Study on Seismic Response and Vibration Reduction of Shield Tunnel Lining in Coastal Areas

Sihui Dong, Xinyu Zhang, Chenxu Jia, Shiqun Li, Kang WangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the seismic response of shield tunnel linings in challenging coastal soil conditions using ANSYS simulations. It identifies critical areas of vulnerability under seismic loading and proposes foam concrete and rubber isolation layers as effective damping solutions, with foam concrete being recommended due to its cost-effectiveness and resistance to groundwater corrosion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Subway tunnels in coastal areas face unique challenges due to unstable soil, groundwater corrosion, and increased seismic vulnerability. These factors significantly complicate tunnel design and compromise safety during earthquakes. While research exists on seismic responses in mountain or deep-sea tunnels, there's a need for specific analysis concerning the complex soil conditions found in coastal floodplains, which combine weathered rock, silty clay, and high groundwater content. This paper aims to fill that gap by simulating the seismic behavior of a tunnel lining in such an environment and evaluating potential damping strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted numerical simulation approach using ANSYS software.

  • Static Analysis: This initial step assessed the tunnel lining's behavior under gravity and surrounding soil pressure to establish a baseline.
  • Modal Analysis: This technique identified the natural frequencies and vibration modes of the tunnel structure, highlighting points most susceptible to deformation.
  • Time History Analysis: This core dynamic analysis simulated the tunnel's response to a specific seismic wave (EI_Centro EW) over time, examining displacement, acceleration, and stress variations.
  • Damping Scheme Evaluation: The study then incorporated isolation layers (foam concrete and rubber) into the model to assess their effectiveness in reducing seismic stress and acceleration.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The seismic input used was the EI_Centro EW seismic wave, a commonly used benchmark for earthquake engineering simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Coastal Soil Complexity: The paper underscores that the combination of weathered rock, silty clay, and groundwater in coastal areas presents a distinct seismic challenge compared to typical mountain or deep-sea tunnel environments.
  • Vulnerability Hotspots: Static analysis revealed that the arch crown experiences the maximum displacement under gravity, while the left and right wall corners are subjected to the highest stress. Seismic analysis further indicated that the upper part of the lining is more vulnerable, with the right arch waist experiencing significant stress.
  • Isolation Layer Effectiveness: The introduction of damping layers (foam concrete and rubber) significantly reduced stress transfer to the tunnel lining, particularly at the arch waist.
  • Foam Concrete Advantage: While both isolation materials showed good damping, foam concrete is recommended due to its lower cost, environmental friendliness, ease of construction, and resistance to groundwater corrosion, making it a more practical choice for coastal tunnel projects.

Key Results

  • Under static conditions, the maximum displacement was 3.8 cm at the arch crown, and maximum stress was 2.6 × 10⁷ Pa at the wall corners.
  • During seismic analysis with the EI_Centro EW wave, the maximum stress reached 1.37 × 10⁻⁴ Pa at the right arch waist, and the maximum displacement was 3.65 × 10⁻¹⁰ m at the right wall.
  • The use of a rubber isolation layer reduced stress at the right arch waist by 76.4%, while foam concrete reduced it by approximately 80%.
  • Foam concrete is recommended due to its cost-effectiveness (approximately 380 yuan/m³ compared to 17,000 yuan/ton for rubber) and suitability for corrosive environments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Seismic Wave Data: The study acknowledges the lack of specific seismic wave data for the Dalian region and relied on a generalized seismic wave (EI_Centro EW). Future work could incorporate site-specific seismic records for more accurate predictions.
  • Simplified Soil Model: While the Drucker-Prager model was used, more advanced nonlinear soil models could potentially capture the complex soil behavior more precisely.
  • Focus on Specific Tunnel: The study focused on a particular tunnel segment. Further research could explore the seismic response of longer tunnel sections and varying geological conditions.
  • Experimental Validation: The findings are based on numerical simulations. Experimental validation through physical model testing would strengthen the conclusions.
  • Long-Term Performance: While foam concrete's resistance to groundwater corrosion is noted, long-term performance under sustained corrosive conditions could be a subject for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The construction of subway tunnels in the coastal section is affected by special soil quality, with complex construction conditions of unstable soil and vulnerability to groundwater corrosion. The design difficulty of subway tunnels is greatly increased, and the safety performance in the event of an earthquake is greatly reduced. To study the changes in shield tunnel lining structure under earthquake and propose damping measures, ANSYS software is used to conduct tunnel soil numerical simulation. Firstly, static analysis and modal analysis are carried out, and it is found that the maximum displacement deformation occurs at 3.8 cm of the arch crown, and the maximum stress occurs at 2.6 × 107 Pa of the left and right wall corners, 8 easily deformed points are obtained at the same time. Input EI_Centro EW forward 19 s seismic wave is used to analyze the displacement, acceleration and stress vibration characteristics of tunnel lining. The upper part of the lining is more vulnerable to earthquake, and the right arch waist is subject to the maximum stress, reaching 1.37 × 10−4 Pa, the maximum displacement deformation point is 3.65 × 10−10 m at the right wall. To reduce the impact of earthquakes on tunnel lining, the damping scheme of adding an isolation layer is adopted. Using foam concrete isolation material can reduce the stress of the arch waist by 74.6%, and rubber isolation material can reduce the stress by 80%. In consideration of groundwater corrosion and subsequent engineering construction, it is recommended to use foam concrete as the material for the isolation layer. This study can provide a theoretical basis for the design of metro tunnels in offshore areas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2023study,
  author = {Sihui Dong and Xinyu Zhang and Chenxu Jia and Shiqun Li and Kang Wang},
  title = {{Study on Seismic Response and Vibration Reduction of Shield Tunnel Lining in Coastal Areas}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15054185},
}
Figure