Abstract Exploring the internal connection between rail transit and land use is of great significance for the coordinated development of urban space and rail transit construction. This study identifies rail transit stations with high population density in Xi’an and establishes an indicator system for urban land use and rail transit operation capabilities based on multivariate data. Using Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), the research explores the coordinated relationship between these two systems. The study finds that the relationship between rail transit capacity and land use at high-density stations is often unbalanced. To promote sustainable development, it is suggested that planners confine land-use intensity around stations, improve local service functions for small-scale living areas, and optimize the environment for short-distance travel while encouraging rail for long-distance commutes.
Introduction
As Chinese cities undergo rapid "station-city integration," a common disconnect has emerged: many multi-billion dollar rail stations fail to reach their designed passenger flow, while the areas surrounding them are developed without regard for the transit they are supposed to feed. This paper seeks to provide a quantitative framework to measure the "coordination" or "coupling degree" between rail capacity and land use to help planners move beyond simple density and toward functional efficiency.
Methodology
The researchers employed a multi-stage analytical approach to evaluate 20 high-density stations across Xi’an Lines 1, 2, and 3.
- Station Selection: SPSS clustering was used to filter 63 stations down to 20 "high population density" samples.
- Indicator System: Two sets of indicators were established: Land Intensive Use (L) (11 indicators including floor area ratio and POI diversity) and Rail Transit Capacity (T) (4 indicators including daily passenger volume and train frequency).
- Efficiency Modeling: Using the $C^2R$ Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) model, the authors calculated the efficiency of the "input-output" relationship between land and rail.
- Coupling Degree: A final coupling score ($\theta_{LT}$) categorized stations into levels ranging from "extreme imbalance" to "quality coordination."
Data Sources and Multivariate Analysis
The study stands out for its use of "big data" sourced from cloud platforms to capture real-world urban dynamics more accurately than traditional census data.
- Mobile Phone Signaling: Data from China Unicom was used to calculate precise population density (living and employment) within an 800m radius of stations.
- POI Data: 0.64 million Points of Interest were scraped from the Gaode Map API to determine land-use functions and diversity.
- Shared Mobility: Bicycle density was pulled from the Mobike API to measure "last-mile" accessibility.
- Operational Data: Official statistics from the Xi’an Rail Transit Group provided passenger flows and train schedules.
Key Insights
- Diversity Over Density: The most influential factor for coordination was the diversity of land use (Information Entropy). A mix of residential, commercial, and public services creates a more stable, all-day demand for transit.
- The "Unbalanced" Reality: The study found that the efficiency of rail transit's impact on land use is generally higher than the reverse. In other words, the infrastructure is ready, but the city layout isn't always "feeding" the stations effectively.
- The Residential Trap: High residential density often showed a negative correlation with system coordination if not balanced by local services. "Bedroom communities" near stations hinder transit efficiency by creating massive peak-hour surges followed by "dead" periods.
Results and Policy Recommendations
Most stations fell into the "low-mid" or "mid-high" coupling categories. Stations like Zhang Ba Bei Lu (0.990) and Long Shou Yuan (0.941) showed near-perfect coupling, while others like Yu Xiang Men (0.481) showed significant imbalance.
To promote the sustainable development of rail transit capacity and surrounding land, the authors suggest:
- Confining development intensity around stations to prevent over-densification.
- Improving service functions of small-scale living areas to encourage short-distance walking/cycling.
- Optimizing the travel environment to reserve rail transit for long-distance travel while effectively evacuating peak passenger flows at stations.
While this study provides a valuable snapshot based on 2017 data, future work will involve longitudinal analysis to track how these coupling degrees change as the rail network matures over time.
Summary updated