Study on the Performance of Variable Density Multilayer Insulation in Liquid Hydrogen Temperature Region

Kecen Li, Jie Chen, Xueqin Tian, Yujing HeEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel method for optimizing variable-density multilayer insulation (VDMLI) for liquid hydrogen storage. By developing a detailed heat transfer model and a new configuration strategy, they demonstrate that a carefully designed VDMLI can significantly reduce heat flux by 8.6% compared to uniform-density insulation, crucial for efficient and safe hydrogen storage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The efficient and safe storage of liquid hydrogen is a critical bottleneck for the widespread adoption of hydrogen as a clean energy source. Liquid hydrogen's extremely low temperature and high energy density present significant thermal insulation challenges. Heat leakage leads to boil-off, causing pressure buildup and loss of valuable fuel. While multilayer insulation (MLI) is a standard solution, optimizing its performance, especially for variable-density configurations (VDMLI), under liquid hydrogen conditions requires a deeper understanding of heat transfer mechanisms and precise design strategies. Existing research often focuses on aerospace applications or complex composite structures, leaving a gap for optimizing simpler VDMLI for broader civil applications.

Methods

The authors developed a layer-by-layer heat transfer model to simulate the thermal performance of MLI. This model accounts for three primary heat transfer mechanisms: radiation, gas conduction, and solid conduction between adjacent radiation shields. To optimize the VDMLI, they proposed a novel variable-density configuration method that combines a "control variable method" with an "insertion by region" approach. This method involves dividing the insulation into three regions (low, medium, and high density) and systematically determining the optimal number of radiation shields in each region to minimize heat flux. Numerical calculations were performed using MATLAB to analyze the influence of various parameters like the number of layers, thermal boundary temperature, and vacuum levels.

Datasets

The paper uses experimental data from a previous study [31] for validation of their proposed variable-density configuration method. This dataset involved a specific variable-density multilayer insulation configuration under liquid hydrogen temperature conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Layer-by-layer analysis is crucial: Understanding how heat flux components (radiation, gas, solid conduction) change across individual layers is key to optimizing insulation, not just looking at the total heat flux.
  • VDMLI offers significant advantages: A well-designed VDMLI can outperform uniform-density MLI, especially at liquid hydrogen temperatures, by strategically placing more radiation shields in regions where heat transfer is more dominant.
  • Optimizing VDMLI requires a systematic approach: The proposed "control variable" and "insertion by region" method provides a precise way to determine the optimal layer distribution, moving beyond simpler sub-regional density adjustments.
  • Vacuum is paramount: Maintaining a high vacuum (below 0.01 Pa, ideally below 10⁻³ Pa) is critical. Once the vacuum is compromised, gas conduction becomes significant, drastically increasing heat flux.
  • Thermal boundary temperature is a major driver: Heat flux is highly sensitive to the hot side temperature, with radiation being the dominant heat transfer mechanism in vacuum conditions.

Key Results

  • The developed layer-by-layer model accurately predicted temperature distributions, showing good agreement with experimental data with a heat flux error of 1.5%.
  • Increasing the total number of layers generally reduces heat flux, but the benefit diminishes significantly after approximately 50 layers, while mass and thickness continue to increase linearly.
  • A vacuum pressure above 0.01 Pa leads to a substantial increase in heat flux, indicating a loss of effective insulation.
  • The optimal variable-density configuration identified consists of 4 layers in the low-density region, 15 in the medium-density region, and 38 in the high-density region.
  • This optimal VDMLI configuration achieved a heat flux reduction of 8.6% compared to a uniform-density structure under the tested conditions (20 K cold boundary, 300 K hot boundary, 61 total layers).
  • The VDMLI structure consistently outperformed uniform-density MLI across a thermal boundary temperature range of 240 K to 350 K.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fixed number of regions: The study divides the insulation into three regions. Future work could explore the impact of a different number of regions or a more continuous variable-density profile.
  • Specific materials: The study focuses on specific materials (aluminized shields, Dacron net spacer). Investigating the performance with other materials could broaden applicability.
  • Transient analysis: While the model is capable of iterative calculations, the primary focus is on steady-state performance. Further analysis of transient heat transfer during filling or operational changes could be valuable.
  • Cost-effectiveness: While the paper aims to improve performance without composite structures, a detailed cost-benefit analysis of implementing VDMLI in large-scale civil applications would be beneficial.
  • Adsorption materials: The paper briefly mentions adsorption materials for maintaining vacuum. Future work could integrate the modeling of such materials into the VDMLI system.

Summary updated

Abstract

The storage of hydrogen is important for the development of hydrogen energy, especially for the storage of liquid hydrogen, which has been receiving more and more attention recently. In order to study the thermal insulation performance of variable-density multilayer insulation (VDMLI) structures under different working conditions at liquid hydrogen temperatures without incorporating a composite structure, we established a heat transfer model based on a layer-by-layer calculation method. Then, we carried out numerical calculations to analyze the influence of the total number of layers, the thermal boundary temperature, and vacuums on the performance of MLI at liquid hydrogen temperatures. To investigate the optimization of variable-density configurations on the thermal insulation performance of VDMLI and to obtain accurate variable-density configurations, we proposed a variable-density configuration method based on the control variable method and the insertion by region method. The results indicate that the optimal variable-density configuration is the insertion of 4 layers of radiation shields in the low-density region, 15 layers in the medium-density region and 38 layers in the high-density region. Compared with a uniform-density structure, the heat flux is reduced by 8.6%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022study,
  author = {Kecen Li and Jie Chen and Xueqin Tian and Yujing He},
  title = {{Study on the Performance of Variable Density Multilayer Insulation in Liquid Hydrogen Temperature Region}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15249267},
}
Figure