotion regulation, well-being, and environmental factors.
  • Anthropometrics: Height, weight, and waist circumference are measured to track physical development.
  • Intelligence Assessment: The Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI-II) is administered to control for intellectual differences.

Datasets

The study utilizes data collected from 174 female adolescents aged 10.0 to 13.0 years at the first assessment wave. This data will be made available through the Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Developmental Pathways: The study's core innovation lies in its attempt to map the complex, interconnected pathways from pubertal hormonal changes to brain development, social-cognitive shifts, and ultimately, mental health outcomes. This holistic approach moves beyond studying these factors in isolation.
  • Focus on Female Adolescents: The study specifically targets female adolescents due to observed sex differences in pubertal processes and a higher prevalence of internalizing disorders (like depression and anxiety) in females during adolescence.
  • Longitudinal Design: The three-wave longitudinal design is crucial for understanding developmental trajectories and identifying predictive relationships over time, offering more power than cross-sectional or two-wave studies.
  • Novel fMRI Tasks: The development of specific fMRI tasks for self-evaluation and self-disclosure allows for the neural investigation of key adolescent social-cognitive processes.
  • Identifying Modifiable Risk Factors: The ultimate goal is to identify specific, developmentally-timed risk factors that can be targeted for early intervention and prevention efforts, making the research highly relevant for public health.

Key Results

As this paper is a study protocol, it does not present results from the completed study. However, the protocol outlines the planned analyses, including:

  • Monte Carlo power analyses indicate that with the chosen sample size and expected attrition rate, the study will have at least an 80% chance of detecting standardized direct effects of 0.235 or larger, moderating effects of 0.15 or larger, and standardized indirect effects of 0.09 or larger in mediation analyses.
  • Data Availability: The collected data, including imaging, hormonal, questionnaire, and diagnostic data, will be uploaded to the RDoC database for public access.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Specificity: While the community-based sample aims for generalizability, it is limited to female adolescents from Lane County, Oregon.
  • Attrition: Although the study has a strong retention rate (94% from T1 to T2), some attrition is expected over the three years, which is accounted for in power analyses.
  • Substudies: The paper mentions three substudies (gut microbiome, social self-evaluative stressor, and smartphone usage) that are not part of the original protocol but offer opportunities for further research.
  • Future Directions: The authors envision that the knowledge gained will inform the development of novel, developmentally targeted, and biologically informed prevention and intervention services to support adolescent mental health. The data will be used to examine mediation models and identify specific risk factors.

Summary updated

Abstract

The knowledge gained from this study will include developmental trajectories of pubertal, neurological, and social processes and their roles as mechanisms in predicting emergence of mental illness in female adolescents. This knowledge will help identify modifiable, developmentally specific risk factors as targets for early intervention and prevention efforts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{barendse2020study,
  author = {Marjolein E.A. Barendse and Nandita Vijayakumar and Michelle L. Byrne and Jessica Flannery and Theresa W Cheng and John C. Flournoy and Benjamin W. Nelson and Danielle Cosme and Arian Mobasser and Samantha Chavez and Lauren Hval and Bernadette Brady and Hanna Nadel and Alison Helzer and Elizabeth A. Shirtcliff and Nicholas B. Allen and Jennifer H. Pfeifer},
  title = {{Study Protocol: Transitions in Adolescent Girls (TAG)}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2019.01018},
}
Figure