Study of the IC 443 region with the HAWC observatory

R. Alfaro, C. Alvarez, Miguel Araya, J. C. Arteaga‐Velázquez, D. Avila Rojas, H. A. Ayala Solares, Rishi Babu, Argelia Bernal, K. S. Caballero‐Mora, T. Capistrán, A. Carramiñana, S. Casanova, U. Cotti, J. Cotzomi, S. Coutinõ de León, E. De la Fuente, Davide Depaoli, P. Desiati, Niccolò Di Lalla, R. Díaz Hernández, B. L. Dingus, M. A. DuVernois, J. C. Díaz–Vélez, T. Ergin, C. Espinoza, Ke Fang, N. Fraija, S. Fraija, J. A. García-González, Hüseyin Göksu, J. A. González-Cervera, Magdalena González, J. A. Goodman, S. Groetsch, J. P. Harding, S. Hernández-Cadena, I. Herzog, J. A. Hinton, D. Huang, F. Hueyotl‐Zahuantitla, P. Hüntemeyer, S. Kaufmann, A. Lara, Jeonghoon Lee, H. León Vargas, J. Linnemann, A. L. Longinotti, G. Luis-Raya, K. Malone, O Martinez, J. Martínez-Castro, J. Matthews, P. Miranda-Romagnoli, J. A. Montes, J.a Morales-Soto, E. Moreno, M. Mostafá, M. Najafi, L. Nellen, M. U. Nisa, R. Noriega-Papaqui, Laura Olivera-Nieto, N Omodei, M. Osorio, E. Ponce, Y. Pérez Araujo, E. G. Pérez‐Pérez, Chang Dong Rho, D. Rosa‐González, M. Roth, E. Ruiz-Velasco, H. Salazar, A. Sandoval, Martin Schneider, Georg Schwefer, J. Serna-Franco, A. J. Smith, Y. Son, R. W. Springer, O. Tibolla, K. Tollefson, I. Torres, R Torres-Escobedo, Rhiannon M. Turner, X. Wang, Z. Wang, I. J. Watson, H. Wu, Shiqi Yu, S. Yun-Cárcamo, H. Zhou, C. de LeónarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

This study, conducted by the HAWC (High Altitude Water Cherenkov) Collaboration, provides a deep look into one of the most famous "Jellyfish" in the sky: the IC 443 supernova remnant. By analyzing nearly eight years of data, the researchers investigate whether this remnant is a "PeVatron"—a cosmic accelerator capable of pushing particles to peta-electronvolt (PeV) energies—and stumble upon a mysterious new neighbor in the process.

TL;DR

HAWC observations of the IC 443 supernova remnant reveal gamma-ray emission extending to ~30 TeV without a spectral cutoff, supporting its potential as a "PeVatron" candidate. The study also discovers a new, nearby extended source, HAWC J0615+2213, which likely represents a "TeV halo" surrounding a middle-aged pulsar.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A century-old mystery in astrophysics is the origin of the highest-energy cosmic rays (protons and nuclei) that bombard Earth. We know they reach energies of at least $10^{15}$ eV (the "knee" of the cosmic ray spectrum), but identifying the specific "PeVatrons" that accelerate them is difficult.

Supernova remnants (SNRs)—the explosive remains of dead stars—are the prime suspects. IC 443 is a particularly interesting candidate because it is currently plowing into dense molecular clouds, which act as a "target" for accelerated protons. When these protons collide with gas, they produce neutral pions that decay into the high-energy gamma rays HAWC detects. The challenge is determining if the energy spectrum of these gamma rays keeps rising or if it "cuts off," which would reveal the maximum speed limit of the accelerator.

Methods

The team used 2,966 days of data from the HAWC observatory, located at 4,100 meters in Mexico. HAWC doesn't "see" light directly; it detects the "air showers" of secondary particles produced when a gamma ray hits Earth's atmosphere.

  • Maximum Likelihood Modeling: The researchers used the threeML framework to fit spatial and spectral models to the data.
  • Morphology Search: They tested whether the emission was best described as a point source or an extended disk/Gaussian.
  • Hadronic Modeling: Using the Naima software package, they performed Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulations to work backward from the observed gamma rays to the original "parent" proton population.
  • Multi-wavelength Comparison: They compared HAWC’s ultra-high-energy data with lower-energy data from the Fermi-LAT satellite and the VERITAS and MAGIC atmospheric Cherenkov telescopes.

Datasets

  • Primary: HAWC gamma-ray data (2015–2023).
  • Ancillary:
    • Fermi-LAT: GeV-scale gamma-ray data.
  • LHAASO: High-energy data from the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory for cross-validation.
  • HI4PI Survey: Maps of atomic hydrogen used to check if gamma-ray emission correlates with gas density.
  • Green Catalog: A standard reference for supernova remnants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Missing Cutoff: Most previous models of IC 443 suggested a spectral cutoff at lower energies. HAWC found no evidence of a cutoff up to ~30 TeV. This suggests that IC 443 is a more efficient accelerator than previously thought and remains a strong PeVatron candidate.
  • Hadronic Dominance: Because IC 443 is surrounded by dense gas, the researchers argue the emission is almost certainly "hadronic" (proton-driven) rather than "leptonic" (electron-driven). Electrons lose energy too quickly in this environment to produce the observed 30 TeV signal.
  • Discovery of HAWC J0615+2213: The team found a second, distinct source of extended emission nearby. It doesn't line up with known gas clouds, ruling out simple cosmic ray interaction with the interstellar medium.
  • The TeV Halo Hypothesis: The new source is centered near pulsar B0611+22. The authors propose this is a "TeV halo"—a region where high-energy electrons escaping a pulsar are trapped by turbulent magnetic fields, creating a glowing "aura" of gamma rays.

