Study on the Regularity of Ammonia-Related Refrigeration Accidents in China from 2010 to 2020

Cong Luo, Yunsheng Zhao, Ke XuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes 82 ammonia-related refrigeration accidents (ArRAs) in China from 2010 to 2020, revealing distinct temporal and spatial patterns. The findings highlight that while overall accident numbers have decreased since 2017 due to policy interventions, the disconnect between accident frequency and casualty severity underscores the need for continued focus on preventing major incidents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid growth of cold storage infrastructure in China, heavily reliant on ammonia as a refrigerant, has been accompanied by a concerning frequency of ammonia-related refrigeration accidents (ArRAs). These accidents pose significant risks to safety and sustainable development. While general hazardous chemical accident analyses exist, a detailed statistical understanding of ArRAs specifically, particularly their temporal and spatial regularities, has been lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a comprehensive statistical analysis of ArRAs in China over a decade, offering crucial insights for accident prevention and safety management in this critical sector.

Methods

The researchers employed descriptive statistical and comparative analysis methods. They collected data on 82 ArRAs occurring between January 2010 and July 2020. This information was then organized into an Excel database, categorizing variables into categorical (e.g., year, month, region) and numerical (e.g., number of accidents, fatalities, injuries). The analysis focused on identifying temporal trends (annual and monthly), spatial distributions (by province and administrative regions), and direct causes of these accidents.

Datasets

The study utilized data from four primary sources:

  • China Chemical Safety Association (CCSA)
  • China Chemical Safety Network (NRCC)
  • Safety Management Network
  • Ministry of Emergency Management (MEM) of the People's Republic of China

These sources provided detailed information on accident cases, including enterprise name, accident time, location, type, causes, casualties, and emergency measures. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing publicly available accident data was compiled and analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "M" Pattern of Accidents: The annual evolution of ArRAs isn't linear. It shows a distinct "M" pattern, with peaks in 2013 and 2016, suggesting periods of heightened risk followed by declines, potentially linked to policy interventions.
  • Summer Surge: A significant clustering of accidents occurs during the warmer months, particularly from June to September, indicating that environmental factors play a role.
  • Regional Hotspots: East and Central China emerge as geographical focal points for ArRAs, likely due to their higher concentration of cold storage facilities. Provinces like Zhejiang, Shandong, Hubei, and Sichuan are identified as key areas for targeted prevention efforts.
  • The Disconnect Between Accidents and Casualties: Perhaps the most striking insight is the lack of direct proportionality between the number of accidents and the number of fatalities/injuries. While overall accident numbers have decreased since 2017, the severity of incidents (measured by casualties) has shown an upward trend in some periods. This suggests that while fewer accidents are occurring, the ones that do happen can be more severe, or that major, high-casualty events can disproportionately skew the data.
  • Human Error and Equipment Failure Dominate: The primary drivers of ArRAs are overwhelmingly human factors (improper operation, misoperation) and equipment failures, accounting for nearly 88% of all analyzed accidents. This points to a need for robust safety management systems, operator training, and diligent equipment maintenance.

Key Results

  • Total Accidents: 82 ArRAs were recorded between 2010 and July 2020.
  • Casualties: These accidents resulted in 189 deaths and 1081 injuries (including poisoning).
  • Peak Years: 2013 and 2016 were identified as peak years for accident occurrences.
  • Peak Months: July saw the highest number of accidents, with a general trend of increased incidents from June to September.
  • Geographic Concentration: East China and Central China accounted for the majority of accidents.
  • Leading Causes: Equipment failure (67.07%) and human factors (20.73%) were the most significant direct causes.
  • Policy Impact: The study suggests that national safety management policies implemented around 2013-2016 and again in 2017 contributed to a decrease in accident numbers.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge potential biases in accident data due to delayed reporting and the possibility of undercounting less impactful incidents. They also note that the temporal analysis, while providing annual and monthly trends, could be more granular by considering diurnal patterns. Future research could delve deeper into accident causation through scenario construction, data mining, and more sophisticated analysis to better understand the complex interplay of factors leading to ArRAs. The study also suggests that while controlling the overall number of accidents is important, preventing severe, high-casualty events remains a critical priority.

Summary updated

Abstract

The frequent occurrence of ammonia-related refrigeration accidents (ArRAs) restricts the safety and sustainable development of cold storage. As an essential tool for safety management, accident statistical analysis can provide a crucial decision-making basis for accident prevention and control. The present study combined descriptive statistics and comparative analysis methods to explore the characteristics and regularities of 82 ArRAs in China from 2010 to 2020. The results showed that the annual evolution of ArRAs presents a bimodal "M" mode in which 2013 and 2016 were the peaking years of accidents. The monthly distribution has an agglomeration effect, and the period from June to September had a high incidence period of accidents. The ArRAs mainly occurred in East China and Central China in the spatial dimension. Zhejiang, Shandong, Hubei, and Sichuan are the pivotal provinces for preventing and controlling ArRAs. Human factors and equipment failure are the leading causes of ArRAs. Accident numbers and casualties have inconsistent trends due to the uncertainty and variability of ArRAs' consequences. The safety situation of ammonia-related refrigeration enterprises has improved but still needs to strive to prevent and control major accidents. This study draws valuable references for safety decision-making by ammonia-related refrigeration enterprises and safety regulators.
BibTeX
@article{luo2022study,
  author = {Cong Luo and Yunsheng Zhao and Ke Xu},
  title = {{Study on the Regularity of Ammonia-Related Refrigeration Accidents in China from 2010 to 2020}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19148230},
}
Figure