Study on Nitrogen Loss Rules of Paddy Fields under Different Irrigation and Drainage Modes in Southern China

Shurong Hao, Xuan Wang, Ting Ding, Wenyu ZhuWater 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how different irrigation and drainage methods in southern Chinese paddy fields affect nitrogen loss and rice yield. They found that "water catching and controlled irrigation" (WC-CI) significantly reduced nitrogen runoff and leaching while boosting yields, making it a promising sustainable practice for the region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agricultural nonpoint source pollution, particularly from nitrogen runoff in rice cultivation, is a growing environmental concern. Southern China, a major rice-producing region, faces challenges with uneven rainfall distribution, leading to both water scarcity and heavy rainfall events. Traditional flooding irrigation methods can exacerbate nitrogen loss, impacting water quality and reducing fertilizer efficiency. The paper aims to identify irrigation and drainage strategies that can mitigate nitrogen loss while maintaining or improving rice yields in this specific agro-climatic context.

Methods

The researchers conducted barrel experiments using three distinct irrigation and drainage treatments:

  • Frequent and Shallow Irrigation (FSI): This served as the control, representing a common irrigation practice.
  • Drought Planting with Straw Mulching (DPS): This method involved reduced watering and covering the soil surface with decomposed straw.
  • Water Catching and Controlled Irrigation (WC-CI): This approach focused on maximizing rainwater storage and controlling water levels.

They meticulously monitored nitrogen concentrations (NH4+-N, NO3−-N, and total nitrogen - TN) in both surface drainage and deep percolation water. Nitrogen loss loads were calculated for runoff and leaching. Additionally, rice yield was measured for each treatment. Statistical analysis (ANOVA) was used to determine significant differences between treatments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized experimental data collected from barrel experiments conducted at Hohai University in Nanjing, China, from June to October 2020.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NH4+-N Dominates Nitrogen Loss: Across all treatments, ammonium nitrogen (NH4+-N) was consistently the primary form of nitrogen lost through both surface runoff and deep percolation. This highlights the importance of managing this specific nitrogen species.
  • Tillering Stage is Critical for Runoff Loss: The tillering stage of rice growth, coinciding with heavy rainfall and fertilizer application, emerged as a critical period for nitrogen loss via surface runoff. This suggests that timing of fertilizer application and water management during this phase are crucial.
  • Straw Mulching's Double-Edged Sword: While DPS significantly reduced deep percolation and leaching losses, it paradoxically increased surface drainage and N runoff losses. This is attributed to its lower water storage capacity, leading to quicker surface runoff during heavy rains.
  • WC-CI: The Sweet Spot: The WC-CI method demonstrated a remarkable ability to reduce both surface drainage and deep percolation, leading to substantial decreases in total nitrogen loss. Crucially, it achieved this while also significantly increasing rice yield.
  • Drought Stress Impacts Yield: The DPS method, despite reducing water loss, led to yield decreases due to water stress, underscoring the delicate balance between water conservation and crop performance.

Key Results

  • Surface Drainage: WC-CI significantly reduced surface drainage by 59.21% compared to FSI, while DPS increased it by 98.67%.
  • Deep Percolation: DPS reduced deep percolation by 68.59%, and WC-CI reduced it by 37.99% compared to FSI.
  • Nitrogen Runoff Loss: WC-CI reduced N runoff loss by 66.38% compared to FSI, whereas DPS increased it by 125.86%.
  • Nitrogen Leaching Loss: DPS reduced N leaching loss by 74.69%, and WC-CI reduced it by 43.23% compared to FSI.
  • Total Nitrogen Loss: DPS and WC-CI reduced total TN loss by 52.58% and 45.82%, respectively, compared to FSI. DPS showed a slightly better reduction effect in total N loss.
  • Rice Yield: WC-CI significantly increased rice yield by 7.31% compared to FSI, while DPS decreased yield by 0.95%.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that it did not consider nitrogen losses due to ammonia volatilization, which can be a significant pathway. Future work could explore the combined effects of different irrigation and drainage modes with varying nitrogen application rates to further optimize practices. The authors also suggest investigating the interplay between water and nitrogen management for enhanced nitrogen-use efficiency and yield, particularly in the context of co-limitation. The paper also implicitly points to the need for region-specific recommendations, noting that DPS might be more suitable for low-rainfall areas, while WC-CI is ideal for high-rainfall regions like southern China.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the growing problem of agricultural nonpoint source pollution, it is an urgent issue to explore irrigation and drainage modes suitable for rice-growing areas in southern China. Barrel experiments were conducted to study the variation of NH4+-N, NO3−-N and TN concentrations in surface drainage and deep percolation water, as well as the rules of nitrogen runoff losses and leaching losses. Treatments included frequent and shallow irrigation (FSI), drought planting with straw mulching (DPS) and water catching and controlled irrigation (WC-CI). The results showed that the trends of NH4+-N, NO3−-N and TN concentrations in surface drainage were similar, and the N concentration gradually decreased with increasing drainage frequency. The trends of NH4+-N, NO3−-N and TN concentrations in deep percolation water were similar, rising to a peak within 5~7 days after fertilization and then gradually decreasing. NH4+-N loss load was the main form of N loss load in surface drainage and deep percolation water, which accounted for 42.06~89.16%. Compared with FSI, DPS significantly increased surface drainage and N runoff loss loads by 98.67% and 125.86%, respectively, while WC-CI significantly reduced them by 59.21% and 66.38%, respectively. Deep percolation water was reduced by 68.59% and 37.99% for DPS and WC-CI, respectively, and N leaching loss loads were reduced by 74.69% and 43.23%, respectively. Compared with FSI, the total TN loss load was significantly reduced by 76.69% and 43.34% for DPS and WC-CI, respectively, and the pollution control was better for DPS. WC-CI significantly increased rice yield by 7.31%, while DPS decreased by 0.95 % due to long-term water stress. Comprehensively considered, WC-CI has obvious advantages, which can reduce nitrogen loss and maintaining a high yield.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hao2022study,
  author = {Shurong Hao and Xuan Wang and Ting Ding and Wenyu Zhu},
  title = {{Study on Nitrogen Loss Rules of Paddy Fields under Different Irrigation and Drainage Modes in Southern China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/w14193071},
}
Figure