TL;DR
This study uses the SWAT model to analyze non-point source pollution (total nitrogen and phosphorus) in China's Ashe River Basin, linking it to land-use changes over three decades. The findings highlight increasing pollution loads, particularly in the middle and lower reaches, driven by urbanization and agricultural intensification, offering a crucial reference for watershed management.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Ashe River Basin, a significant water source in Northeast China, faces severe pollution challenges, yet lacks specific studies on how land-use changes impact non-point source pollution. Non-point source pollution, stemming from diffuse sources like agricultural runoff and urban discharge, is notoriously difficult to monitor and control due to its complex spatial and temporal dynamics, intricately linked to human activities and environmental factors. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by simulating the Ashe River Basin's hydrological processes and water quality under different land-use scenarios to understand pollution trends and identify key drivers.
Methods
The researchers employed the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), a widely recognized watershed-scale ecohydrological model, to simulate the Ashe River Basin. SWAT allows for the integration of various spatial and attribute data to model hydrological cycles and pollutant transport. The study focused on analyzing hydrological processes and the temporal and spatial distribution of total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP). Model validation was performed using the coefficient of determination (R²) and the Nash–Sutcliffe simulation efficiency coefficient (NS), with SWAT-CUP used for calibration. Land-use changes were analyzed across three periods: 2000, 2010, and 2020, using land-use dynamic degree and land-use transfer matrices to quantify shifts in land cover.
Datasets
The study utilized several datasets:
- DEM (Digital Elevation Model): SRTMDEMUTM 90M
- Land Use Maps: 1 km Grid data for 2000, 2010, and 2020.
- Soil Type Maps: HWSD China Soil data.
- Watershed Map: Derived from Google Earth.
- Meteorological Data: Daily and monthly data from the National Weather Science Data Center (2010-2020).
- Measured Runoff Data: Daily scale data from Harbin Acheng District Hydrology Station (2010-2020).
- Measured Nitrogen and Phosphorus Data: Monthly scale data from Harbin City Environmental Monitoring Center (2015-2020).
Key Insights and Ideas
- SWAT's Applicability: The SWAT model proved to be a robust tool for simulating hydrological processes and water quality in the Ashe River Basin, with R² and NS values consistently above 0.75 for runoff, total nitrogen, and total phosphorus. This validates its use for similar watershed studies.
- Land Use as a Driver: While annual runoff showed a slight increasing trend, it was found to be less sensitive to land-use changes and more influenced by weather patterns like precipitation. In contrast, land-use changes, particularly the increase in urban areas and intensification of agriculture, were identified as significant drivers of rising total nitrogen and phosphorus loads.
- Pollution Hotspots: The middle and lower reaches of the Ashe River Basin, especially near the main stream, emerged as the most polluted areas. This is attributed to the cumulative effect of pollutants from upstream areas and increased fertilizer application due to expanding cultivated land.
- Urbanization's Impact: The study observed a steady increase in urban land use, which is closely linked to the growing pollution loads, suggesting that urban expansion and associated waste management are critical factors.
- Nitrogen vs. Phosphorus Trends: Total nitrogen showed a consistent upward trend throughout the study period, while total phosphorus exhibited more moderate changes between 2000 and 2010, with a notable increase in 2020.
Key Results
- Model Performance: The SWAT model demonstrated good applicability, with R² and NS values for runoff simulation exceeding 0.79 during calibration and validation. For total nitrogen and total phosphorus, R² and NS values were also above 0.75.
- Runoff Trends: Annual runoff showed a gradual increase from 2015 to 2020, but land-use changes had minimal impact on this trend. Monthly runoff varied with rainfall, peaking from June to September.
- Nitrogen and Phosphorus Loads:
- Total Nitrogen: The annual load of total nitrogen generally increased from 2015 to 2020, reaching a peak of 1962.39 t in 2020. Monthly analysis showed a peak in months 6 and 8. The average monthly total nitrogen load increased from 96.71 t in 2000 to 107.59 t in 2020.
- Total Phosphorus: The annual load of total phosphorus also showed an increasing trend, with a maximum of 360 t in 2020. Monthly analysis indicated a correlation with rainfall, peaking at 58.91 t in September. The average monthly total phosphorus load increased from 16.63 t in 2000 to 20.97 t in 2020.
- Spatial Distribution: Pollution hotspots for both nitrogen and phosphorus were concentrated in the middle and lower reaches of the watershed, particularly in sub-basins 5, 6, 9, 11, 17, and 22.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Availability: The study acknowledges limitations due to the availability of data, particularly the lack of sediment data and high-precision remote sensing maps, which could have further enhanced the model's accuracy and analysis.
- Temporal Resolution: The analysis was conducted on a decadal basis for land-use changes. The authors suggest that annual land-use change analysis would provide a more granular understanding of its impact.
- Model Scope: Sediment transport modeling was not possible due to data limitations.
- Future Research: The authors propose future work to include more detailed, year-by-year land-use change analysis, investigate the transition from quantity to quality of water resources, and improve pollutant source analysis models for a better understanding of the ecosystem. They also emphasize the need for strategic placement of sewage treatment plants to mitigate pollution.
Summary updated