Study on Electromagnetic Radiation Interference Caused by Rocket Fuel

Yuanbo Cui, Jian Jiang, Deren Kong, Shang Gao, Shuai Wang2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the electromagnetic radiation (EMR) generated by rocket fuel combustion, a phenomenon that can disrupt spacecraft electronics during launch and recovery. The authors developed a novel measurement system and analysis framework to characterize this EMR, creating a model to assess its interference potential and inform the design of more robust spacecraft systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Spacecraft operations, particularly during critical phases like launch and landing, are vulnerable to electromagnetic interference (EMI). A significant source of this interference is the intense electromagnetic radiation emitted by the combustion of rocket propellants. This radiation can disrupt sensitive electronic equipment, leading to mission failures or safety hazards. While previous research has touched upon EMR from explosions, a comprehensive understanding and a standardized method for evaluating the impact of rocket fuel EMR on spacecraft electronics were lacking. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a detailed study of rocket fuel EMR characteristics and developing a framework for assessing its interference threat.

Methods

The authors designed and implemented a specialized electromagnetic radiation measurement system. This system utilizes a combination of ultrawideband and shortwave omnidirectional antennas to capture EMR across a broad frequency spectrum (up to 3 GHz). A high-speed acquisition card ensures precise time-domain measurements with an accuracy of 10⁻⁹ seconds and a recording duration of up to 1000 ms.

The data processing method involves analyzing the EMR in four key domains:

  • Spatial Characteristics: Distribution of EMR in space, represented by the power density spectrum.
  • Time-Domain Characteristics: The temporal evolution of the EMR signal, including pulse intensity and duration.
  • Frequency-Domain Characteristics: The spectral distribution of the EMR, identifying dominant frequencies and bandwidths.
  • Energy-Domain Characteristics: The overall energy content and flow of the EMR.

Based on these analyses, the paper proposes a mathematical model to quantify the electromagnetic environment around a spacecraft. This model uses indicators like space coverage (SO), time occupancy (TO), and frequency occupancy (FO) to characterize the EMR. Furthermore, it defines spatial threat degree (ST), time-domain threat degree (TT), and frequency-domain threat (FT) to assess the interference potential on electronic equipment.

Datasets

The paper describes experimental cases involving six different combinations of rocket fuels, all commonly used for aviation launch missions. These fuels were tested under controlled conditions to measure their electromagnetic radiation. The specific fuel combinations and their mixture ratios and masses are detailed in Table 2. No pre-existing datasets were used; the data was generated through the experiments described.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rocket fuel combustion is a significant source of EMI: The study confirms that the intense EMR generated by rocket fuel deflagration poses a real threat to spacecraft electronics, as evidenced by temporary interruptions in live broadcasts during rocket landings.
  • Multi-domain characterization is crucial: Understanding EMR requires analyzing its spatial, temporal, frequency, and energy characteristics. Each domain provides unique insights into the nature and impact of the radiation.
  • A comprehensive threat assessment framework is developed: The paper introduces a novel framework that combines measurement, data processing, and modeling to quantify the complexity and threat level of rocket fuel EMR. This framework allows for a more objective evaluation of interference risks.
  • Different fuel compositions yield distinct EMR signatures: The experimental results show that variations in fuel composition lead to significant differences in the timing, duration, and frequency spectrum of the emitted EMR. This suggests that fuel selection can influence the EMI profile.
  • Classification standards for EMR threat are established: The study proposes classification standards for both the complexity of EMR and the threat level it poses to electronic equipment, providing a useful tool for engineers.

Key Results

The experimental results demonstrated that:

  • The electromagnetic radiation signals produced by different rocket fuels varied significantly. For instance, Lox-Hydrogen produced the earliest radiation but with the shortest duration (0.04 s), while Lox-Propane had the longest duration (0.6 s).
  • The frequency range of the electromagnetic radiation varied from 60 MHz to 1550 MHz. Lox-Propane exhibited the widest electromagnetic spectrum (450 MHz), while Lox-Hydrogen had the narrowest (35 MHz).
  • Lox-Propane and Lox-Kerosene were found to produce high-frequency electromagnetic interference exceeding 1000 MHz.
  • The study successfully classified the interference level of rocket fuel EMR into different threat levels (I-V) and complexity indices (A-E) based on experimental data, validating the proposed classification standards.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while their theoretical research suggests that high-energy fuel deflagration causes rapid temperature rises and creates unbalanced plasma regions, further detailed investigation into the precise mechanisms of electric and magnetic field generation within these regions is warranted. The paper also establishes a complete set of "measurement-acquisition-analysis-modelling" projects, but the practical implementation and validation of anti-electromagnetic interference designs for spacecraft electronics based on this model are areas for future work. The study provides a foundation for improving the safety of aviation missions by offering a method to evaluate and mitigate the threat of rocket fuel EMR.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{cui2021study,
  author = {Yuanbo Cui and Jian Jiang and Deren Kong and Shang Gao and Shuai Wang},
  title = {{Study on Electromagnetic Radiation Interference Caused by Rocket Fuel}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21238123},
}
Figure