Key Results

  • IC 443 Spectrum: Measured as a simple power law with an index of $-3.14 \pm 0.18$. The emission is detected significantly up to 30 TeV.
  • New Source (HAWC J0615+2213): This extended source has a harder (flatter) spectrum with an index of $-2.49 \pm 0.08$ and is detected up to 47 TeV.
  • Proton Energy: The modeling suggests that IC 443 is accelerating protons to at least 65 TeV, and potentially up to 1 PeV, depending on the magnetic field assumptions.
  • G189.6+03.3: A nearby overlapping supernova remnant was found to have no significant emission above 1 TeV, allowing the team to set strict upper limits on its activity.

Limitations and Future Work

The main limitation is angular resolution. While HAWC is great at seeing the "big picture" and very high energies, it struggles to distinguish between the SNR shell and the pulsar wind nebula (PWN) located very close to it.

The authors also note that while IC 443 looks like a PeVatron, they haven't seen the "smoking gun" yet—emission at 100 TeV or higher. They suggest that future observations from LHAASO or the upcoming SWGO (Southern Wide-field Gamma-ray Observatory) will be needed to definitively confirm if the Jellyfish Nebula is truly a PeV-scale accelerator. A more detailed analysis of the newly discovered TeV halo is also promised in a forthcoming paper.

Summary updated

Abstract

Supernova remnants are one potential source class considered a PeVatron (i.e. capable of accelerating cosmic rays above PeV energies). The shock fronts produced after the explosion of the supernova are ideal regions for particle acceleration. IC 443 is a supernova remnant that has been studied extensively at different wavelengths. Using 2966 days of gamma-ray data from the HAWC observatory, we study the emission of IC 443 with the objective of finding signatures of cosmic-ray acceleration at the PeV scale. Using a maximum likelihood method, we find a point source located at ($α$=94.42$^{\circ}$, $δ$=22.35$^{\circ}$) that we associate with IC 443. The measured spectrum is a simple power law with an index of $-3.14\pm$0.18, which is consistent with previous TeV observations. Although we cannot confirm that IC 443 is a hadronic PeVatron, we do not find any sign that the spectrum has a cut off at tens of TeV energies, with the spectrum extending to $\sim$30 TeV. Furthermore, we also find a new extended component in the region whose emission is described by a simple power law with an index of $-2.49\pm$0.08 and which we call HAWC J0615+2213. While we show evidence that this new source might be a new TeV halo, we defer a detailed analysis of this new source to another publication.
BibTeX
@misc{alfaro2025study,
  author = {R. Alfaro and C. Alvarez and Miguel Araya and J. C. Arteaga‐Velázquez and D. Avila Rojas and H. A. Ayala Solares and Rishi Babu and Argelia Bernal and K. S. Caballero‐Mora and T. Capistrán and A. Carramiñana and S. Casanova and U. Cotti and J. Cotzomi and S. Coutinõ de León and E. De la Fuente and Davide Depaoli and P. Desiati and Niccolò Di Lalla and R. Díaz Hernández and B. L. Dingus and M. A. DuVernois and J. C. Díaz–Vélez and T. Ergin and C. Espinoza and Ke Fang and N. Fraija and S. Fraija and J. A. García-González and Hüseyin Göksu and J. A. González-Cervera and Magdalena González and J. A. Goodman and S. Groetsch and J. P. Harding and S. Hernández-Cadena and I. Herzog and J. A. Hinton and D. Huang and F. Hueyotl‐Zahuantitla and P. Hüntemeyer and S. Kaufmann and A. Lara and Jeonghoon Lee and H. León Vargas and J. Linnemann and A. L. Longinotti and G. Luis-Raya and K. Malone and O Martinez and J. Martínez-Castro and J. Matthews and P. Miranda-Romagnoli and J. A. Montes and J.A Morales-Soto and E. Moreno and M. Mostafá and M. Najafi and L. Nellen and M. U. Nisa and R. Noriega-Papaqui and Laura Olivera-Nieto and N Omodei and M. Osorio and E. Ponce and Y. Pérez Araujo and E. G. Pérez‐Pérez and Chang Dong Rho and D. Rosa‐González and M. Roth and E. Ruiz-Velasco and H. Salazar and A. Sandoval and Martin Schneider and Georg Schwefer and J. Serna-Franco and A. J. Smith and Y. Son and R. W. Springer and O. Tibolla and K. Tollefson and I. Torres and R Torres-Escobedo and Rhiannon M. Turner and X. Wang and Z. Wang and I. J. Watson and H. Wu and Shiqi Yu and S. Yun-Cárcamo and H. Zhou and C. de León},
  title = {{Study of the IC 443 region with the HAWC observatory}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2501.12613},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.12613},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure