Study on the impact of different friction coefficient combinations of disc spring assemblies on load

Yuan Yuan, Shuaiyan Li, Tianyi Su, Zhongliang Song, Xiang LiJOURNAL 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how friction and the configuration of disc springs (nested, stacked, composite) affect their load-bearing capacity, particularly within disc spring bellows. By combining numerical simulations and experimental validation, the study develops a more accurate load prediction model for composite disc springs, crucial for their engineering applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Disc springs are essential components in many mechanical systems due to their high load capacity and compact design. However, their performance, especially in assemblies like those used in disc spring bellows, is significantly influenced by friction between the spring surfaces and how multiple springs are combined. While research exists on single disc springs and some combinations, a comprehensive understanding of how different friction coefficients interact with various assembly configurations (nested, stacked, composite) and the number of discs is still needed. This lack of detailed knowledge hinders precise design and optimization, particularly for applications like disc spring bellows where reliable load prediction is critical. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically analyzing these influences and providing a validated predictive model.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Numerical Simulation: They developed finite element models for disc spring assemblies in nested, stacked, and composite configurations. These models were used to simulate the load-displacement behavior under varying numbers of discs and friction coefficients (0, 0.1, and 0.16).
  • Experimental Validation: Experiments were conducted using disc spring samples with different surface treatments (galvanized, graphite-coated, and lubricated) to achieve the target friction coefficients. A universal testing machine was used to measure the force-displacement curves.
  • Model Development: Based on the simulation and experimental data, the authors refined existing load calculation formulas and developed a new prediction model specifically for composite disc spring configurations, incorporating the influence of friction and the number of discs.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated by the authors and numerical simulation results.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Friction is a significant load influencer: The study clearly demonstrates that increasing the friction coefficient consistently increases the load-bearing capacity of disc springs. This is attributed to the increased frictional force generated by the rubbing surfaces as the discs compress or expand.
  • Configuration matters for load behavior:
    • Nested: The number of discs has little effect on the load; it remains similar to a single disc spring.
  • Stacked: The load increases linearly with the number of discs, and friction has a more pronounced effect as the number of discs increases due to larger contact areas.
  • Composite: The load shows a non-linear increase with the number of discs, and friction's influence also amplifies with more layers.
  • Accuracy of the composite model: The developed numerical model for composite disc springs, when validated against experimental results, showed very low relative errors (as low as 1.4%), confirming its reliability for predicting load.
  • Friction's impact stabilizes: For composite disc springs, the relative load increase due to friction appears to stabilize after a certain number of layers (around 8 layers in their study).

Key Results

  • Experimental vs. Numerical Errors: Relative errors between numerical calculations and experimental results for 56 composite disc springs were:
  • Friction coefficient µ=0: 3.3%

    • Friction coefficient µ=0.1: 1.5%
    • Friction coefficient µ=0.16: 1.4% These low errors validate the accuracy of their proposed model.
  • Friction's Load Increase in Stacked Springs: For stacked disc springs, a friction coefficient of 0.16 led to a 3.7% load increase for 2 discs and a significant 27% increase for 10 discs compared to a frictionless scenario.

  • Composite Model Refinement: A prediction model for composite disc springs was developed and validated, providing guidance for selecting disc springs in bellows.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Nonlinearity in Three-Layer Composites: While the model is accurate for two-layer composite disc springs, applying it to three-layer configurations resulted in larger prediction errors due to increased nonlinearity.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest further research to address the pronounced nonlinearity observed in three-layer composite disc springs and to extend the model's applicability. They also mention that the influence of friction on load stabilizes after a certain number of layers, which could be further explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper focuses on the disc spring assembly in a certain type of disc spring bellows as the research object. According to the technical requirements of the bellows, disc spring assemblies with different combinations (face-to-face, stacked, and composite) are designed. The influence of the number of discs and different combinations on the load of disc spring assemblies with different friction coefficients is analyzed using numerical simulation methods and verified by experiments. The simulation results show that the number of discs in the face-to-face combination has no effect on the load, the number of discs in the stacked combination has a linearly increasing effect on the load, and the number of discs in the composite combination has a non-linear effect on the load. Furthermore, the numerical calculation results of the load with friction coefficients of 0, 0.1, and 0.16 are compared with the experimental results. The relative errors between the two results are 3.3%, 1.5%, and 1.4%, respectively, and the error values are within the allowable range, which verifies the accuracy of the load calculation model. After discussing the combination methods, finally, through comparative analysis, the load model of the composite disc spring structure is used to fit a prediction model of the number of discs and the load considering the influence of friction, which provides a theoretical reference for the engineering application of disc spring assemblies in disc spring bellows.
BibTeX
@article{yuan2025study,
  author = {Yuan Yuan and Shuaiyan Li and Tianyi Su and Qingdi Yuan and Zhongliang Song and Xiang Li},
  title = {{Study on the impact of different friction coefficient combinations of disc spring assemblies on load}},
  journal = {JOURNAL},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.15282/jmes.19.1.2025.11.0828},
}
Figure