Study on the Spatial and Temporal Distribution of the High–Quality Development of Urbanization and Water Resource Coupling in the Yellow River Basin

Xin Huang, Juqin Shen, Fuhua Sun, Lunyan Wang, Pengchao Zhang, Yu WanSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the complex relationship between urban development and water resource management in China's Yellow River Basin (YRB). By developing a novel "HQDU-WRS coupling" framework and employing advanced modeling techniques, the research reveals an overall improvement in coordination, though significant regional disparities and key obstacles persist. This work offers crucial insights for sustainable development strategies in water-scarce regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China is undergoing a critical transition from rapid economic growth to high-quality development, particularly in its urban areas. This shift, termed High-Quality Development of Urbanization (HQDU), places immense pressure on natural resources, especially water. The Yellow River Basin (YRB), a vital economic and ecological region, faces significant water scarcity and uneven distribution, making the coordination between urban development and water resource systems (WRS) a paramount challenge. Existing research has explored urbanization's impact on water resources, but a comprehensive framework to assess their coupled and coordinated development, especially in a water-stressed region like the YRB, has been lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by proposing and applying a new conceptual framework and analytical tools to understand this intricate relationship.

Methods

The authors introduce a novel concept: "High-Quality Development of Urbanization–Water Resources Coupling" (HQDU-WRS coupling). To operationalize this, they construct two comprehensive index systems: one for HQDU (comprising innovation, coordination, greenness, openness, and sharing subsystems) and another for WRS (including background conditions, utilization capacity, management level, and pollution control subsystems).

The core analytical approach involves a combination of three models:

  1. Coupling Coordination Degree (CCD) Model: This model quantifies the interaction and synergy between the HQDU and WRS, moving beyond simple correlation to assess the level of harmonious development.
  2. Obstacle Degree Model: This model identifies the specific factors (subsystems and indicators) that hinder the improvement of the coupling coordination between HQDU and WRS.
  3. Clustering Model (Ward's Method): This statistical technique is used to group provinces within the YRB based on their CCD levels, revealing spatial patterns and regional disparities.

The study also employs the Entropy Weight Method and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to determine indicator weights, ensuring a robust evaluation.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from 2010 to 2021 for the nine provinces within the Yellow River Basin. The primary data sources include:

  • China Statistical Yearbook
  • China Urban Statistical Yearbook
  • Water Resources Bulletins of various provinces
  • National Economic and Resources Development Bulletins
  • Relevant data from the National Bureau of Statistics

Missing data were addressed by using averages from adjacent years.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A New Conceptual Framework: The introduction of the "HQDU-WRS coupling" concept provides a structured way to think about the interdependence and mutual influence between urban development and water resource systems, especially in the context of high-quality development.
  • Overall Improvement, but Uneven: While the YRB as a whole shows an improving trend in coupling coordination, moving from "mild disorder" to "barely coordination," the spatial distribution is highly uneven, with distinct development trajectories for different provinces.
  • Water Resource Management is Key: The study highlights that improvements in water resource management levels are crucial for enhancing the WRS, as background conditions and utilization capacity show less consistent improvement.
  • Obstacles to Coordination: Specific subsystems and indicators consistently emerge as significant barriers, pointing to targeted areas for policy intervention.

Key Results

  • Temporal Trends: Over the 2010-2021 period, the comprehensive development index for HQDU in the YRB showed a steady upward trend, while the WRS experienced an initial sharp decline followed by a steady increase. The overall coupling coordination degree (CCD) improved from 0.3751 to 0.5661, shifting from "mild disorder" to "barely coordination."
  • Spatial Variations: Provinces exhibit diverse development patterns:
  • Henan and Ningxia: Characterized by low initial levels and fluctuating trends, with rapid development in recent years.
  • Shanxi and Inner Mongolia: Showed steady development throughout the period.
  • Sichuan, Shandong, Shaanxi, and Qinghai: Experienced a prolonged period of low development followed by accelerated growth.
  • Gansu: Started with a high level but showed insufficient momentum later, leading to it having the lowest CCD by 2021.
  • Dominant Obstacle Factors:
    • For HQDU, the Coordination Index of Urbanization Economic Growth Speed and Technology Market Turnover as a Percentage of GDP were frequently identified as major obstacles.
  • For WRS, Comprehensive Production Capacity of Water Supply and Total Wastewater Discharge were consistently significant hindrances.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: While the study covers nine provinces, finer-grained analysis within provinces could reveal more localized challenges and opportunities.
  • Dynamic Nature of Obstacles: The study identifies key obstacles, but further research could explore the causal mechanisms behind these obstacles and how they evolve over time.
  • Policy Implications: While the paper provides a strong analytical basis, translating these findings into specific, actionable regional policies would be a valuable next step. The authors suggest focusing on innovation and coordination for HQDU, and management and pollution control for WRS, alongside promoting water recycling and reuse.

The study's findings are crucial for informing regional development strategies in the YRB, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach that prioritizes both urban advancement and water resource sustainability.

Summary updated

Abstract

China is facing a critical period of high–speed development and a transition to high–quality development. The purpose of this study is to investigate the spatial and temporal distribution of the coupling and coordination of high–quality development of urbanization and water resources in the Yellow River Basin (YRB). Firstly, we propose the concept of “High–Quality Development of Urbanization–Water Resources Coupling” and construct a high–quality development of urbanization (HQDU) system consisting of five sub–systems: innovation, coordination, greenness, openness and sharing, and a water resources system (WRS) consisting of four sub–systems: water resources background conditions, utilization capacity, management level, and pollution control. The improved coupling coordination degree model combined with the barrier degree model and clustering model is used to study the spatial and temporal distribution of the two systems in the YRB. The results show that the coupling coordination state of HQDU and WRS in the YRB improves to some extent, from “mild imbalance” to “barely coordination” in general; Henan and Ningxia are characterized by “low and fluctuating (levels) in early years and fast development in recent years”; Shanxi and Inner Mongolia develop steadily during the study period; Sichuan, Shandong, Shaanxi, and Qinghai are characterized by “low (levels) which lasted for a long time in the early stage and accelerated development in the later stage”; and Gansu Province is characterized by “high level in the early stage but insufficient momentum in later stage”. The Coordination Index of Urbanization Economic Growth Speed and the Total Wastewater Discharge are the most important obstacle factors in HQDU and WRS. This study explores the level of coordination development of HQDU and WRS as well as finds the obstacle factors in the development process of the two systems, which is an important reference value for the high–quality development of urbanization under the constraint of water resources.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2023study,
  author = {Xin Huang and Juqin Shen and Fuhua Sun and Lunyan Wang and Pengchao Zhang and Yu Wan},
  title = {{Study on the Spatial and Temporal Distribution of the High–Quality Development of Urbanization and Water Resource Coupling in the Yellow River Basin}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151612270},
}
Figure