Study on Psychological Capital and School Adaptation of Urban Left-behind Children in China

Biyun Zhang, Xinyu Li, Haipeng Zhang, Jianjun Huang, Wenjuan XiongJournal of Education and Educational Research 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the psychological well-being and school performance of "urban left-behind children" in China—a group often overlooked in favor of their rural counterparts. The researchers found that while these children perform better than rural left-behind children, they still lag behind their urban peers who live with their parents; crucially, "psychological capital" (hope, optimism, and resilience) accounts for nearly half of the variance in how well they adapt to school.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In China, the term "left-behind children" typically evokes images of rural kids living with grandparents while parents work in distant cities. However, as urban-rural integration accelerates, a new demographic has emerged: urban left-behind children (ULBC). These are children living in cities whose parents work elsewhere for long periods or who have been sent to urban centers for better schooling, leaving them without direct parental care.

While rural left-behind children have been studied extensively, ULBC remain a "hidden" group. The authors address a critical gap: how does the absence of parental companionship affect the mental health and school adaptation of children in an urban environment? Specifically, they look at Psychological Capital (PsyCap)—a positive developmental state consisting of hope, optimism, resilience, and self-confidence—and its role in helping these children navigate the academic and social demands of school.

Methods

The researchers conducted a large-scale survey involving 4,474 valid participants from grades four to nine across ten primary and secondary schools in Hubei Province, China. They utilized two primary standardized instruments:

  1. The Adolescent Psychological Capital Questionnaire: A 22-item scale measuring four dimensions: hope, optimism, self-confidence, and psychological resilience.
  2. The School Adaptation Questionnaire: A 27-item scale assessing five dimensions: academic adaptation, attitude towards school, peer relationships, teacher-student relationships, and routine adjustment.

The study employed descriptive statistics to establish a baseline, independent sample t-tests to compare ULBC against other groups (rural and non-left-behind), and regression analysis to determine if PsyCap could predict school adaptation success.

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset collected by the authors via school-based surveys. The sample breakdown is as follows:

  • Urban Left-behind Children (ULBC): 1,004 (22.5%)
  • Urban Non-left-behind Children (UNLBC): 1,848 (41.3%)
  • Rural Left-behind Children (RLBC): 735 (16.4%)
  • Rural Non-left-behind Children (RNLBC): 887 (19.8%)

No external benchmarks or pre-existing datasets were used; the study provides a snapshot of the Hubei Province student population in 2023.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Middle Ground" Status: ULBC occupy a unique middle tier. They show significantly higher psychological capital and school adaptation than rural left-behind children, likely due to better urban infrastructure, more diverse social circles (larger class sizes), and richer extracurricular activities. However, they still score significantly lower than urban children who live with their parents.
  • PsyCap as a Powerful Predictor: The most striking finding is that psychological capital explains 49% of the variation in school adaptation. This suggests that a child’s internal "psychological resource bank" is nearly as important as their external environment in determining school success.
  • The Parental Guidance Gap: The data suggests that while urban grandparents or guardians can provide for physical needs (food, clothing, transport), they often struggle to provide the "soft" support—academic guidance, emotional regulation, and rule-setting—that parents typically offer. This lack of guidance directly undermines the child's PsyCap.
  • Resilience through Trial: Interestingly, the overall PsyCap of ULBC was still rated as "good" (above the median). The authors hypothesize that being forced to face difficulties early in life without parents may actually foster a degree of forced resilience.

Key Results

  • Quantitative Comparison: ULBC mean PsyCap was 4.41, which is higher than RLBC (3.94) but lower than UNLBC (4.57).
  • School Adaptation: Similarly, ULBC scored 4.12 on school adaptation, outperforming RLBC (3.73) but trailing UNLBC (4.23).
  • Regression Significance: Three specific dimensions of PsyCap—hope, optimism, and self-confidence—were found to be significant positive predictors of school adaptation ($p < 0.01$).
  • Dimension Breakdown: Within PsyCap, "optimism" scored the highest for ULBC (4.78), while "self-confidence" was the lowest (4.10), suggesting that while these children remain hopeful, they may doubt their own specific abilities due to a lack of parental reinforcement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for improvement:

  • Intervention Strategies: While the study identifies PsyCap as a predictor, it does not test specific interventions. Future work should explore how schools can actively "train" PsyCap in ULBC.
  • Mental Health Counseling: The paper emphasizes a lack of dedicated mental health resources for this specific urban subgroup and calls for more targeted counseling services.
  • Scope: The study is limited to Hubei Province. Given China's vast regional differences, a broader national study would be required to generalize these findings.
  • Causality: As a cross-sectional survey, the study shows correlation rather than definitive longitudinal causality. Future research could track these children over several years to see how PsyCap evolves as they enter high school and adulthood.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective: This study explores the current status and relationship between psychological capital and school adaptation of urban left-behind children. Methods: The Adolescent Psychological Capital Questionnaire and the School Adaptation Questionnaire were used to investigate students in 10 primary and secondary schools in Hubei Province, China. Results: Urban left-behind children’s psychological capital and the average score of each dimension, school adaptation and the average score of each dimension were significantly higher than the median value. The psychological capital and school adaptation level of urban left-behind children are significantly lower than those of urban non-left-behind children, and at the same time significantly higher than those of rural left-behind children. There is a significant positive correlation between psychological capital and school adaptation of urban left-behind children. The psychological capital of urban left-behind children has a predictive effect on school adaptation and can explain 49% of the variation in school adaptation. Conclusion: The overall level of psychological capital and school adaptation of urban left-behind children is good. The school adaptation of urban left-behind children can be improved by raising the level of their psychological capital.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2023study,
  author = {Biyun Zhang and Xinyu Li and Haipeng Zhang and Jianjun Huang and Wenjuan Xiong},
  title = {{Study on Psychological Capital and School Adaptation of Urban Left-behind Children in China}},
  journal = {Journal of Education and Educational Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.54097/jeer.v5i2.12548},
}
Figure