Study on the Homogeneity of Large-Size Blade Lithium-Ion Batteries Based on Thermoelectric Coupling Model Simulation

Fei Chen, Wenkuan Zhu, Xiangdong Kong, Yunfeng Huang, Yu Wang, Yuejiu Zheng, Dongsheng RenEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

As lithium-ion batteries get bigger to pack more energy, they're facing a new challenge: inhomogeneity. This paper tackles this by developing a detailed 3D electro-thermal model to understand and predict how temperature and charge distribution become uneven in large-format cells. They then use this model to propose strategies for improving battery performance and longevity by optimizing cell design and thermal management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The drive for higher energy density in electric vehicles and energy storage systems has led to the development of larger lithium-ion battery cells, often referred to as "blade" batteries. While larger cells offer more capacity, they also introduce significant challenges related to inhomogeneity. This means that properties like temperature, state of charge (SOC), and current density can vary considerably across the cell. This unevenness can lead to accelerated aging, reduced performance, and even safety concerns like localized abuse failure. Existing models often struggle to capture these complex, coupled electro-thermal phenomena in large-format cells, necessitating a more sophisticated approach.

Methods

The core of this research is a three-dimensional (3D) electro-thermal coupling model. This model builds upon the established pseudo-two-dimensional (P2D) model, which describes the electrochemical processes within a battery, and integrates it with a solid-state heat transfer model.

Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Experimental Characterization: They began by conducting extensive experimental tests on a commercial 135 Ah prismatic blade battery. This included capacity tests at various temperatures and charge/discharge rates, as well as measuring equilibrium potentials of electrode materials. This data was crucial for parameterizing their model.
  • Model Development: A 3D model was constructed using COMSOL Multiphysics®. This model accounts for the coupled electrochemical reactions (like intercalation and deintercalation) and the heat generation and dissipation within the battery. The 3D aspect is key to capturing spatial variations that 2D models might miss.
  • Parameter Identification: Key parameters for both the electrochemical and thermal aspects of the model were identified through a combination of experimental data, literature references, and material property databases. This included parameters like thermal conductivity, specific heat capacity, diffusion coefficients, and reaction kinetics.
  • Model Verification: The developed 3D model was rigorously validated against experimental data. They compared simulated charging voltage curves and temperature responses under various operating conditions (different temperatures and C-rates) with actual measurements.
  • Inhomogeneity Analysis: Using the validated model, they analyzed the distribution of SOC, current density, and temperature within the large-size cell under different charging scenarios. This allowed them to pinpoint the mechanisms driving inhomogeneity.
  • Optimization Strategies: Based on the insights gained from the model, they proposed two main strategies to mitigate inhomogeneity:
  • Battery Connection Optimization: Increasing the contact area of the lug connections to improve current distribution.
  • Thermal Management Strategy: Adjusting convective heat transfer coefficients at different locations on the cell to better manage localized heat buildup.

Datasets

The paper utilizes experimental data collected from a commercial prismatic power battery with a nominal capacity of 135 Ah. This battery uses LiFePO4 as the cathode and graphite as the negative electrode. The experimental data includes:

  • Capacity charge/discharge tests at various temperatures (-10 °C, 0 °C, 25 °C, 45 °C) and C-rates (0.2C to 2C).
  • Equilibrium potential curves of the positive and negative electrodes.
  • Temperature measurements at multiple points on the battery surface during charging and discharging.
  • Voltage responses during charging under different conditions.

The paper also references material property data from the COMSOL Multiphysics® (version 5.4) large-size battery materials library.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Size Matters (for Inhomogeneity): As battery cells scale up, inherent inhomogeneities become much more pronounced and critical to address.
  • Coupled Phenomena are Key: Temperature and electrochemical processes are not independent; they strongly influence each other, especially in large cells. A model that captures this coupling is essential.
  • Lug Design is Crucial: The design of the current collection points (lugs) significantly impacts current distribution and, consequently, temperature inhomogeneity. Larger contact areas can help.
  • Localized Thermal Management is Effective: Simply applying uniform cooling isn't enough. Tailoring heat dissipation at specific locations on the cell can significantly reduce temperature gradients.
  • Model as a Design Tool: The validated 3D electro-thermal model serves as a powerful tool for understanding the root causes of inhomogeneity and for designing optimized battery architectures and thermal management systems.

Key Results

  • The 3D electro-thermal coupling model demonstrated good accuracy in predicting charging voltage curves, with RMSE voltages generally below 7.5 mV at 25 °C and 45 °C.
  • The model accurately simulated temperature responses, with average temperature errors less than 2 °C.
  • Analysis revealed that temperature inhomogeneity increases with higher charging rates. For example, at 25 °C, the maximum temperature difference at the charging cut-off increased from 0.4 °C at 0.5 C to 8.8 °C at 2 C.
  • SOC distribution also showed inhomogeneity, with differences of up to 7% observed at higher charging rates.
  • Optimizing lug connection area reduced the maximum temperature difference from 51.2 °C to 46.9 °C at 2 C charging.
  • Adjusting convective heat transfer coefficients at lug sides reduced the temperature on those sides by about 10 °C and the maximum temperature difference by over 1 °C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Data Limitations: While extensive, the experimental data is based on a single type of large-size battery. Further validation with different cell chemistries and form factors would be beneficial.
  • Model Simplifications: The paper mentions that the model is based on pseudo-two-dimensional theory, which inherently involves some simplifications.
  • Focus on Charging: The primary focus of the inhomogeneity analysis and optimization was on charging conditions. Further investigation into discharging and mixed cycling scenarios would be valuable.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The authors suggest that the developed model can be used for further optimization of cell connection methods and thermal management strategies. They also imply that this work lays the foundation for state estimation and management of large-size batteries.

Summary updated

Abstract

To improve the energy density of lithium-ion battery packs, lithium-ion batteries are gradually advancing towards large-size structures, which has become one of the dominant development trends in the battery industry. With large-size blade lithium-ion batteries as the research object, this paper develops a high-precision electro-thermal coupling model based on the relevant parameters obtained through basic performance experiments, explores the mechanism of battery inhomogeneity from a simulation perspective, and further proposes a design management method. First of all, the optimal intervals of capacity and temperature, as well as the characteristics of the inhomogeneity distribution for large-size cells, are determined by essential performance and inhomogeneity tests; subsequently, the electrochemical and thermal characteristics of the large-size battery are described precisely through a 3D thermoelectric coupling mechanism model, and the inhomogeneity of the temperature distribution is obtained through simulation; eventually, the optimized cell connection method and thermal management strategy are proposed based on the validated model. As indicated by the findings, the above solutions effectively ease the inhomogeneity of large-size cells and significantly boost the performance of large-size cells under different operating conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2022study,
  author = {Fei Chen and Wenkuan Zhu and Xiangdong Kong and Yunfeng Huang and Yu Wang and Yuejiu Zheng and Dongsheng Ren},
  title = {{Study on the Homogeneity of Large-Size Blade Lithium-Ion Batteries Based on Thermoelectric Coupling Model Simulation}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15249556},
}
Figure