Study of single and multidigit activation in monkey somatosensory cortex using voltage-sensitive dye imaging

Anna Wang Roe, Jeremy E. Winberry, Robert M. FriedmanNeurophotonics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that voltage-sensitive dye (VSD) imaging is a powerful tool for studying the somatosensory cortex in nonhuman primates, revealing detailed spatial and temporal patterns of neural activity during tactile stimulation. The study shows VSD can map digit representations, uncover interactions between digit inputs, and even detect motion selectivity, opening new avenues for understanding tactile processing and designing advanced prosthetics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how the brain integrates sensory information from multiple parts of the body, especially the hand, is crucial for fields ranging from neuroscience to robotics and prosthetics. While previous studies have mapped the somatosensory cortex using electrophysiology and intrinsic signal optical imaging (OIS), these methods have limitations. Electrophysiology offers high temporal but low spatial resolution, and OIS, while better spatially, can be slower and less sensitive to subtle neural dynamics. There was a need for a technique that could capture both the spatial organization and the rapid temporal changes in neural activity across the somatosensory cortex, particularly in primates, to understand complex tactile behaviors like grasping and manipulation. This paper addresses this gap by applying VSD imaging, a technique known for its high spatial and temporal resolution, to the primate somatosensory cortex for the first time to study single and multidigit tactile processing.

Methods

The researchers employed voltage-sensitive dye (VSD) imaging as their primary technique. VSDs are fluorescent molecules that change their fluorescence intensity in response to changes in membrane potential, effectively acting as optical reporters of neural activity.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • VSD Staining: Specialized VSDs (RH-1691, 1692, or 1838) were applied to the exposed somatosensory cortex of anesthetized macaque and squirrel monkeys. This involved careful procedures to ensure adequate staining while minimizing light exposure to prevent dye bleaching.
  • High-Speed Imaging: A CCD camera capable of acquiring frames at 100 Hz was used to capture the rapid changes in VSD fluorescence. This temporal resolution allowed for the tracking of neural activity with millisecond precision.
  • Tactile Stimulation Paradigms:
    • Single Digit Stimulation: Simple tactile indentations were applied to individual digits to map their topographic representation in the somatosensory cortex.
  • Tactile Funneling: A paradigm involving stimulation of two adjacent digits was used to investigate how the brain integrates inputs from multiple digits and to probe for inhibitory interactions.
  • Tactile Apparent Motion: Sequential stimulation of multiple digits was employed to investigate motion selectivity in the somatosensory cortex, mimicking the perception of movement across the skin.
  • Comparison with Intrinsic Signal Optical Imaging (OIS): The study frequently compared VSD results with OIS data from the same or similar experiments. OIS, which measures changes in light reflectance due to blood flow and metabolic activity, provided a complementary view of cortical responses. This comparison helped validate the VSD findings and highlight the unique insights VSD offered.
  • Image Processing: Standard image processing techniques, including spatial filtering and region of interest (ROI) analysis, were used to analyze the VSD fluorescence data.

The novelty lies in the application of VSD imaging to the primate somatosensory cortex for these specific tactile stimulation paradigms, allowing for a more detailed examination of dynamic neural interactions than previously possible with OIS or electrophysiology alone.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized direct experimental data collected from anesthetized macaque and squirrel monkeys.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • VSD Imaging is a Powerful Tool for Primate Somatosensory Cortex: The study definitively shows that VSD imaging is a viable and highly informative technique for mapping somatosensory cortex in nonhuman primates, offering both high spatial and temporal resolution.
  • Confirmation of Digit Topography: VSD imaging successfully replicated known topographic maps of digit representations in the somatosensory cortex (areas 3b, 1, and 2), consistent with previous electrophysiological and OIS studies. This validates VSD as a reliable mapping tool.
  • Revealing Subthreshold Interactions: In tactile funneling paradigms, VSD imaging revealed subthreshold influences that were not as apparent with OIS. Specifically, VSD detected an enhancement of signal when two digits were stimulated together, suggesting the detection of inhibitory influences that modulate overall neural excitability. This contrasts with OIS, which showed signal suppression.
  • Evidence for Motion Selectivity: The study provided the first evidence using VSD imaging for motion-selective responses in the primate somatosensory cortex. Areas 1 and 3b showed a preferential response to apparent motion stimuli over static tactile stimuli, with area 1 exhibiting a potential directionally selective preference.
  • Species Differences in VSD Dynamics: The paper noted that VSD signal timecourses in monkeys appear to be slower and more spatially confined than those observed in rodents, suggesting potential differences in cortical circuitry or the balance of spiking versus subthreshold activity.

