Study of the effects of radiation on the CMS Drift Tubes Muon Detector for the HL-LHC
G. Abbiendi, J. Alcaraz Maestre, A. Álvarez Fernández, B. Álvarez González, N. Amapane, I. Bachiller, J.m. Barcala, L. Barcellan, C. Battilana, M. Bellato, Gyorgy Bencze, M. Benettoni, N. Beni, A. C. Benvenuti, L.c. Blanco Ramos, A. Boletti, A. Bragagnolo, J. A. Brochero Cifuentes, V. D. Cafaro, A. Calderón, E. Calvo, A. Cappati, R. Carlin, C. A. Carrillo Montoya, F. R. Cavallo, J. M. Cela Ruiz, M. Cepeda, M. Cerrada, B. Chazin Quero, P. Checchia, L. Ciano, N. Colino, Daniele Corti, G. Cotto, J. Cuevas, M. Cuffiani, G. M. Dallavalle, D. Dattola, B. De La Cruz, P. De Remigis, C. Erice Cid, F. Fabbri, A. Fanfani, D. Fasanella, C. Fernandez Bedoya, J. F. de Trocóniz, P. Fernandez Manteca, J. Fernández Menéndez, J. P. Fernández Ramos, S. Folgueras, M. C. Fouz, D. Francia Ferrero, Josefa García Romero, F. Gasparini, U. Gasparini, S. Ghosh, V. Giordano, F. Gomez Casademunt, F. Gonella, I. González Caballero, J. R. González Fernández, O. González López, S. Goy López, A. Gozzelino, Alberto Griggio, G. Grosso, C. Guandalini, L. Guiducci, M. Gulmini, T. Hebbeker, C. Heidemann, J. M. Hernández, K. Höepfner, F. Iemmi, R. Isocrate, M. I. Josa, B. Kiani, S. Lacaprara, S. Lo Meo, S. Marcellini, M. Margoni, J. Marín, C. Mariotti, I. M. Martin, J.j. Martínez Morales, C. Martínez Rivero, S. Maselli, G. Masetti, A. T. Meneguzzo, M. Merschmeyer, G. Mocellin, L. Modenese, A. Molinero, J. Molnár, F. Montecassiano, D. Moran, J. Navarrete, F. L. Navarria, Á. Navarro Tobar, J. C. OllerJournal of Instrumentation2019 · DOI · arXiv
Abstract
The CMS drift tubes (DT) muon detector, designed for the LHC, will face significantly higher radiation levels during the High Luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) phase. Initial tests at the CERN gamma irradiation facility (GIF++) revealed ageing effects that degrade cell performance. To better understand these effects, a second spare DT chamber was irradiated at lower acceleration factors, using a subset of layers as a reference telescope. This study reports on the impact of an integrated dose equivalent to twice the HL-LHC's expected luminosity. While efficiency losses were observed, strategies such as dynamic voltage management and improved shielding are being developed to ensure robust muon reconstruction throughout the HL-LHC era.
Introduction
The High-Luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) upgrade, scheduled for the mid-2020s, aims to increase the rate of particle collisions by a factor of 5 to 7. For the CMS experiment, this translates to a total integrated luminosity ten times higher than the original design specifications. The Drift Tube (DT) chambers, responsible for muon identification and momentum measurement in the barrel region, will be subjected to a massive increase in radiation background.
High radiation environments induce "ageing" in gaseous detectors through polymerization processes. Ionizing radiation triggers chemical reactions that create insulating, resistive deposits on the thin anode wires. These deposits shield the electric field, reducing gas gain and hit efficiency. This paper investigates whether the current DT system can maintain operational integrity over a decade of HL-LHC operation.
Experimental Methodology
To simulate the long-term effects of radiation in a compressed timeframe, researchers utilized the CERN Gamma Irradiation Facility (GIF++). The facility employs a powerful $^{137}$Cs source to provide a photon flux approximately 10 times higher than the projected HL-LHC background.
The "Telescope" Setup
A key innovation in this study was the use of a spare DT chamber configured as a reference telescope. Only two of the chamber's twelve layers were powered at the full working voltage (3550 V) during irradiation. The remaining layers were kept at a lower "idle" voltage (1900 V), preventing ageing in those cells. This allowed the non-aged layers to serve as a precise, unbiased reference for tracking muons, enabling an accurate measurement of hit efficiency degradation in the aged layers.
Schematic of a CMS drift tube cell showing the anode wire where resistive deposits can form during irradiation.
The team monitored "Normalized Current" (current per unit of radiation dose) and "Hit Efficiency" (the probability of detecting a muon track). Following irradiation, aged anode wires were extracted and subjected to microscopic inspection to characterize the chemical nature of the deposits.
Key Results and Discussion
The Polymerization Plateau
Data collected between 2017 and 2019 revealed a non-linear ageing process. As shown in the normalized current plots, there is a sharp initial drop in performance followed by a plateau. This suggests that the polymerization on the wires may reach a saturation point rather than causing a linear decline to total failure.
Normalized current as a function of expected integrated luminosity, showing the sharp initial drop and subsequent plateau for aged layers (SL1L1, SL1L4) compared to the stable non-aged layer (SL1L3).
