Study on Frost-Suppression Characteristics of Superhydrophobic Aluminum Surface Heat Exchanger Applied in Air Source Heat Pump

Yaxiu Gu, Guixiang He, Shuaipeng Li, Weiqi Ding, Hanlin Li, Jiahui DuanSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a superhydrophobic aluminum surface created via chemical etching, demonstrating significantly reduced frost formation and faster defrosting times for air source heat pump (ASHP) heat exchangers. By understanding the unique condensation and freezing behaviors on these surfaces, the research provides a foundation for improving ASHP efficiency in cold climates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Air source heat pumps (ASHPs) are a popular, energy-efficient heating solution. However, their outdoor heat exchangers are prone to frosting in cold, humid conditions. This frost layer impedes heat transfer, reducing the unit's efficiency and potentially causing it to shut down. Existing defrosting methods often require extra equipment or complex controls. This paper tackles the challenge of preventing and mitigating frost buildup on ASHP heat exchangers by exploring the application of superhydrophobic surfaces.

Methods

The researchers prepared superhydrophobic aluminum (Al) surfaces using a chemical etching process followed by a fluorosilane modification. This involved cleaning the Al specimens, removing the oxide layer, etching with a mixture of acids, and then applying the fluorosilane and curing. The resulting surface's hydrophobicity was confirmed by measuring the contact angle (CA), which reached 158.3°.

To understand the frost-suppression mechanisms, they conducted visual experiments and theoretical analyses. This included:

  • Condensation Experiments: Observing droplet behavior on both bare Al and superhydrophobic Al surfaces under controlled temperature and humidity.
  • Antifreezing Experiments: Measuring the time it took for droplets to start and finish freezing on both surface types at various sub-zero temperatures.
  • Thermal Conductivity Analysis: Investigating the thermal resistance of the superhydrophobic surface using a Cassie-Baxter model to explain the delayed freezing.
  • Heat Exchanger Fin Simulation: Preparing Al bases that mimicked the fin distribution of actual heat exchangers to test frost suppression and melting effects on a larger scale.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from controlled laboratory setups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Coalescence-Bounce" Effect: Superhydrophobic surfaces exhibit a unique behavior where condensed water droplets merge and then "bounce" off the surface. This prevents them from spreading and forming a continuous frost layer, significantly delaying the onset of frosting.
  • Nucleation Energy Barrier: The micro-nano structure of superhydrophobic surfaces creates a high energy barrier for water vapor to condense and form ice nuclei. This means condensation and subsequent freezing occur much later compared to a bare surface.
  • Delayed Freezing = Delayed Frosting: The primary mechanism for frost suppression is delaying the initial freezing of condensed water droplets. The superhydrophobic surface dramatically extends this freezing time.
  • Enhanced Thermal Resistance: The trapped air within the micro-nano structure of the superhydrophobic surface acts as an insulator, increasing the thermal resistance and further slowing down heat transfer and thus freezing.
  • Faster Defrosting: Not only does the superhydrophobic surface reduce frost buildup, but it also facilitates faster melting of any accumulated frost, leading to quicker recovery of heat exchanger performance.

Key Results

  • Superhydrophobic Surface Preparation: A superhydrophobic Al surface with a contact angle of 158.3° was successfully prepared via chemical etching and modification.
  • Reduced Frosting Amount: The frosting amount on the superhydrophobic Al-based surface was 69.79% of that on the bare Al-based surface after 50 minutes of frosting.
  • Delayed Freezing: The average freezing time of droplets on the superhydrophobic Al surface was 5.19 times longer than on the bare Al surface across various cold temperatures.
  • Faster Defrosting Time: The time required to melt the frost layer on the superhydrophobic Al-based surface was 64% of that on the bare Al-based surface.
  • Improved Droplet Retention: The superhydrophobic surface showed significantly less retention of liquid water after defrosting compared to the bare surface.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Long-Term Stability: While the paper mentions preparing a stable superhydrophobic surface, the long-term durability and performance under repeated icing/deicing cycles in real-world conditions are not extensively detailed.
  • Scale-Up: The study simulates heat exchanger fins, but scaling up the superhydrophobic treatment to full-sized heat exchanger units for commercial ASHPs is the next logical step.
  • Mechanism Depth: While the paper explores condensation and freezing mechanisms, further in-depth analysis of the interplay between surface structure, air entrapment, and frost crystal morphology could be beneficial.
  • Environmental Factors: The study was conducted under controlled laboratory conditions. Investigating performance under a wider range of environmental conditions (e.g., varying air flow rates, different types of contaminants) would be valuable.

The authors suggest that their work provides a theoretical and experimental basis for the practical application of superhydrophobic technology in ASHP heat exchangers. Future work will focus on the antifrosting effect of superhydrophobic heat exchangers on a larger scale.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to solve the frosting problem of air source heat pump (ASHP) outdoor heat exchange under low-temperature and low-humidity conditions, a superhydrophobic aluminum (Al) surface with a contact angle (CA) of 158.3° was prepared by chemical etching. The microscopic characteristics of droplet condensation and the freezing process of a superhydrophobic surface were revealed through visual experiments and theoretical analysis. On this basis, the frost-suppression effect of a superhydrophobic Al-based surface simulating the distribution of actual heat exchanger fins was preliminarily explored. The results demonstrated that, due to the large nucleation energy barrier and the coalescence-bounce behavior of droplets, the condensed droplets on the superhydrophobic surface appeared late and their quantity was low. The thermal conductivity of the droplets on a superhydrophobic surface was large, so their freezing rate was low. The frosting amount on the superhydrophobic Al-based surface was 69.79% of that of the bare Al-based surface. In turn, the time required for melting the frost layer on the superhydrophobic Al-based surface was 64% of that on the bare Al-based surface. The results of this study lay an experimental and theoretical foundation for the application of superhydrophobic technology on the scale of heat exchangers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gu2022study,
  author = {Yaxiu Gu and Guixiang He and Shuaipeng Li and Weiqi Ding and Hanlin Li and Jiahui Duan},
  title = {{Study on Frost-Suppression Characteristics of Superhydrophobic Aluminum Surface Heat Exchanger Applied in Air Source Heat Pump}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14041954},
}
Figure