Study on the Relationship between Indoor Vertical Greening and Oxygen Content in High-Rise Buildings

Yang Liu, Xin Wang, Xie Guilin, Congcong ZhaoSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of indoor vertical greening and ventilation on oxygen levels in high-rise buildings. Researchers developed a novel, eco-friendly candle-burning method to measure relative oxygen content, finding that vertical greening, particularly in south-facing rooms, positively correlates with increased oxygen, especially when combined with strategic window ventilation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As urbanization drives the proliferation of high-rise buildings, people are spending an increasing amount of time indoors. Human activities, like respiration, deplete oxygen and increase carbon dioxide levels, leading to "indoor air syndrome" with symptoms ranging from fatigue to respiratory issues. While natural ventilation and indoor plants are known to improve air quality, a quantitative understanding of how vertical greening interacts with ventilation to affect indoor oxygen content in high-rise environments has been lacking. Existing methods for measuring oxygen, like red phosphorus combustion, are cumbersome, polluting, and potentially hazardous. This paper aims to bridge this gap by establishing a quantitative relationship and proposing a more sustainable measurement technique.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a novel, eco-friendly method for measuring relative indoor oxygen content. Instead of traditional, hazardous techniques, the authors employed a candle-burning experiment within a sealed gas bottle. The principle is that the duration a candle burns is directly proportional to the amount of oxygen available.

The experimental setup involved:

  • A sealed water tank: To create a controlled environment and seal the gas bottle.
  • A candle on a fixing table: Positioned within the gas bottle.
  • A gas bottle: A glass bottle with a wide mouth used to enclose the burning candle.

The process involved:

  1. Lighting a candle and allowing its flame to stabilize.
  2. Quickly covering the candle with the gas bottle, sealing it with the water in the tank.
  3. Measuring the time from sealing the bottle until the candle extinguished.
  4. This burning time was then used as a proxy for relative oxygen content.

This method was applied to five different functional spaces (living room, master bedroom, second bedroom, study, kitchen) in a high-rise apartment in Harbin, China. Experiments were conducted both before and after the installation of vertical greening, and under various window-opening states (from fully closed to all six windows open).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on on-site experimental data collected within a specific high-rise building.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Candle-burning as an oxygen proxy: The study successfully demonstrates a practical and environmentally friendly method for assessing relative oxygen levels, offering a viable alternative to older, more hazardous techniques.
  • Vertical greening's positive impact: Indoor vertical greening, especially in south-facing rooms with ample sunlight, demonstrably increases oxygen content, likely due to enhanced photosynthesis.
  • Ventilation is key: Strategic window opening is crucial. Simply opening one window has limited impact, but opening multiple windows (especially two or more) promotes air convection, which is vital for distributing oxygen and improving overall air quality.
  • Synergy between greening and ventilation: The most significant oxygen level increases were observed when vertical greening was combined with effective ventilation strategies that created smooth air convection throughout the rooms.
  • Room orientation matters: South-facing rooms, benefiting from more sunlight, showed a greater positive impact from vertical greening compared to north-facing rooms.

Key Results

  • Baseline oxygen levels: In the absence of greening, south-facing rooms (master bedroom, living room) generally had higher oxygen content than north-facing rooms (study, kitchen, second bedroom) when windows were closed.
  • Impact of ventilation: Opening windows generally increased oxygen content. Opening two windows in the kitchen and living room led to a steady increase across rooms, with the second bedroom showing a peak.
  • Effect of vertical greening:
    • With windows closed, only the master bedroom and living room showed increased oxygen after greening.
  • With ventilation, the effect of greening varied. In some scenarios (e.g., one window open in the kitchen), rooms without greening showed higher oxygen, likely due to the plants being located further away from those specific areas.
  • However, with more comprehensive ventilation (e.g., two or more windows open), rooms with vertical greening consistently showed higher oxygen content.
  • Optimal placement: The study suggests that vertical greening should ideally be placed in south-facing rooms to maximize photosynthetic activity and oxygen production.
  • Ventilation strategy: For daily ventilation, opening two or more windows is recommended to ensure room convection and increase oxygen content.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Relative vs. Absolute Oxygen: The candle-burning method measures relative oxygen content, not absolute values. Future research could incorporate negative oxygen ion testers for more comprehensive measurements.
  • Environmental Conditions: The study was conducted under specific weather conditions (sunny, light breeze). Future work should investigate the impact of varying wind speeds and other environmental factors.
  • Plant Species and Density: The study used a specific plant (green dill) and a fixed density. Further research could explore the effects of different plant species, growth stages, and densities.
  • Building Specificity: The experiments were conducted in a single high-rise building. Replicating these studies in diverse building types and climates would enhance generalizability.
  • Long-term Effects: The study focused on short-term measurements. Investigating the long-term impact of vertical greening and ventilation on oxygen content would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article clarifies the quantitative relationship between vertical greening, indoor ventilation, and the oxygen content in high-rise buildings, with the aim of determining values for a high-oxygen-content threshold to assess the ventilation and greening of high-rise buildings. The quantitative index could be provided to architects to assist in the sustainable design of vertical greening in high-rise buildings. The quantitative index offers an effective, convenient, and environmentally friendly oxygen-content-testing method for interior spaces, while avoiding the air pollution caused by the current red phosphorus combustion method. Firstly, a floor of a high-rise building in Harbin was selected for on-site and fixed-point experiments. Secondly, through the design of a candle-burning experiment in a gas bottle, we measured the change in candle-burning time before and after installing vertical greening, as well as under different ventilation states. Finally, the changes in relative oxygen content in each functional space before and after vertical greening and under different ventilation states were statistically analyzed. The results showed that there was a potential correlation between indoor oxygen content and vertical greening placement in high-rise buildings; this correlation was found to be directly related to room orientation, the degree of the plants’ photosynthesis, and indoor airflow. In general, vertical greening should be placed in south-facing rooms. For daily ventilation, two or more windows should be opened to ensure convection in rooms, which can increase their oxygen content.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023study,
  author = {Yang Liu and Xin Wang and Xie Guilin and Congcong Zhao},
  title = {{Study on the Relationship between Indoor Vertical Greening and Oxygen Content in High-Rise Buildings}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15031916},
}
Figure