Study on a Concentric Tube Bulb Manometer and its Performance Compared to U-shaped Manometer

Syed Sheraz Daood, Aamir Ijaz, Muhammad Atif ButtSensors 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces and evaluates a novel "Concentric Tube Bulb" (C.T.B) manometer, designed to overcome the instability and spillage issues common in conventional U-shaped manometers. Experimental results demonstrate that the C.T.B manometer offers comparable or improved accuracy and stability, particularly in dynamic flow conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Measuring low pressure differences is crucial in many engineering applications, and manometers have been the go-to instruments for decades due to their simplicity and accuracy. However, conventional U-shaped manometers have inherent drawbacks. A significant issue is the potential for the manometer fluid (like mercury) to be ejected from the tube during sudden pressure surges or high flow rates, leading to spillage and hazardous conditions. Additionally, pressure fluctuations can cause erroneous readings. This paper addresses the need for a more stable and robust manometer design that retains the accuracy of traditional U-shaped manometers while mitigating these practical problems.

Methods

The study compares a newly designed Concentric Tube Bulb (C.T.B) manometer with a conventional U-shaped manometer. The C.T.B manometer features a unique design with two concentric glass tubes and spherical bulbs, intended to dampen pressure fluctuations.

The experimental methodology involved:

  • Flow Measurement: Water was used as the flowing fluid to measure mass flow rates and pressure drops. Two standard flow measuring devices, an orifice plate and a venturimeter, were employed.
  • Pressure Measurement: Both the C.T.B and U-shaped manometers were used to measure the differential pressure across these flow devices.
  • Sensing Fluids: Mercury (Hg) and carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) were used as the sensing fluids in the manometers.
  • Gauge Pressure Measurement: Air was used as the flowing medium to measure gauge pressure.
  • Comparison: Experimental measurements were compared against values calculated using theoretical equations. A calibrated bourdon tube gauge was used as a reference for gauge pressure measurements.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments generated their own data based on controlled setups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stability Enhancement: The C.T.B manometer's design, with its concentric tubes and spherical bulbs, appears to effectively dampen pressure fluctuations during flow rate changes. This leads to more stable error peaks compared to the U-shaped manometer.
  • Reduced Spillage Risk: The design inherently reduces the likelihood of manometer fluid being ejected, addressing a key safety and operational concern with traditional manometers.
  • Sensing Fluid Influence: The choice of sensing fluid significantly impacts manometer performance. CCl4, with its lower density and surface tension compared to Hg, exhibits more sinusoidal error behavior, suggesting greater susceptibility to instability during flow rate changes.
  • Linearity Advantage: The C.T.B manometer consistently showed a closer linear agreement between reference and calculated mass flow rates across various conditions, indicating potentially higher accuracy and predictability.

Key Results

  • Mass Flow Rate Accuracy: For orifice meter measurements using Hg, the C.T.B manometer showed a closer linear relationship between reference and calculated mass flow rates, with fitted line angles of 49° compared to 53° for the U-shaped manometer.
  • Error Analysis:
    • With Hg as the sensing fluid, the U-shaped manometer exhibited a "step rise function" in error, while the C.T.B manometer showed more stable error peaks.
  • Using CCl4, both manometers showed sinusoidal error behavior, but the C.T.B manometer still had a lower overall average error (0.2% vs. 0.6% for U-shaped).
  • Venturimeter Performance: Similar trends were observed when using a venturimeter, with the C.T.B manometer generally showing better linearity and stability in error profiles.
  • Gauge Pressure: The C.T.B manometer's gauge pressure readings were found to be more concordant with reference readings from a calibrated bourdon tube gauge.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Capillary Effects: The paper acknowledges that capillary effects in the C.T.B manometer are not fully studied and are a subject for future experimentation.
  • Pressure Transients: Further investigation into pressure transients during mass flow rate changeovers is planned.
  • Characteristic Time and Process Gain: The authors intend to calculate characteristic time and process gain values for the C.T.B manometer.
  • Sensing Fluid Limitations: The study highlights that CCl4's properties lead to more instability, suggesting that further research might focus on optimizing its use or exploring other fluids.

The paper concludes that the C.T.B manometer is a promising alternative to conventional U-shaped manometers, offering improved stability and comparable accuracy, making it suitable for applications involving dynamic flow conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents comparative study of a new type of manometer calledconcentric tube bulb (C.T.B) manometer. Its performance of measuring differential heightis studied against conventional U-shaped manometer. Pressure drops and mass flow ratesare calculated by taking various systems comprising of different flow measuring devicessuch as orifice and venturimeters using both U- shaped and C.T.B manometers.Comparison between the physically measured values of differential pressure drops andmass flow rates with the calculated values based on theoretical equations is also made.Experiments are carried out using mercury and CCl4 in these manometers as sensing fluids.Water is used as flowing fluid for mass flow rate and pressure drop measurements, whereasin gauge pressure measurements air is used.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{daood2007study,
  author = {Syed Sheraz Daood and Aamir Ijaz and Muhammad Atif Butt},
  title = {{Study on a Concentric Tube Bulb Manometer and its Performance Compared to U-shaped Manometer}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.3390/s7112835},
}

Loading related content...

Figure