Study on the Distribution Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Traditional Villages in the Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guizhou Rocky Desertification Area

Guanglei Yang, Lixin Wu, Liang Xie, Zhezheng Liu, Zhe LiSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the spatial distribution of traditional villages in China's Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guizhou rocky desertification area, revealing a clustered pattern primarily driven by socio-economic and national cultural factors, rather than natural environmental ones. The findings offer crucial insights for developing targeted strategies to preserve these villages while promoting sustainable development in this ecologically sensitive region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guizhou region is characterized by a unique and challenging environment: extensive rocky desertification, a high concentration of ethnic minorities, and significant poverty. Within this context, traditional villages, which embody rich cultural heritage and historical wisdom, are facing threats of attrition and disappearance due to modernization and environmental pressures. While previous research has explored traditional village distribution, a comprehensive understanding of the specific interplay of factors influencing their location within this particular, complex region was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by identifying the spatial patterns of these villages and dissecting the natural, socio-economic, and cultural drivers behind their distribution, paving the way for effective conservation and development strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and Geodetector software.

  • Spatial Distribution Analysis: Standard GIS techniques were used to map and analyze the villages. This included:
  • Average Nearest Neighbor Index: To determine if the distribution is clustered, random, or dispersed.
  • Voronoi Diagram: To visualize spatial relationships and identify areas of concentration.
  • Kernel Density Analysis: To map the density of villages and identify hot spots.
  • Geographic Concentration Index & Imbalance Index: To quantify the degree of concentration and unevenness in distribution.
  • Moran's I Index: To assess spatial autocorrelation, indicating whether nearby villages are similar in their distribution.
  • Lorentz Curve: To visualize the balance or imbalance of distribution.
  • Influencing Factor Analysis: The Geodetector software was the core tool for identifying and quantifying the influence of various factors. This method allows for the assessment of both individual factor impacts and the interaction effects between multiple factors on spatial phenomena.

Datasets

The study utilized data from various sources for 705 officially recognized traditional villages in the Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guizhou rocky desertification area:

  • Traditional Village Locations: Sourced from official Chinese Traditional Village Directories.
  • Natural Environmental Data:
    • Elevation and terrain relief (from Geospatial Data Cloud).
  • River networks (from National Earth System Science Data Center).
  • Climate data (temperature and precipitation) (from National Earth System Science Data Center).
  • Rocky desertification sensitivity (from a research paper).
  • Socio-economic Data:
    • Population density and urbanization rate (from regional almanacs and census data).
  • Per capita GDP (from regional almanacs and census data).
  • Road and transportation network data.
  • National Cultural Data:
    • Ethnic minority population proportion (from regional almanacs and census data).
  • Quantity of national intangible cultural heritage (from Digital Museum of China Intangible Cultural Heritage).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Socio-economic and Cultural Dominance: Surprisingly, socio-economic factors (like population density and urbanization) and national cultural factors (especially intangible heritage) exert a stronger influence on traditional village distribution than natural environmental factors. This challenges the common assumption that natural conditions are the primary drivers.
  • Interaction is Key: The influence of factors is not additive; they interact in complex, often nonlinear ways. This means that the combined effect of two factors can be greater than the sum of their individual impacts, highlighting the need for holistic analysis.
  • "Living in Steep Environments": Historically, villages were often situated at higher elevations with significant relief, not just for strategic reasons or to avoid conflict, but also to maximize limited arable land in a rocky desertification-prone area.
  • Urbanization's Double-Edged Sword: While urbanization can lead to rural-to-urban migration and the decline of traditional villages, it also presents opportunities for economic development and preservation through initiatives like tourism and cultural industrialization, particularly when managed effectively.
  • Anshun as an Anomaly: The Anshun region stands out as an area with high socio-economic indicators that still retains a significant number of traditional villages, attributed to unique historical factors (Tunpu settlements) and proactive tourism development.

Key Results

  • Clustered Distribution: Traditional villages in the study area exhibit a clear clustered distribution pattern, with pronounced concentrations in Southeast Guizhou and secondary clusters in Anshun and Guilin.
  • Factor Influence Ranking: Geodetector analysis revealed the following order of explanatory power for influencing factors: Intangible cultural heritage > Population density > Urbanization rate > Per capita GDP > Minority population proportion > Precipitation > Temperature > Rocky desertification > Elevation > River distance > Road distance > Relief degree.
  • Natural Environment as Foundation: Natural environmental factors (like terrain and climate) laid the initial groundwork for village placement.
  • Ethnic Culture as Deepener: National cultural factors (ethnic minority population and intangible heritage) then accentuated regional differences in distribution.
  • Socio-economic as Catalyst: Socio-economic factors (urbanization, economy) have become critical drivers for the sustainable development and preservation of these villages in the modern era.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Difficulty in Quantifying Culture: The authors acknowledge that reproducing the environment of ancient times and quantifying historic culture are inherent limitations. Future work could explore more specific methodologies for this.
  • Macro-Level Focus: This study adopted a macro-level approach. Future research could delve into micro-level aspects such as spatial layout, architectural characteristics, and detailed ecological management within individual villages.
  • Data Availability: While not explicitly stated as a limitation, the reliance on existing datasets implies potential constraints if finer-grained or more specific data were needed.

The study's findings provide a strong theoretical foundation for developing targeted protection and development strategies, including ecological preservation and tourism, cultural heritage conservation, and eco-agriculture, tailored to the unique conditions of this region and potentially serving as a model for similar areas globally.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper aims to analyze the distribution patterns of the Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guizhou rocky desertification area, and provide efficient protection and development strategies. This region has a complex geographical environment, and it is distinguished by hosting China’s largest ethnic minority population and the highest concentration of autonomous ethnic counties among contiguous impoverished areas, with numerous traditional villages. Thus, it is significant to conduct a comprehensive study of traditional villages within this domain, with a particular focus on their centralized preservation and strategic utilization. This research employed ArcGIS and Geodetector software for a rigorous analysis of the spatial distribution characteristics and influential factors of traditional villages in the Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guizhou rocky desertification area. The key findings can be summarized as follows. (1) The traditional villages in this region predominantly exhibit an agglomerative distribution pattern, with pronounced concentrations in southeast Guizhou and secondary concentrations in Anshun and Guilin. (2) Natural environmental factors, social economic factors, and national cultural factors impact the distribution of traditional villages synthetically by positive, median, or negative correlation. (3) The results of the Geodetector show that, significantly, social economic and national cultural factors exert a more pronounced influence than natural environmental factors, especially population density and intangible heritage quantity. The interaction of multiple factors shows an enhanced trend. (4) From the perspective of formation mechanism, natural environmental factors serve as foundational elements shaping the original distribution pattern; national cultural factors act as dominant determinants, accentuating spatial distribution distinctions across various regions and social economic factors emerge as critical catalysts for the sustainable development of traditional villages. The interaction factors can have a more profound impact. Furthermore, it is expected that this study will contribute to the effectiveness of ecology and economy in this area and more analogous regions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2023study,
  author = {Guanglei Yang and Lixin Wu and Liang Xie and Zhezheng Liu and Zhe Li},
  title = {{Study on the Distribution Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Traditional Villages in the Yunnan, Guangxi, and Guizhou Rocky Desertification Area}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su152014902},
}
Figure