Study of the Challenges and Ways of Improvement of International Health Regulations -based on regulations related to cooperation between Contracting States

Zhimei Du, Meng Wang, Lijuan Wu, Yu RenJournal of Innovation and Development 2023 · DOI

Abstract: The International Health Regulations (IHR) (2005) gives health guidance to prevent global outbreaks of infectious diseases and help contracting parties to become open and cooperate. The lack of horizontal information shared among States parties, the need for pre-epidemic prevention, and the wide variation of State parties' action capacity are the problems that IHR (2005) has to face in COVID-19. The revision of the IHR is necessary. Improving the information-sharing mechanism between States Parties, strengthening the capacity of States Parties to prevent public health incidents, improving the implementation of State parties' response in public health events and refining the health construction regulations of States Parties, and urging States Parties to improve the level of medical and health emergency response are important four aspects which should be implemented now.

Introduction

The COVID-19 pandemic served as a rigorous stress test for the International Health Regulations (IHR) (2005), a legally binding framework for 196 countries designed to prevent and respond to acute public health risks. While the IHR was intended to foster global health cooperation, the pandemic exposed structural flaws—specifically in how information is shared and how sovereign states balance national interests against global health recommendations. This paper provides a critical post-mortem of the IHR (2005), identifying bottlenecks and proposing a roadmap for regulatory reform.

The Vertical Reporting Bottleneck

A primary challenge identified is the "vertical" nature of the current information-sharing mechanism. Under the existing framework, states report to the World Health Organization (WHO), which then analyzes and redistributes data. This structure creates a significant time lag, allowing pathogens to spread geometrically before a global alarm is officially sounded.

Timeline of WHO response and key global milestones during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic.

As shown in the timeline above, the period from the initial notification on January 3, 2020, to the official pandemic designation on March 11, 2020, highlights the delays inherent in the current system. To address this, a shift toward horizontal information sharing between neighboring states is proposed, allowing for immediate regional adjustments and faster localized responses.

Compliance and the Paradox of Capacity

The pandemic also revealed a lack of "compliance gravity." Under Article 43, states can implement "additional health measures" (such as travel bans), provided they are based on science. However, in practice, many states prioritized national politics over WHO guidelines. Furthermore, a massive "short board effect" exists where the weak infrastructure of a single nation can compromise global security.

Interestingly, the research highlights a paradox of capacity. While the United States had significantly higher healthcare investment as a percentage of GDP (17.1%) compared to China (5.2%), its adherence to IHR warnings and enforcement capacity was lower, leading to an explosive increase in cases.

Key epidemiological milestones comparing the initial notice in Wuhan with the first confirmed case in the United States.

This comparative milestone data suggests that financial investment does not automatically equate to regulatory compliance or effective pre-epidemic prevention. The IHR currently focuses on "controllers" (reacting to outbreaks) but largely ignores the "pre-epidemic prevention link," which must be mandated in future revisions.

Strategic Recommendations for IHR Revision

To strengthen the global health architecture, the authors propose four major countermeasure suggestions for the next revision of the IHR:

  1. Add Horizontal Channels: Supplement the WHO-centric reporting with regional information-sharing networks to bypass vertical delays.
  2. 24-Hour Notification Mandate: Tighten the window for states to notify the WHO after monitoring a potential public health incident.
  3. Standardized Reserve Systems: Amend the IHR to require states to maintain specific levels of medical supplies (masks, protective clothing) to prevent the panic and shortages seen in early 2020.
  4. Enhanced WHO Management Authority: Grant the WHO more authority to "remind and supervise" implementation, moving the organization away from a purely advisory role toward a more active regulatory body.

Conclusion

The global health security system is only as strong as its most vulnerable link. Future work must focus on training medical personnel in underdeveloped countries and establishing a legal roadmap that balances sovereign autonomy with the collective need for global health compliance. The revision of the IHR (2005) is not merely a legal necessity but a global imperative to ensure the world is better prepared for the next inevitable outbreak.

Summary updated

Abstract

The International Health Regulations (IHR) (2005) gives health guidance to prevent global outbreaks of infectious diseases and help contracting parties to become open and cooperate. The lack of horizontal information shared among States parties, the need for pre-epidemic prevention, and the wide variation of State parties' action capacity are the problems that IHR (2005) has to face in COVID-19. The revision of the IHR is necessary. Improving the information-sharing mechanism between States Parties, strengthening the capacity of States Parties to prevent public health incidents, improving the implementation of State parties' response in public health events and refining the health construction regulations of States Parties, and urging States Parties to improve the level of medical and health emergency response are important four aspects which should be implemented now.
BibTeX
@article{du2023study,
  author = {Zhimei Du and Meng Wang and Lijuan Wu and Yu Ren},
  title = {{Study of the Challenges and Ways of Improvement of International Health Regulations -based on regulations related to cooperation between Contracting States}},
  journal = {Journal of Innovation and Development},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.54097/jid.v2i1.5116},
}
Figure