Key Results

  • Spatial Mapping: VSD imaging successfully mapped the topographic organization of digit representations in both macaque and squirrel monkey somatosensory cortex, with activation patterns closely matching those from OIS.
  • Temporal Dynamics: VSD signals rose rapidly (within 25-40 ms post-stimulus onset), peaked within 10-20 ms, and remained elevated for 100-300 ms, with dF/F signal sizes in the 0.01% to 0.1% range.
  • Tactile Funneling: In response to dual-digit stimulation, VSD showed an increase in signal at the stimulated digit's representation, interpreted as detecting subthreshold inhibitory influences, while OIS showed a reduction.
  • Motion Selectivity: Apparent motion stimuli elicited stronger responses than static stimuli in both areas 3b and 1. Area 1 showed a more pronounced response to "toward digit" motion compared to "away from digit" motion, suggesting directional selectivity.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Anesthetized Subjects: The study was conducted on anesthetized monkeys. The authors acknowledge that future studies should be performed in awake, behaving monkeys to better understand the neural basis of tactile perception and manual behavior.
  • Limited Field of View: In some macaque experiments, the field of view for VSD imaging was limited, preventing a full evaluation of the extent of similarity with OIS.
  • Standard Error in Funneling: The standard error measurements for OIS and VSD time courses in the tactile funneling experiment were relatively large, potentially due to the difficulty in synchronizing with heart rate and respiration.

Future Work:

  • Awake Behaving Monkeys: The primary recommendation is to extend these VSD studies to awake monkeys to investigate multidigit integration during complex behaviors like grasping.
  • Further Motion Selectivity Studies: More research is needed to confirm and characterize the directional selectivity observed in area 1 for motion stimuli and to explore its functional significance.
  • Investigating Inhibitory Mechanisms: The VSD findings on subthreshold influences in tactile funneling warrant further investigation to fully elucidate the underlying inhibitory neural circuits.
  • Developing VSD for Grasp Behavior: The authors are optimistic about the potential of VSD imaging to unravel the cortical mechanisms underlying multidigit integration during various types of grasp behavior in primates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Toward the goal of understanding cutaneous sensory integration during manual behavior, we used voltage-sensitive dye (VSD) imaging to study the organization and dynamics of anesthetized monkey primary somatosensory cortex (SI) in response to single and multidigit tactile stimulation. We find that in both macaque and squirrel monkey SI, VSD reveals clear focal digit topography consistent with previous electrophysiological and intrinsic signal imaging studies. VSD also reveals interactions in SI in response to multidigit stimulation. With a tactile funneling paradigm in areas 3b and 1 in squirrel monkeys, VSD reveals two-digit induction of subthreshhold influences, consistent with lateral intracortical inhibition. In response to tactile apparent motion stimuli, VSD reveals preferential response to motion stimuli over static tactile stimuli in both areas 1 and 3b. Comparison of the response at different digit locations to "toward digit" stimuli suggests the presence of direction-selective response in area 1; however, further study is needed. These exciting results indicate that VSD constitutes a powerful tool for studying somatosensory cortical processing in nonhuman primates and should be further developed for future somatosensory studies in awake behaving monkeys.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{roe2017study,
  author = {Anna Wang Roe and Jeremy E. Winberry and Robert M. Friedman},
  title = {{Study of single and multidigit activation in monkey somatosensory cortex using voltage-sensitive dye imaging}},
  booktitle = {Neurophotonics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1117/1.nph.4.3.031219},
}
Figure