Study of the Effect of the Driving Force on the Kinetics of CO2 Hydrate Growth in Coal Particles

Chuanhai Liu, Ran Chen, Baoyong Zhang, Qiang Wu, Qiang Zhang, Qiong WuFrontiers in Energy Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates "hydration curing"—a technique that turns dangerous $CO_2$ gas in coal mines into solid hydrates—to prevent violent gas outbursts. By testing various coal particle sizes and "driving forces" (excess pressure), the researchers mapped out exactly how pressure and coal texture interact to speed up or slow down hydrate formation, providing a mathematical roadmap for safer mining operations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In coal mining, "gas outbursts" are terrifying events where gas and coal erupt violently from a seam, often leading to fatalities and massive economic loss. While methane ($CH_4$) is the usual suspect, many coal seams globally are dominated by carbon dioxide ($CO_2$). $CO_2$ outbursts are rarer but significantly more violent and harder to control.

A promising safety solution is hydration curing. By injecting water into the coal seam under specific pressure and temperature conditions, the $CO_2$ gas reacts with water to form solid clathrate hydrates. This effectively "locks" the gas in a solid state, reducing the gas pressure and the risk of an outburst. However, we haven't fully understood the kinetics—how fast and efficiently these hydrates grow—within the complex, porous structure of coal. This paper seeks to fill that gap by analyzing how pressure and coal particle size dictate the success of this curing process.

Methods

The researchers used a custom-built experimental rig featuring a high-pressure visual reactor, a thermostatic control system, and a data acquisition module. They focused on two primary variables:

  1. Driving Force ($\Delta P$): Defined as the pressure applied above the phase equilibrium pressure. They tested three levels: 2, 2.5, and 3 MPa.
  2. Coal Particle Size: They sieved coal into four categories, ranging from relatively coarse (C1: 0.425–0.850 mm) to very fine (C4: 0–0.180 mm).

The team measured gas consumption over time, calculated growth rates using the "forward difference method," and determined the heat of decomposition using the Clausius-Clapeyron equation. This allowed them to see not just how much hydrate formed, but how stable it was.

Datasets

As an experimental laboratory study, the "dataset" consists of the primary measurements taken across 12 distinct experimental groups (combinations of the 4 particle sizes and 3 driving forces). The results are synthesized into:

  • Pressure-Temperature-time (P-T-t) curves showing the transition from gas dissolution to nucleation and growth.
  • Gas consumption tables (Table 1) and average growth rate tables (Table 2).
  • Heat of decomposition data (Table 4) used to assess hydrate stability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Diffusion Tug-of-War: The study reveals a fascinating conflict. Smaller coal particles provide more surface area (promoting hydrate growth), but they also create a more "packed" environment that obstructs gas diffusion (inhibiting growth).
  • The "Critical Value" of Pressure: There is a tipping point where increasing the driving force overcomes the physical resistance of the coal. In very fine coal (C4), a high driving force (3 MPa) actually caused a massive jump in gas consumption, suggesting that high pressure can "force" the reaction even in cramped pores.
  • Stability vs. Size: Interestingly, the largest coal particles (C1) produced the most stable hydrates. These hydrates had the highest heat of decomposition, meaning they require more energy to break back down into gas—a vital characteristic for long-term mining safety.
  • Predictive Modeling: The authors successfully used linear fitting to create equations that predict the average growth rate based on the driving force for each coal type. This turns experimental observations into a practical tool for engineers.

Key Results

  • Gas Consumption: In the C1 system, gas consumption increased from 59.3 to 68.3 mmol/mol as the driving force rose from 2 to 3 MPa.
  • Growth Rates: Increasing the driving force consistently boosted the growth rate. For the finest particles (C4), the growth rate at 3 MPa was nearly double that at 2 MPa.
  • Stability: The heat of decomposition for $CO_2$ hydrates in the C1 medium was approximately 47.87 kJ/mol, the highest among all tested groups, indicating the most stable "cured" state.
  • Nucleation: Unlike growth, the time it took for hydrates to start forming (nucleation) didn't follow a simple linear trend with pressure, suggesting that the initial "spark" of hydrate formation is influenced by complex interfacial tensions within the coal.

Limitations and Future Work

The study was conducted using pure water and sieved coal particles in a controlled reactor. In a real-world coal mine, the environment is much messier: the water contains impurities, the coal is a solid mass rather than loose particles, and there are pre-existing tectonic stresses.

The authors suggest that future research should move toward "field applications." This would involve testing how these kinetics hold up in large-scale coal blocks and investigating how the presence of other gases (like methane) might change the $CO_2$ hydrate formation process. Additionally, exploring chemical additives that could further lower the required "driving force" could make the technology more energy-efficient.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coal and gas outbursts are geological disasters occurring in the process of coal mining that can cause serious casualties and economic losses, among which CH 4 is the main component of coal mine gas. However, there are still many coal seams around the world that are dominated by CO 2 . Although the frequency of CO 2 gas outburst accidents is relatively low, CO 2 outbursts are very violent, notably difficult to control and highly dangerous. The application of hydration curing technology to reduce the pressure and gradient of CO2 gas in the coal can effectively reduce the occurrence of coal and CO 2 outburst. Accordingly, in this paper, experimental studies on the growth kinetics of CO 2 hydrate with three driving forces (2, 2.5, 3 MPa) were carried out under four different coal particle sizes (C1: 0.425–0.850 mm, C2: 0.250–0.425 mm, C3: 0.180–0.250 mm, C4: 0–0.180 mm) to obtain kinetic parameters such as gas consumption, growth rate, and heat of decomposition during the synthesis of CO 2 hydrate. The results show that the hydrate nucleation time in the same particle size system does not follow the same decreasing trend with increasing driving force. Gas consumption of CO 2 hydrates in the same particle size system increased with increasing driving force, and there exists a critical value regarding the effect of the driving force on CO 2 hydrate generation in coal particles with the particle size. Under the same temperature conditions, increasing the driving force in the particle size system could increase the CO 2 hydrate growth rate. With decreasing coal particle size and increasing driving force, the promoting effect gradually exceed the inhibiting effect, which promote CO 2 hydrate formation. Through linear fitting, an equation of the average growth rate of CO 2 hydrates versus the driving force for the C1-C4 systems is fitted to provide a reference to predict the average CO 2 hydrate growth rate. In the same medium, with increasing driving force, more heat is required for complete decomposition, which remains relatively stable, and the heat of decomposition of CO 2 hydrates is the highest in the C1 medium, indicating that the presence of CO 2 hydrates in the C1 system represents the most stable state.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2022study,
  author = {Chuanhai Liu and Ran Chen and Baoyong Zhang and Qiang Wu and Qiang Zhang and Qiong Wu},
  title = {{Study of the Effect of the Driving Force on the Kinetics of CO2 Hydrate Growth in Coal Particles}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.926342},
}
Figure