Study on the effect of rubber content on the frost resistance of steel fiber reinforced rubber concrete

Lei Jiang, Jiahua Jing, Ming Zhang, Shuai YangScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have identified that adding exactly 10% waste rubber to steel fiber-reinforced concrete creates a "sweet spot" for durability in freezing climates. While rubber improves elasticity and pore structure, exceeding this limit triggers a sharp decline in performance due to weak internal bonding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In cold regions, concrete pavement is under constant attack from freeze-thaw (F-T) cycles. As water trapped in the concrete's pores freezes, it expands, creating internal pressure that eventually leads to cracking, scaling, and structural failure.

Engineers have turned to "rubberized concrete"—incorporating recycled tire particles—because it is environmentally friendly and adds much-needed elasticity. However, rubber typically reduces the concrete's compressive strength. To fix this, "Steel Fiber Reinforced Rubber Concrete" (SFRRC) was developed, using high-modulus steel fibers to bridge cracks and restore strength. The missing piece of the puzzle was understanding exactly how much rubber is "too much" when it comes to long-term frost resistance.

Methods

The research team prepared four types of SFRRC with varying rubber content (0%, 5%, 10%, and 15% replacement of fine aggregate by volume), all containing a consistent 1.5% volume fraction of wave-shaped steel fibers.

To simulate years of winter wear, they used a Rapid Freeze-Thaw Test, subjecting specimens to 300 cycles of extreme temperature swings (-18°C to 5°C). They didn't just look at the surface; they employed several sophisticated diagnostic tools:

  • Ultrasonic Testing: To measure the Damage Layer Thickness ($H_f$), a metric that tracks how deep the F-T damage penetrates from the surface to the core.
  • Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry (MIP): To "see" the internal pore structure and categorize pores by size (harmless vs. harmful).
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To observe the Interfacial Transition Zone (ITZ)—the microscopic "glue" between the rubber particles and the cement matrix.

Datasets

As an experimental materials science study, the "dataset" consists of the primary data generated from the four experimental groups (SFR0C, SFR5C, SFR10C, and SFR15C). The authors compared their findings against established Chinese national standards for Portland cement (GB 175-2007) and fly ash (GB/T 1596-2017).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Air-Entrainment Effect: Rubber particles act like a solid version of air-entraining agents. They introduce tiny, enclosed "harmless" pores (<20 nm) that act as pressure relief valves for expanding ice.
  • The 10% Threshold: Up to 10% rubber content, the benefits of improved pore structure and increased elasticity outweigh the loss in bonding. At this level, the steel fibers and rubber work in tandem: rubber absorbs stress, while fibers prevent cracks from propagating.
  • The Hydrophobic Downside: Rubber is hydrophobic (water-repelling). At 15% content, the bond between the rubber and the cement (the ITZ) becomes the "weakest link." These weak interfaces eventually interconnect, creating "harmful" large pores (>200 nm) that actually accelerate damage rather than preventing it.
  • Surface-to-Interior Degradation: The study quantifies that F-T damage isn't uniform; it creates a distinct "damage layer" that grows thicker over time. Measuring the velocity of ultrasonic waves through this layer proved to be a highly accurate way to predict structural health.

Key Results

  • Optimal Performance: The SFR10C (10% rubber) group was the clear winner. After 300 F-T cycles, it showed the lowest mass loss (2.92%) and the highest Relative Dynamic Modulus of Elasticity (75.81%).
  • The 15% Failure: Increasing rubber to 15% caused a performance "cliff." Mass loss jumped to 4.01%, and the damage layer thickness ($H_f$) reached 19.07 mm, significantly worse than even the concrete with no rubber at all.
  • Pore Refinement: In the 10% rubber mix, the number of "harmless" pores increased by 35.23% compared to the 5% mix, while harmful pores decreased by roughly 30%.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study focused exclusively on one size of rubber particles (1–2 mm) and one specific steel fiber content. They suggest that future research should explore:

  1. Hybrid Fibers: Combining steel fibers with synthetic fibers to see if frost resistance can be pushed even further.
  2. Salt-Frost Durability: Testing how these mixes hold up when de-icing salts are involved, which is a common real-world scenario for pavements.
  3. Varying Particle Sizes: Investigating if finer rubber powders or larger crumbs change the "sweet spot" percentage.

Summary updated

Abstract

In cold areas, the steel fiber reinforced rubber concrete (SFRRC) pavement is exposed to natural environment and experiences varying degrees of damage from freezing and thawing. This can have a serious impact on the normal usage and safe operation of the pavement structure. This research examines the impact of varying rubber concentrations on multiple variables, such as the rate of mass reduction, relative dynamic modulus of elasticity, compressive strength, and thickness of the damage layer (H<sub>f</sub>) during freeze-thaw (F-T) durability testing conducted on SFRRC. Furthermore, an analysis is conducted to determine the degradation pattern exhibited by SFRRC. The internal structure evolution and pore structure characteristics of SFRRC were examined using scanning electron microscopy and mercury intrusion porosimetry techniques, which revealed the underlying damage mechanism in SFRRC during F-T cycles. The results suggest that the addition of an appropriate amount of rubber can effectively enhance the frost resistance of SFRRC in water. A gradual improvement in the frost resistance of SFRRC is observed when increasing the rubber content from 0 to 10%. The optimal frost resistance is observed in SFRRC with 10% rubber content. However, when the rubber content reaches 15%, SFRRC exhibits significant degradation and lower level of resistance to freezing compared to SFRRC without rubber. Microcracks form within SFRRC due to the freezing-thawing forces experienced during the experiment, resulting in the development of a damage layer that extends from the surface to the interior. The compressive strength of the damaged layer significantly decreases as H<sub>f</sub> increases. The addition of appropriate rubber in SFRRC improves its pore structure, leading to an increased proportion of harmless or less harmful pores and a reduction in average pore size, thereby significantly enhancing its frost resistance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2024study,
  author = {Lei Jiang and Jiahua Jing and Ming Zhang and Shuai Yang},
  title = {{Study on the effect of rubber content on the frost resistance of steel fiber reinforced rubber concrete}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-64719-9},
}
Figure