Study of the wave packet treatment of neutrino oscillation at Daya Bay

Fengpeng An, A. B. Balantekin, H. R. Band, M. Bishai, S. Blyth, D. Cao, G. F. Cao, Jun Cao, W. R. Cen, Y. L. Chan, J. F. Chang, Ling-Hua Chang, Y. Chang, H.s. Chen, Qian Chen, S.m. Chen, Y.x. Chen, J.-h. Cheng, Jie Cheng, Yaping Cheng, Zhaokan Cheng, J. J. Cherwinka, M. C. Chu, A. Chukanov, J. P. Cummings, J. de Arcos, Z. Y. Deng, Xuefeng Ding, Yayun Ding, M. Diwan, M. Dolgareva, J. Dove, D. A. Dwyer, W. R. Edwards, R. Gill, M. Gonchar, G. Gong, Haipeng Gong, M. Grassi, W. Gu, Mengyun Guan, L. Guo, X. H. Guo, Zhou Guo, R. Hackenburg, Ran Han, S. Hans, M. He, K. M. Heeger, Y. K. Heng, A. Higuera, Y. K. Hor, Y. Hsiung, Beibei Hu, J. F. Hu, W. Hu, E.-c. Huang, Hui Huang, Xia Huang, Patrick Huber, W. J. Huo, Ghulam Hussain, D. E. Jaffe, P. Jaffke, K. L. Jen, S. Jetter, Xingzhao Ji, J. B. Jiao, R. A. Johnson, J. Joshi, Li-Wei Kang, S. H. Kettell, S. Kohn, M. Krämer, K. K. Kwan, M. W. Kwok, T. Kwok, Thomas Langford, K. Lau, L. Lebanowski, J. Lee, R. T. Lei, R. Leitner, J.k.c. Leung, C. Li, D.j. Li, F. Li, G.s. Li, Q.j. Li, S. Li, W.d. Li, Xiaonan Li, Yufeng Li, Z.b. Li, H. Liang, Cheng-Ju LinarXiv 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The disappearance of reactor $\bar{\nu}_e$ observed by the Daya Bay experiment is examined in the framework of a model in which the neutrino is described by a wave packet with a relative intrinsic momentum dispersion $\sigma_{\text{rel}}$. Three pairs of nuclear reactors and eight antineutrino detectors, each with good energy resolution, distributed among three experimental halls, supply a high-statistics sample of $\bar{\nu}_e$ acquired at nine different baselines. This provides a unique platform to test the effects which arise from the wave packet treatment of neutrino oscillation. The modified survival probability formula was used to fit Daya Bay data, providing the first experimental limits: $2.38 \cdot 10^{-17} < \sigma_{\text{rel}} < 0.23$. Treating the dimensions of the reactor cores and detectors as constraints, the limits are improved: $10^{-14} \lesssim \sigma_{\text{rel}} < 0.23$, and an upper limit of $\sigma_{\text{rel}} < 0.20$ is obtained. All limits correspond to a 95% C.L. Furthermore, the effect due to the wave packet nature of neutrino oscillation is found to be insignificant for reactor antineutrinos detected by the Daya Bay experiment, thus ensuring an unbiased measurement of the oscillation parameters $\sin^22\theta_{13}$ and $\Delta m^2_{32}$ within the plane wave model.

Introduction

In the standard model of neutrino physics, neutrino oscillation—the phenomenon where neutrinos change flavor as they propagate—is typically described using the "plane wave" approximation. While this simplification is mathematically convenient, it is fundamentally inconsistent with the localized nature of particle production and detection. A more rigorous physical description treats the neutrino as a wave packet with a finite spatial extent and a corresponding momentum dispersion, denoted as $\sigma_{\text{rel}}$.

This paper presents the first experimental test of this wave packet treatment using the high-statistics dataset from the Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment. By moving beyond the plane wave approximation, researchers can investigate phenomena such as decoherence and dispersion, which could potentially dampen the observed oscillation amplitude over long distances.

The Wave Packet Framework and Decoherence

The wave packet model introduces a relative momentum dispersion, $\sigma_{\text{rel}} = \sigma_p / p$, where $\sigma_p$ is the longitudinal momentum uncertainty. This dispersion leads to two primary physical effects:

  1. Decoherence: Because different neutrino mass eigenstates travel at slightly different velocities, the wave packets associated with each mass state eventually separate in space. Once the separation exceeds the size of the wave packets, they can no longer interfere, and the oscillation pattern is suppressed.
  2. Localization: The production and detection processes occur within finite volumes (e.g., the reactor core and the detector). If the neutrino wave packet is too large (very small $\sigma_{\text{rel}}$), these localization effects dominate the survival probability.

By modifying the standard survival probability formula to include these terms, the researchers can determine if the experimental data shows any signs of these wave packet effects.

Experimental Configuration

The Daya Bay experiment, located in China, provides an ideal environment for this study due to its unique geometry and high statistics:

  • Statistics: The analysis utilized 621 days of data, encompassing over 1.2 million antineutrino candidates.
  • Geometry: The setup includes six nuclear reactors and eight antineutrino detectors (ADs) spread across three experimental halls (EH1, EH2, and EH3).
  • Baselines: This configuration results in nine different baselines ranging from approximately 350 meters to 2 kilometers.

The variety of baselines is critical; decoherence is a distance-dependent effect. By comparing the oscillation patterns at different distances, the experiment can distinguish between a genuine loss of coherence and uncertainties in the initial neutrino flux.

