Study on the Variation Law of Water Consumption Rate of Cascade Hydropower Station under Different Conditions

Xueshan Ai, Xiaoke Zhang, Renwei Guo, Xiao Li, Mian Wang, Fengshuo Liu, Jiawei ZhangEnergies 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex relationships governing the water consumption rate of cascade hydropower stations, a key metric for efficient operation. By developing a novel methodology based on unit characteristics and a "mirror vertical shift method," the study reveals how factors like water level, flow, and output influence this rate, providing crucial insights for optimizing real-time energy generation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optimizing hydropower station operations is critical for maximizing energy output while minimizing water usage. The "water consumption rate" (WCR) is a vital indicator of this efficiency, defined as the amount of water used per unit of electricity generated. However, existing methods for calculating WCR often rely on actual operating data, which can be difficult to generalize and use for predictive operational guidance. Furthermore, the intricate interplay of various factors—such as reservoir water levels, flow rates, and the combined operation of multiple units in a cascade—makes understanding the WCR's variation patterns a significant challenge. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically analyzing and modeling the WCR's behavior under diverse operational conditions for cascade hydropower systems.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-step approach to model the WCR:

  • Unit Characteristic Curves: They begin by establishing the relationship between a unit's output, net head, and flow (NHQ). This is then extended to gross head by incorporating head loss curves, resulting in output-gross head-flow (NHgrossQ) curves for individual units.
  • Mirror Vertical Shift Method: This novel technique is used to combine the NHgrossQ curves of multiple units. It involves graphically manipulating the flow-output curves of individual units to find the optimal flow distribution that maximizes the combined output for a given gross head. This method is applied iteratively to determine the optimal operating characteristics for combinations of units, eventually scaling up to the entire cascade.
  • Water Consumption Rate Calculation: The WCR is calculated using the formula $\mu = \frac{W}{E} = \frac{Q \cdot T}{N}$, where $W$ is water volume, $E$ is energy generated, $Q$ is flow rate, $T$ is time, and $N$ is power output. This is then adapted to derive characteristic curves of WCR against various parameters like flow, gross head, and water level.
  • Cascade Operation Analysis: The study extends the analysis to a two-station cascade (A and B), considering their interdependencies. They develop formulas and calculation steps to determine the optimal flow distribution and output for the cascade to achieve the minimum WCR under given total output and water level conditions.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from two specific cascade hydropower stations, "A" and "B," located on the Jinsha River. The paper provides detailed technical specifications for these stations, including reservoir capacities, normal water levels, and the characteristics of their hydroelectric generating units. No new benchmark datasets are introduced; rather, the analysis is based on the operational parameters of these existing facilities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • WCR is Highly Sensitive to Operational Parameters: The research clearly demonstrates that the water consumption rate is not a static value but dynamically changes with variations in flow, gross head, and, crucially, reservoir water levels.
  • The "Mirror Vertical Shift Method" is Effective for Multi-Unit Optimization: This graphical technique provides a systematic way to determine optimal flow distributions and combined outputs for multiple units, which is essential for cascade operations.
  • Cascade Interdependence Matters: The return flow from a downstream reservoir can influence the tailwater level of an upstream reservoir, creating a feedback loop that affects the gross head and, consequently, the WCR of the upstream station. This highlights the need for a holistic approach to cascade optimization.
  • Optimal WCR Decreases with Increased Output and Water Level: For cascade systems, higher total output generally leads to a lower WCR, and increasing water levels in the reservoirs also contribute to a more efficient water usage.

Key Results

  • Single Unit Behavior: For a single unit, the WCR generally decreases with increasing flow, but this trend can reverse at very high flows or low gross heads, showing a slight increase.
  • Hydropower Station Behavior: For individual hydropower stations, the WCR shows slight fluctuations and an increasing trend with outflow, with a generally decreasing trend as gross head increases.
  • Cascade WCR: The study found that for the A-B cascade, as the total output increases, the optimal WCR decreases, eventually stabilizing. Furthermore, increasing the water level of the downstream reservoir (B) leads to a decrease in the cascade's optimal WCR, assuming the upstream reservoir's (A) water level and total output remain constant.
  • Quantitative Example: In one case, with a total output of 558 × 10⁴ kW, the optimal WCR for the cascade was 2.7148 m³/kWh, achieved with specific output distributions between stations A and B.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: While the methods are presented as extendable, the specific results are derived from two particular cascade hydropower stations. Further validation with other cascade configurations would be beneficial.
  • Dynamic Conditions: The study focuses on variations under different static conditions (e.g., fixed water levels). Future work could explore the WCR's behavior under more dynamic, real-time operational changes and transient conditions.
  • Complexity of Cascade Interactions: The paper acknowledges the return water effect but a more in-depth analysis of complex hydraulic and electrical interdependencies within larger cascades could be explored.
  • Data Availability: The authors note that data availability is restricted, which might limit broader replication and further research by the community.

Summary updated

Abstract

The water consumption rate for hydropower station power generation is an important index of the economic operation of hydropower stations, which has been widely considered and applied in the production practice of hydropower stations and has great significance for the full utilization of hydroelectric resources. This paper takes A and B cascade hydropower stations as the research objects to study the variation patterns of the water consumption rate of hydropower stations under different conditions, which mainly includes the following: (1) in this study, the relationship curve of output–gross head–flow (NHgrossQ) of each unit was established based on the relationship curve of output–net head–flow (NHQ) and the flow–head loss curve of each unit; (2) the mirror vertical shift method was used to calculate and plot the relationship curve of gross head–flow for combinations of multiple units; (3) the outflow–water–output characteristic curve of the hydropower station under the conditions of different reservoir water levels, different discharge flow, or different power generation output under the optimal operation of the hydropower station were calculated and drawn; (4) the outflow–water level–output curve of the hydropower station under various conditions was converted into an outflow–water level–water consumption curve; (5) the variation characteristics of the water consumption rate of the hydropower station under different conditions were analyzed; (6) on the basis of the definition of the water consumption rate of cascade hydropower stations, the research on the variation in the water consumption rate of cascade hydropower stations was carried out under the conditions of different water levels of the A reservoir, different water levels of the B reservoir, different discharge, and different total output of the hydropower stations. The variation pattern of the water consumption rate of hydropower stations under different conditions obtained in this paper can provide technical support for the real-time economic operation of cascade hydropower stations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ai2024study,
  author = {Xueshan Ai and Xiaoke Zhang and Renwei Guo and Xiao Li and Mian Wang and Fengshuo Liu and Jiawei Zhang},
  title = {{Study on the Variation Law of Water Consumption Rate of Cascade Hydropower Station under Different Conditions}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/en17194966},
}
Figure