Study on a novel power emergency plan based on the virtual reality technology

Xiangning He, He He Pan, Xianqi Li, Guiyun Huang, Dehe Wang, Xin HuangAdvances 2015 · DOI

Abstract

This paper investigates the current state of power emergency drills both domestically and internationally, comparing practical and virtual drills in terms of scale, investment, and overall effectiveness. Building on this analysis, the authors propose a novel power emergency response framework based on virtual reality (VR) technology, designed to bridge the gap between technical simulation and social coordination.

Introduction

Maintaining a stable power grid is increasingly difficult due to rising energy demands and the threat of natural disasters. To prepare for large-scale blackouts, utilities traditionally rely on two methods: practical drills and virtual drills. Practical drills are massive, multi-agency exercises that test social coordination but are prohibitively expensive and rare. Conversely, virtual drills use simulation software to train technicians cost-effectively but often lack the "authenticity" of a real-world disaster, failing to simulate cross-departmental friction and social chaos.

This research identifies a critical gap: the lack of a standardized way to merge the technical depth of virtual simulations with the organizational breadth of physical drills. The proposed solution is a hybrid emergency response framework that combines large-scale physical coordination with high-fidelity VR simulations.

System Architecture

The core of the proposed system is a sophisticated software architecture that integrates professional power management systems into a unified VR environment. This integration is achieved through the IEC60870-5-104 protocol, which links real-time data from Integrated Automation, Dispatcher Training Simulators (DTS), and SCADA/EMS systems.

Software architecture for the VR-based emergency simulation system.

As shown in Figure 1, the system utilizes a "Bus Allocator" to manage data flow between the primary/secondary system models and the visualization modules. The visualization component includes a "3D virtual field" that renders control panels, protection screens, and on-the-spot equipment, allowing trainees to interact with a digital twin of the substation environment.

The Hybrid Emergency Framework

The proposed emergency plan is structured around a multi-layered response model that categorizes activities by their nature (Social vs. Grid) and their execution environment (Actual vs. Virtual).

The multi-layered power accident disposal and evaluation model.

As illustrated in Figure 2, the framework divides the response into four distinct layers:

  1. Infrastructure Layer: Addresses immediate social impacts (road traffic, medical emergencies) alongside physical grid damage and security.
  2. Power Operation Layer: Focuses on grid scheduling and "Power Marketing" to manage load and prioritize critical users like hospitals and banks.
  3. Power Recovery Layer: Simulates "Black Start" procedures—restarting the grid from scratch—using a mix of actual equipment reuse and virtual simulations for large factory-owned motors and captive power plants.
  4. Evaluation Layer: A final stage to assess the performance of both organizational units and individual participants.

Key Insights and Advantages

  • The Authenticity-Cost Balance: The ideal drill uses VR to handle high-cost simulation activities (like equipment failure and complex switching) while physical coordination handles "social linkage" (communication between government, police, and utilities).
  • Error-Tolerance: Unlike physical drills where a mistake might halt the entire exercise, the VR component allows for "jumping" between links. Trainees can retry specific segments, significantly increasing the pedagogical value.
  • Black Start Complexity: Restarting a grid after a total blackout requires intense coordination with external entities. VR is uniquely suited to simulate these rare, high-risk interactions without risking physical hardware.

Conclusion

The paper presents a qualitative framework for a unified architecture connecting real-world power management software to 3D visualization tools. While the authors acknowledge that the network complexity and software integration required for multi-departmental data sharing are significant hurdles, they conclude that this hybrid approach leads to higher emergency response efficiency. Future work will focus on implementing these platforms across different regional power grids to validate the model's scalability.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper investigated power emergency drills situation in domestic and foreign, compared practical and virtual drills from the aspects of the scale and investment of the drill and the effect of drill. Then proposed the concept of power emergency response drills on the basis of virtual reality technology, and designed a novel power emergency plan based on virtual reality technology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2015study,
  author = {Xiangning He and He He Pan and Xianqi Li and Guiyun Huang and Dehe Wang and Xin Huang},
  title = {{Study on a novel power emergency plan based on the virtual reality technology}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2991/icmeis-15.2015.31},
}
Figure