Study on the Combination of “Online Open Course” and “Cloud Class” in the Embryology Teaching: a randomized controlled trial

Linlin Gong, Yang Song, Xin Zhou, Jun Hu, Jian Li, Xinming Chi, Liyuan Zhang, Wanjiang Chu, Lihong HaoResearch Square 2019 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates a blended teaching strategy combining "online open courses" (MOOCs) and a mobile "Cloud Class" app in embryology education. Through a prospective randomized controlled trial, researchers compared this new approach against traditional teaching methods. Results indicated a statistically significant improvement in academic achievement for the experimental group ($p = 0.005$), alongside high student satisfaction and improved self-learning abilities.

Introduction

Embryology is a foundational yet challenging subject in medical education due to its dynamic and three-dimensional nature. Traditional "passive" lectures often fail to maintain student engagement. This research addresses the need for modern pedagogical frameworks that effectively integrate digital tools, shifting the classroom focus from basic knowledge acquisition to active, high-level problem-solving.

Methods

A prospective, randomized controlled trial was conducted with 176 first-year medical students at Dalian Medical University.

  • Experimental Group (n=89): Utilized a blended learning model. Students engaged with MOOC videos and mind maps before class. In-class time was "flipped," focusing on student-led questions via the "Cloud Class" app and Case-Based Learning (CBL).
  • Control Group (n=87): Received standard face-to-face lectures.

The "Cloud Class" app facilitated real-time quizzes and tracked formative assessment data. Statistical analysis was performed using the rank sum test to measure differences between the groups.

Results

The implementation of the blended teaching strategy led to a marked improvement in academic performance. The experimental group achieved a significantly higher rank mean in the embryology section of the final exam compared to the control group.

Comparison of rank means for exam scores between the experimental and control groups.

Statistical analysis confirmed that these differences were significant, with a p-value of 0.005, indicating that the blended model was more effective than traditional lecturing.

Statistical test results confirming the significance of the performance gap.

Beyond grades, over 90% of students in the experimental group expressed satisfaction with the online/offline combination. Students highlighted the ability to use "fragmented time" for review and the successful transition of smartphones from distractions to valuable learning tools.

Discussion

The "flipped" classroom model successfully moved lower-order cognitive tasks (remembering and understanding) to independent study, allowing classroom hours to be dedicated to higher-order analysis and evaluation. While the model showed great success, challenges remain regarding scalability for larger classes and overcoming student inertia toward passive learning.

Conclusion

The combination of MOOCs and "Cloud Class" provides a robust platform for enhancing student learning outcomes in embryology. This blended approach fosters "initiative learning" and appears highly effective for modern medical students.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background The purpose of this study was to illustrate that only by focusing on curriculum design and implementation can we use modern information education tools reasonably and effectively. Thus it could provide an interactive platform to improve the teaching quality and to change the traditional classroom from “passive learning” into “initiative learning”. Methods A prospective, randomized controlled study was performed. Students of Clinical Medicine (The First and Second Affiliated Hospital) enrolled in 2017 were taken as the research subjects. 3 classes were chosen in the experimental group using the new blended teaching strategy(combination of “online open courses” and “Cloud Class”), while the other 3 classes were allocated to the control group using the traditional teaching method. A questionnaire about “evaluation of learning environment, self-learning ability and teaching effects” was administered in the experimental group after class. The whole learning process was evaluated to form formative assessment, which worked as the daily grade. All the students took an examination in the final semester. Results The rank sum test were used to measure the statistical difference between the two groups. Comparison of academic achievement in the embryology part of final exam between the two groups, statistically significant differences could be identified (p =0.005). The results revealed that the combination teaching strategy could significantly enhance the final score of medical students compared with the control. The questionnaire showed that most students thought the new teaching method bringing a good experience of online learning. And application of smartphones not only stimulated their interests in learning, but also made perfect use of fragmented time. Reviewing videos after the class might prove more effective. Most students from the experimental group were satisfied with the new teaching strategy, and more than 90% students accepted this online and offline combination teaching module. Conclusion The combination of “online open courses” and “Cloud Class” provides a platform for improving students’ learning ability and learning effects. These results demonstrate that the new approach appears to be a successful learning method among the fresh students.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2019study,
  author = {Linlin Gong and Yang Song and Xin Zhou and Jun Hu and Jian Li and Xinming Chi and Liyuan Zhang and Wanjiang Chu and Lihong Hao},
  title = {{Study on the Combination of “Online Open Course” and “Cloud Class” in the Embryology Teaching: a randomized controlled trial}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.13068/v1},
}
Figure