For an integrated dose equivalent to twice the HL-LHC run (approximately 6000 fb⁻¹), a moderate hit efficiency loss of about 10% was observed using cosmic muons. However, when background radiation mimicking HL-LHC instantaneous rates was applied, the efficiency degradation reached approximately 20%.
Spatial analysis indicates that vulnerability is not uniform; the "MB1" chambers closest to the collision point will face the highest doses, while outer "MB4" chambers will remain largely unaffected. Microscopic forensics confirmed that the primary cause of gain loss is the deposition of melted resistive silicon and hydrocarbon materials on the anode wires.
Mitigation and Future Outlook
Despite the observed ageing, full CMS simulations suggest that the impact on global muon reconstruction efficiency will be minimal across most of the barrel acceptance. To further ensure system longevity, several mitigation strategies are proposed:
Shielding: Installation of 7mm lead and 30-90cm borated polyethylene to block scattered radiation.
Dynamic High Voltage: Gradually increasing the wire voltage as ageing progresses to recover lost gas gain.
Gas Chemistry: Ongoing research into gas additives that might inhibit polymerization or provide a "cleaning" effect during operation.
Conclusion
The CMS DT muon system demonstrates significant resilience. While the most exposed chambers may see hit efficiency drops, the majority of the 250 chambers are expected to maintain efficiencies above 90% throughout the HL-LHC lifetime. Continued investigation into material outgassing and gas components will be critical to refining these long-term performance projections.
Summary updated
Abstract
The CMS drift tubes (DT) muon detector, built for withstanding the LHC expected integrated and instantaneous luminosities, will be used also in the High Luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) at a 5 times larger instantaneous luminosity and, consequently, much higher levels of radiation, reaching about 10 times the LHC integrated luminosity. Initial irradiation tests of a spare DT chamber at the CERN gamma irradiation facility (GIF++), at large (∼ O(100)) acceleration factor, showed ageing effects resulting in a degradation of the DT cell performance. However, full CMS simulations have shown almost no impact in the muon reconstruction efficiency over the full barrel acceptance and for the full integrated luminosity. A second spare DT chamber was moved inside the GIF++ bunker in October 2017. The chamber was being irradiated at lower acceleration factors, and only 2 out of the 12 layers of the chamber were switched at working voltage when the radioactive source was active, being the other layers in standby. In this way the other non-aged layers are used as reference and as a precise and unbiased telescope of muon tracks for the efficiency computation of the aged layers of the chamber, when set at working voltage for measurements. An integrated dose equivalent to two times the expected integrated luminosity of the HL-LHC run has been absorbed by this second spare DT chamber and the final impact on the muon reconstruction efficiency is under study. Direct inspection of some extracted aged anode wires presented a melted resistive deposition of materials. Investigation on the outgassing of cell materials and of the gas components used at the GIF++ are underway. Strategies to mitigate the ageing effects are also being developed. From the long irradiation measurements of the second spare DT chamber, the effects of radiation in the performance of the DTs expected during the HL-LHC run will be presented.
BibTeX
@article{abbiendi2019study,
author = {G. Abbiendi and J. Alcaraz Maestre and A. Álvarez Fernández and B. Álvarez González and N. Amapane and I. Bachiller and J.M. Barcala and L. Barcellan and C. Battilana and M. Bellato and Gyorgy Bencze and M. Benettoni and N. Beni and A. C. Benvenuti and L.C. Blanco Ramos and A. Boletti and A. Bragagnolo and J. A. Brochero Cifuentes and V. D. Cafaro and A. Calderón and E. Calvo and A. Cappati and R. Carlin and C. A. Carrillo Montoya and F. R. Cavallo and J. M. Cela Ruiz and M. Cepeda and M. Cerrada and B. Chazin Quero and P. Checchia and L. Ciano and N. Colino and Daniele Corti and G. Cotto and J. Cuevas and M. Cuffiani and G. M. Dallavalle and D. Dattola and B. De La Cruz and P. De Remigis and C. Erice Cid and F. Fabbri and A. Fanfani and D. Fasanella and C. Fernandez Bedoya and J. F. de Trocóniz and P. Fernandez Manteca and J. Fernández Menéndez and J. P. Fernández Ramos and S. Folgueras and M. C. Fouz and D. Francia Ferrero and Josefa García Romero and F. Gasparini and U. Gasparini and S. Ghosh and V. Giordano and F. Gomez Casademunt and F. Gonella and I. González Caballero and J. R. González Fernández and O. González López and S. Goy López and A. Gozzelino and Alberto Griggio and G. Grosso and C. Guandalini and L. Guiducci and M. Gulmini and T. Hebbeker and C. Heidemann and J. M. Hernández and K. Höepfner and F. Iemmi and R. Isocrate and M. I. Josa and B. Kiani and S. Lacaprara and S. Lo Meo and S. Marcellini and M. Margoni and J. Marín and C. Mariotti and I. M. Martin and J.J. Martínez Morales and C. Martínez Rivero and S. Maselli and G. Masetti and A. T. Meneguzzo and M. Merschmeyer and G. Mocellin and L. Modenese and A. Molinero and J. Molnár and F. Montecassiano and D. Moran and J. Navarrete and F. L. Navarria and Á. Navarro Tobar and J. C. Oller},
title = {{Study of the effects of radiation on the CMS Drift Tubes Muon Detector for the HL-LHC}},
journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
year = {2019},
doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/14/12/c12010},
}