Study on the co-occurrence of multiple health service needs throughout the lifecourse of rural residents in China based on association rules

Jingjing Jia, Xuejiao Liu, Panpan Ren, Mengyao Chen, Jinglin Xu, Xiang ZhangFrontiers in Public Health 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers used the Apriori association rule algorithm to analyze the health service needs of over 15,000 rural residents in China. They discovered that nearly 80% of residents have multiple, overlapping health needs that shift significantly across the life course, suggesting a critical need for "bundled" rather than siloed healthcare delivery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As China’s demographic and disease patterns shift from acute infectious diseases to chronic conditions, the "biomedical model"—which often treats health needs as isolated events—is becoming outdated. In the current "big health" era, residents often require a suite of services simultaneously (e.g., managing a chronic illness while seeking nutritional advice and physical therapy).

However, most existing research focuses on individual health services. This paper addresses the gap in understanding co-occurrence: how different health needs cluster together and how these clusters evolve as a person moves from infancy to old age. By identifying these patterns, the authors aim to provide a data-driven foundation for "packaging" health services more effectively at the grassroots level.

Methods

The study utilized a cross-sectional survey design with a massive sample size. To find patterns in the data, the authors turned to Association Rule Mining, specifically the Apriori algorithm. While common in retail (the "beer and diapers" market basket analysis), it is a novel way to look at public health.

The team evaluated relationships using three key metrics:

  • Support: How frequently a combination of needs appears in the population.
  • Confidence: The likelihood that a person needing Service A also needs Service B.
  • Lift: The strength of the association (a lift > 1 indicates a meaningful relationship beyond random chance).

Datasets

The researchers collected primary data through stratified random sampling across eastern, central, and western China.

  • Sample Size: 15,125 individuals from 5,040 households.
  • Scope: 12 specific health service needs were identified based on China’s "14+16" basic public health service projects, including Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), chronic disease management, and internet health information.
  • Response Rate: An impressive 93.33%.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Bundle" is the Norm: A staggering 78.72% of the population reported multiple simultaneous health needs. This confirms that single-service delivery models are likely failing to meet the comprehensive needs of the majority.
  • TCM as a "Gateway" Service: One of the most striking findings was that Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is rarely sought in isolation. It is almost always bundled with exercise guidance or health education, reflecting a holistic "harmony and unity" preference in the rural population.
  • The Life Course Pivot: Needs are not static.
  • Infancy (Life Preparation): Focuses on the intersection of modern medical care and child management.
  • Adulthood (Life Protection): Shifts toward preventive "maintenance" like exercise and internet health info.
  • Old Age (Life Maintenance): Becomes highly diverse and "long-tail," with strong links between chronic disease management and rehabilitation.
  • Digital Demand: Internet health information services ranked in the top three most-needed services (14.40%), suggesting that rural residents are increasingly looking to digital platforms to bridge the gap in health literacy.

Key Results

  • Overall Need Rate: 86.76% of rural residents have at least one health service need.
  • Top Three Needs: Physical exercise guidance (17.10%), TCM health care (15.53%), and internet health information (14.40%).
  • Strongest Elderly Association: The combination of chronic disease management and rehabilitation services showed the highest support (31.24%) among the older adult population.
  • Highest Lift: In children, the combination of modern medical care, TCM consultation, and child management yielded a lift of 13.59, indicating an extremely strong interdependency between these services.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this is a cross-sectional study, meaning it provides a snapshot in time rather than tracking individuals as they age. Furthermore, the data is self-reported, which introduces the risk of recall bias.

The study focused exclusively on rural areas; future research is needed to see if urban residents exhibit similar "bundling" patterns. The authors suggest that the next step for policymakers is to move away from "hospital-centric" models and toward integrated digital platforms that can deliver these identified service packages (e.g., an app that combines TCM advice with personalized exercise routines) directly to residents.

Summary updated

Abstract

The multiple health service needs rate among rural residents in China is high, with the greatest needs being for exercise guidance, Traditional Chinese Medicine health care, and internet health information services. There are significant differences in health service needs across different life stages. It is essential to enhance the integration and packaging of health service resources to promote diversity in health services and meet the multiple health service needs of residents throughout their life courses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jia2024study,
  author = {Jingjing Jia and Xuejiao Liu and Panpan Ren and Mengyao Chen and Jinglin Xu and Xiang Zhang},
  title = {{Study on the co-occurrence of multiple health service needs throughout the lifecourse of rural residents in China based on association rules}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2024.1480894},
}
Figure