Study on the Influencing Factors of Digital Transformation of Construction Enterprises from the Perspective of Dual Effects—A Hybrid Approach Based on PLS-SEM and fsQCA

Guanqiao Zhang, Tao Wang, Yuhan Wang, Shuai Zhang, Wenhao Lin, Zixin Dou, Haitao DuSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the complex factors driving digital transformation in Chinese construction firms, using a hybrid approach combining PLS-SEM and fsQCA. It reveals that while individual factors like technology use and relative advantage are important, specific combinations of technological, organizational, and environmental elements are crucial for achieving high-level digital transformation. Top management and policy support emerge as critical enablers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction industry, despite its importance, faces significant challenges like low productivity, safety issues, and resource waste, making digital transformation essential for sustainable development. However, research on the specific mechanisms and influencing factors of this transformation in construction enterprises, particularly in China, is still developing. Existing studies often focus on single factors or lack a comprehensive view of how multiple factors interact. This paper aims to fill this gap by exploring both the individual (net) effects and the combined (configurational) effects of various factors on digital transformation, offering a more nuanced understanding of this complex process.

Methods

The study employs a dual-approach methodology:

  • Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM): This statistical technique was used to analyze the "net effect" of individual influencing factors on digital transformation. It allows for testing direct and indirect relationships within a complex model.
  • Fuzzy-Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA): This method was used to explore the "configurational effect," identifying different combinations of factors that lead to either high-level or low-level digital transformation. fsQCA is particularly useful for understanding how multiple conditions work together to produce an outcome, acknowledging causal asymmetry.

These methods were applied to data collected from a survey of construction enterprise managers.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 236 valid questionnaires collected from construction enterprise managers in China. The data was gathered through an online survey platform. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study relies on existing survey data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Individual Factors: The research highlights that simply having individual "good" factors isn't enough. The combination of factors is what truly drives successful digital transformation. This shifts the focus from optimizing single variables to understanding synergistic effects.
  • Internal Focus for High Transformation: For achieving high levels of digital transformation, internal organizational factors (like technology use, digital employees, organizational readiness, strategy, and top management support) are paramount, often outweighing external pressures.
  • External Push for Low Transformation: Conversely, a lack of external environmental pressure (like competitive or partner pressure) and insufficient top management/policy support can lead to low-level digital transformation, suggesting that external incentives can be crucial for initiating change.
  • Top Management & Policy as Linchpins: Across both net and configurational analyses, top management support and policy support consistently emerge as critical drivers, underscoring their foundational role in enabling and guiding digital transformation efforts.
  • Digital Employees' Limited Impact (Currently): Surprisingly, digital employees, while theoretically important, showed no significant direct impact. This might be due to the nascent stage of digital integration in Chinese construction, where digital skills are often limited to basic applications or are hampered by high employee turnover.

Key Results

Net Effect (PLS-SEM):

  • Significant Positive Impacts: Use of digital technology, relative advantage, digital transformation strategy, top management support, competitive pressure, and policy support positively influence digital transformation.
  • Significant Negative Impact: Digital costs negatively impact digital transformation.
  • Non-Significant Impacts: Digital employees and organizational readiness did not show a significant direct impact in this study.
  • Mediating Role: Top management support partially mediates the relationship between relative advantage and competitive pressure, and digital transformation.

Configurational Effect (fsQCA):

  • High-Level Digital Transformation: Three distinct configurations of factors lead to high-level digital transformation, with core enabling conditions including technology use, digital employees, organizational readiness, digital transformation strategy, top management support, and policy support.
  • Low-Level Digital Transformation: One configuration points to low-level digital transformation, characterized by the absence of external environmental pressure and insufficient top management/policy support.

Limitations and Future Work

  • TOE Framework Limitation: The study is limited to the Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) framework. Future research could incorporate other theoretical lenses, such as PPM theory, for a more holistic view.
  • Respondent Familiarity: The relatively new nature of digital transformation in traditional construction enterprises meant some respondents might have had limited experience, potentially affecting the empirical findings.
  • fsQCA Novelty: The application of fsQCA in this context is novel, and future work could explore its extension, perhaps by integrating deep learning algorithms to predict future digital transformation factors.
  • Firm Size: The study did not account for firm size, which could influence digital transformation paths, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises compared to larger ones. Future research should investigate these differences.

Summary updated

Abstract

The digital transformation of Chinese construction enterprises is crucial for achieving sustainable and high-quality development in the construction industry. However, there is still a lack of in-depth research on the impact mechanism of digital transformation in construction enterprises. The purpose of this study is to explore the multiple influencing factors and complex causal relationships of digital transformation in construction enterprises and promote the deep integration of digitalization and construction enterprises. To this end, based on the dual-effect perspective (net effect perspective of a single influencing factor and configuration effect perspective of multiple influencing factors), using the “technology–organization–environment” framework (TOE framework) to construct a research model of influencing factors for digital transformation in construction enterprises. A sample of 236 construction enterprise managers was surveyed, and partial least squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM) and fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) methods were used to empirically analyze the dual effects of influencing factors for digital transformation in construction enterprises. The results show that: (1) from the net effect perspective, there are seven factors that significantly impact digital transformation in construction enterprises; (2) from the configuration effect perspective, there are three paths that can achieve high-level digital transformation in construction enterprises, and one path that leads to low-level digital transformation; (3) from the dual-effect perspective, top management support and policy support are key factors for digital transformation in Chinese construction enterprises. The research results enrich the relevant research on digital transformation in construction enterprises and provide a reference basis for promoting digital transformation in construction enterprises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023study,
  author = {Guanqiao Zhang and Tao Wang and Yuhan Wang and Shuai Zhang and Wenhao Lin and Zixin Dou and Haitao Du},
  title = {{Study on the Influencing Factors of Digital Transformation of Construction Enterprises from the Perspective of Dual Effects—A Hybrid Approach Based on PLS-SEM and fsQCA}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15076317},
}
Figure