Methodology

The authors performed a multi-parameter fit to the Daya Bay data, treating $\sigma_{\text{rel}}$ as a free parameter alongside the standard oscillation parameters $\sin^2 2\theta_{13}$ and $\Delta m^2_{32}$. To ensure the statistical validity of the results, particularly when dealing with parameters near physical boundaries, the Feldman-Cousins method was employed to construct confidence intervals.

To further refine the model, the researchers incorporated physical constraints based on the known dimensions of the reactor cores and the detectors. These constraints help bound the possible values of $\sigma_{\text{rel}}$ by defining the minimum and maximum possible localization of the neutrino at production and detection.

Key Results and Implications

The study successfully established the first experimental limits on the relative momentum dispersion of neutrinos:

  • Unconstrained Limits: $2.38 \cdot 10^{-17} < \sigma_{\text{rel}} < 0.23$ (95% C.L.).
  • Constrained Limits: By treating reactor and detector dimensions as constraints, the lower limit improved significantly to $10^{-14} \lesssim \sigma_{\text{rel}} < 0.23$.
  • Upper Bound: A robust upper limit of $\sigma_{\text{rel}} < 0.20$ was obtained.

Importantly, the analysis found that the best-fit values for the mixing angle $\theta_{13}$ and the mass splitting $\Delta m^2_{32}$ did not change significantly when the wave packet model was used instead of the plane wave model. This indicates that for the distances and energies involved in the Daya Bay experiment, the wave packet effects are negligible.

Conclusion

This research provides a vital validation of the standard plane wave approximation used in neutrino physics. While the wave packet nature of neutrinos is a theoretical necessity, these results demonstrate that it does not introduce significant bias into current measurements of oscillation parameters. The established limits on $\sigma_{\text{rel}}$ represent a milestone in our understanding of the fundamental nature of the neutrino and set the stage for future long-baseline experiments, such as JUNO, which may be even more sensitive to the subtle effects of decoherence.

Summary updated

Abstract

The disappearance of reactor $\barν_e$ observed by the Daya Bay experiment is examined in the framework of a model in which the neutrino is described by a wave packet with a relative intrinsic momentum dispersion $σ_\text{rel}$. Three pairs of nuclear reactors and eight antineutrino detectors, each with good energy resolution, distributed among three experimental halls, supply a high-statistics sample of $\barν_e$ acquired at nine different baselines. This provides a unique platform to test the effects which arise from the wave packet treatment of neutrino oscillation. The modified survival probability formula was used to fit Daya Bay data, providing the first experimental limits: $2.38 \cdot 10^{-17} &lt; σ_{\rm rel} &lt; 0.23$. Treating the dimensions of the reactor cores and detectors as constraints, the limits are improved: $10^{-14} \lesssim σ_{\rm rel} &lt; 0.23$, and an upper limit of $σ_{\rm rel} &lt;0.20$ is obtained. All limits correspond to a 95\% C.L. Furthermore, the effect due to the wave packet nature of neutrino oscillation is found to be insignificant for reactor antineutrinos detected by the Daya Bay experiment thus ensuring an unbiased measurement of the oscillation parameters $\sin^22θ_{13}$ and $Δm^2_{32}$ within the plane wave model.
BibTeX
@misc{an2016study,
  author = {Fengpeng An and A. B. Balantekin and H. R. Band and M. Bishai and S. Blyth and D. Cao and G. F. Cao and Jun Cao and W. R. Cen and Y. L. Chan and J. F. Chang and Ling-Hua Chang and Y. Chang and H.S. Chen and Qian Chen and S.M. Chen and Y.X. Chen and Y. Chen and J.-H. Cheng and Jie Cheng and Yaping Cheng and Zhaokan Cheng and J. J. Cherwinka and M. C. Chu and A. Chukanov and J. P. Cummings and J. de Arcos and Z. Y. Deng and Xuefeng Ding and Yayun Ding and M. Diwan and M. Dolgareva and J. Dove and D. A. Dwyer and W. R. Edwards and R. Gill and M. Gonchar and G. Gong and Haipeng Gong and M. Grassi and W. Gu and Mengyun Guan and L. Guo and X. H. Guo and Zhou Guo and R. Hackenburg and Ran Han and S. Hans and M. He and K. M. Heeger and Y. K. Heng and A. Higuera and Y. K. Hor and Y. Hsiung and Beibei Hu and J. F. Hu and W. Hu and E.-C. Huang and Hui Huang and Xia Huang and Patrick Huber and W. J. Huo and Ghulam Hussain and D. E. Jaffe and P. Jaffke and K. L. Jen and S. Jetter and Xingzhao Ji and X. L. Ji and J. B. Jiao and R. A. Johnson and J. Joshi and Li-Wei Kang and S. H. Kettell and S. Kohn and M. Krämer and K. K. Kwan and M. W. Kwok and T. Kwok and Thomas Langford and K. Lau and L. Lebanowski and J. Lee and J.H.C. Lee and R. T. Lei and R. Leitner and J.K.C. Leung and C. Li and D.J. Li and F. Li and G.S. Li and Q.J. Li and S. Li and S. Li and W.D. Li and Xiaonan Li and Yufeng Li and Z.B. Li and H. Liang and Cheng-Ju Lin},
  title = {{Study of the wave packet treatment of neutrino oscillation at Daya Bay}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1608.01661},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.01661},
}
Figure