Study on the Spatial Distribution Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages in Hubei Province, China

Qi Wang, Bing He, Siqi Wang, Qing XuSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses GIS to analyze the spatial distribution of 44 historical and cultural towns and villages in Hubei Province, China. It reveals a clustered distribution pattern influenced by historical geography, natural environments, and migration patterns, highlighting the need for integrated conservation strategies to address modern challenges like urbanization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's rich cultural heritage includes numerous "Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages" (FHCTV). However, these sites face significant threats from rapid urbanization, changing population densities, and modern infrastructure development. Understanding their spatial distribution and the factors influencing it is crucial for effective conservation and sustainable development. This paper addresses the gap in understanding these patterns at a provincial level, specifically within Hubei Province, to inform targeted conservation efforts.

Methods

The researchers employed Geographic Information Technology (GIS) for spatial analysis. Key methods included:

  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM) Analysis: To understand the relationship between FHCTV distribution and terrain elevation.
  • Nearest Neighbor Analysis: To determine if the distribution is clustered, random, or uniform.
  • Buffer Zone Analysis: To assess the proximity of FHCTV to river systems.
  • Nuclear Density Analysis: To identify areas of high and low density of FHCTV.
  • Imbalance Index Analysis: To quantify the unevenness of FHCTV distribution across administrative regions.
  • Correlation Analysis: To investigate the relationship between FHCTV distribution and various socio-economic factors (population density, urbanization, transportation, ecological environment).

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages (FHCTV) Data: 44 national and provincial FHCTV in Hubei Province, announced between 2003 and 2022. Data was sourced from official government websites.
  • Socio-economic Data: Land area, population, road mileage, Gross Domestic Product (GDP) from the Hubei Statistical Yearbook 2020 and city/prefecture yearbooks.
  • Ecological Data: Hubei Provincial Ecological Index.
  • Geographical Data: Baidu Map for coordinates, converted to GPS. China's administrative divisions, elevation, river systems, and road data from the Planning Cloud website, National Basic Geographic Information Center, and Geospatial Data Cloud. DEM data from ASTER GDEM V3.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Clustered Distribution: FHCTV in Hubei are not randomly distributed but exhibit a significant low-value agglomeration, meaning they tend to cluster together.
  • "One Belt, Two Clusters" Pattern: The spatial distribution can be described as "one belt, two clusters, and many scattered points," indicating concentrated areas and dispersed sites.
  • River Proximity is Key: A substantial majority of FHCTV are located within 5-15 km of major river systems, highlighting the historical importance of water for settlement.
  • Historical Geography Matters: The distribution is deeply rooted in historical migration patterns, particularly from the Ming and Qing dynasties, and the influence of ancient transportation routes (rivers and landways).
  • Urbanization is a Threat: Modern urbanization and increased transportation density show a negative correlation with FHCTV preservation, suggesting that development can negatively impact these sites.
  • Ecological Environment is a Protector: A good ecological environment shows a positive correlation with FHCTV preservation, acting as a natural buffer and indicating a harmonious relationship with the land.
  • Cultural Fusion: Hubei's FHCTV reflect a rich blend of cultures, including Chu culture, immigrant culture, and local adaptations, making them unique but also complex to categorize.

Key Results

  • Elevation: 77.3% of FHCTV are located in plain areas with an elevation below 200m, primarily in southeastern and northeastern Hubei.
  • Nearest Neighbor Analysis: The nearest neighbor index (R=0.811) indicates a cohesive distribution, with a statistically significant negative z-score (-2.4) suggesting low-value clustering.
  • River Buffer: 73% of FHCTV are within a 5km river buffer zone (grade V and above).
  • Density: Distribution density varies significantly across cities, with Xianning City having the highest density.
  • Imbalance Index: An imbalance index of 0.59 indicates uneven distribution across administrative regions, with a significant portion concentrated in Xianning, Huangshi, Enshi, and Huanggang.
  • Correlations:
    • Population density: Weak negative correlation (r = -0.15).
  • Urbanization level: Weak negative correlation (r = -0.18).
  • Modern traffic: Extremely weak negative correlation (r = -0.03).
  • Ecological environment: Moderate positive correlation (r = 0.44).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Temporal Analysis: The study did not analyze the evolution of FHCTV protection elements (architectural heritage, land use, roads, etc.) over time.
  • Data Collection: Provincial vernacular heritage data was not comprehensively collected or collated.
  • Ecological Protection and Disaster Monitoring: The study did not delve into ecological protection or disaster monitoring aspects.
  • Planning and Management: Planning decision-making and management were not directly addressed.

Future work could involve:

  • Analyzing the temporal evolution of FHCTV elements.
  • Developing comprehensive provincial vernacular heritage databases.
  • Integrating ecological protection and disaster risk assessment into conservation strategies.
  • Developing practical planning and management frameworks for FHCTV.

Summary updated

Abstract

Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages are among the important components of China’s cultural heritage. Their spatial distribution patterns are directly related to regional geographical patterns, historical transportation geography and traditional communities. Meanwhile, their conservation is challenged by the change in regional population density, the level of urbanization, modern transportation and ecological environment conditions. Therefore, studying the provincial distribution patterns is of great practical significance to the conservation and sustainable development of Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages in China. This study takes 44 of China’s national and provincial Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages in Hubei Province that were announced from 2003 to 2022 as the research subjects and uses the Geographic Information Technology (GIS) tools to determine their clusters and linear distribution zones, including nearest distance analysis, nuclear density analysis, buffer zone analysis and imbalance index analysis. We further analyze the causes of their spatial distribution in conjugation with historical geography and factors related to the preservation of the current situation of them via correlation analysis. Finally, we make suggestions for the conservation and development of Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages in Hubei Province.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022study,
  author = {Qi Wang and Bing He and Siqi Wang and Qing Xu},
  title = {{Study on the Spatial Distribution Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Famous Historical and Cultural Towns or Villages in Hubei Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142113735},
}
Figure